Madonna: The Discography Rate - COMPLETE | Page 192 | The Popjustice Forum

Madonna: The Discography Rate - COMPLETE

Discussion in 'Charts, rates etc' started by RJF, Apr 19, 2020.

  1. "Eliminate 2Night"
     
    MilesAngel likes this.
  2. R27

    R27

    Two more sub-6 scores gone. I had originally given I Fucked Up a 7, but after listening to it again I downgraded it to a 5. As mentioned by others, it's interesting seeing Madonna strike a more apologetic stance; however, I find the song is undermined by its grating melody.
     
    Maki likes this.
  3. RJF

    RJF

    194
    [​IMG]
    SCORE: 6.012


    2015 PLACEMENT: 171 of 210 (5.961)
    HIGHEST SCORE: 10 x 1 (@torontodj)
    LOWEST SCORE: 1 x 1 (@Daniel_O)
    MY SCORE: 6/10

    And we break into the 6/10 bracket... maybe with not as much fanfare as we could, but still. We're getting through them. MDNA scores a hat-trick tonight with three losses in a row. I've actually always had a soft spot for this one and thought it was one of the album's highlights. It's loaded with fun hooks, Madonna sounds... well, she sounds pitched up for one, but she also sounds like she's having fun, which is a turn up for the books considering a lot of the time on the album she sounds like she recorded her vocals chained to a radiator. I also enjoy the 60s psychedelia production; it sounds like something the Beatles would have written on LSD. I particularly enjoy the outro where she's daring all the saints to come and purify her. Don't they know Madonna has a reservation? WHADDYA MEAN IT'S NOT IN THE COMPUTER?! It's a bit of a silly song overall but it also doesn't make me feel like my soul is dying, which is something parts of its parent album fails at. So a cute 6/10 position feels appropriate, even with it veering slightly into Madonna Lyric Bingo at certain points.

    The song was performed in the penultimate act of the MDNA Tour in a performance you might have already seen since it leads into "Cyber-Raga" and was therefore provided during that elimination. Madonna is mostly stationary with a decorative guitar, but if nothing it's another look at how amazing the MDNA stage was. Maybe her most technically impressive setup, although I might be forgetting some of the intricacies of the Rebel Heart stage when saying that.


     
  4. RJF

    RJF

  5. I'm a Sinner is a little guilty pleasure fun bop. Gone too soon
     
  6. So Madame X and Girl Gone Wild.
     
    Maki, Verandi and Pop Life like this.
  7. RJF

    RJF

    For anyone curious, we've actually hit 6/10 songs faster than the original rate. It took 43 songs to get there in 2015, while it's only taken 33 here.
     

  8. Yeah, but Some Girls is a

    (Looks at scores)

    3/10 at best
    [​IMG]
     
    phoenix123 and Cutlery like this.
  9. [​IMG]
     
  10. Bloody hell, you guys didn’t come to play did you?
     
  11. Some Girls is a guilty please of mine and once I realized the backing vocals apparently had lyrics like "got their fuck me porn star heels on" and "Like a virgin, sweet and sticky keen" it was just impossible to not stan. I never bothered that much about the mix, it makes the whole thing sound like a monstrous instrumental. Total opposite of "I'm Addicted" which you just realize she's actually singing when "All of the letters push to the the front of my mouth and saying your name is somewhere between a prayer and a shout!"

    I Fucked Up is cute, too bad it was buried on the "Deluxe" version (but do people really care about what's standard and what's a deluxe post... 2009? MDNA is just a hard listen, yeah).

    I'm a sinner exists but it's also one of the points that show the record had some... interesting ideas behind it somewhere. I like the production being a little left-field even if it's basic. Too bad that, just like most of the record, it is just forgettable.
     
    Maki and sfmartin like this.
  12. Currently bopping to this deserving cull of "MDNA".

    [​IMG]
     
  13. The leaderboard is looking like an accurate depiction of the worst Madonna songs ever...

    I Fucked Up and Spanish Lesson sweeties, I'm so sorry!
     
  14. This MDNA cull nourishes me.
     
    Maki and Phonetics Girl like this.
  15. To me, Beautiful Stranger, Amazing and I'm a Sinner make up a holy trinity of '60s influenced pop.
     
    BreatheBox, Maki, rav4boy and 4 others like this.
  16. I'm a Sinner, like nearly all of the Solveig tracks, suffers in that it hasn't aged well for me. Several of my early MDNA favorites feel redundant now. Then again I have some choice opinions where that came from!!

    Wait, this is Orbit isn't it. LOL
     
    rav4boy likes this.
  17. Gay Male is fine. It has a few components I like, and it's a well structured song (I love the cheer hook tbh). The video and single cover are both fantastic. It's just not in the same realm as any of her lead singles. It's a Super Bowl promo single.
     
    Mvnl likes this.
  18. RJF

    RJF

    For the sake of promoting conversation and for clarity, here's what is left on MDNA after tonight. When we're further into eliminations, the nightly leaderboard will also be accompanied with a list of what songs are left, but I'm not going to do that just yet for obvious reasons as we've barely just begun.

    1. Girl Gone Wild
    2. Gang Bang
    3. I'm Addicted
    8. I Don't Give A (Feat. Nick Minaj)
    10. Love Spent
    11. Masterpiece
    12. Falling Free
    13. Beautiful Killer​

    Personally, I think that this is a pretty solid core that's been chiselled out. I am a little surprised that "I Don't Give A" is still here, purely because it's kind of in between the capital-B Basic bops and more well constructed ballads in terms of genre and energy and I didn't think it was that popular. Everything else is more or less in line with what I expected.
     
  19. "Girl Gone Wild," "I Don't Give A" (?!) and "Masterpiece" were some of my lowest scores in the rate so they can all go yesterday!
     
  20. LTG

    LTG

    MDNA needed to lose a few. Not I Fucked Up though.
     
    Phonetics Girl likes this.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.