Madonna: The Discography Rate - COMPLETE | Page 604 | The Popjustice Forum

Madonna: The Discography Rate - COMPLETE

Discussion in 'Charts, rates etc' started by RJF, Apr 19, 2020.

  1. She was my #2 behind Dua but had like a third of my top 100. I miss this thread like most days.
     
    RJF likes this.
  2. I come back to this thread often to reminisce, re-read write-ups...etc. It cheers me up actually. I'm stuck on this hamster wheel where, even though I nearly voted for it as my 11, Frozen winning just feels...wrong .....but still wonderful? I have this weird irrational desire for the winner to be Like a Prayer or Vogue or something that's somehow more representative of her discography as a whole (if there's even such a thing?!) even though I enjoy Frozen more...and then I realize that it's just an embarrassment of riches she's gifted the world ....and that it's 5am, I can't sleep or shut-off my ocd brain and that I have to work in 3 hrs... but THE MADONNA RATE!!!!
     
  3. This rate was the highlight of the fuckery that was (and still is) 2020.

    Another testament to the power of this rate.

    itswhatweneeded.gif
     
  4. RJF

    RJF

    NN even coming back to this thread is weird at the moment. Did I leave a piece of myself in it? Mess.
     
  5. Uno

    Uno

    Don't mean to bump this, but I'm just now catching up. Deeper & Deeper getting #7 is a pleasant surprise - it's my favorite Madonna song. Like A Prayer not winning is shocking.

    My roommate would have y'all heads for putting Inside of Me at #95 - I'll be sure to keep the results away from him!
     
  6. I was reading over some of my favourite write ups & commentary this morning, and I forgot this is the first post below Sky Fits Heaven's elimination featuring @dodoriazarbon's achingly gorgeous reflection on the song:
    The fucking whiplash. You're a whore!
    [​IMG]
     
    Remorque, GimmeWork, RJF and 5 others like this.
  7. LTG

    LTG

    [​IMG]
     
    Last edited: Jan 2, 2021
  8. RJF

    RJF

    Speaking of this rate in the poll thread made me realise I actually never made the spreadsheet public so y'all could point out all the incorrect scores I input. Maybe one of the more Excel savvy amongst us can even pull some interesting data out of it. Is there still interest for that or will I not bother?
     
    Push, dirtypony, joe_alouder and 13 others like this.
  9. As someone who spent hours and hours looking at the spreadsheet for my rate and grasped for stats...

    [​IMG]

    I'm definitely interested.
     
    Remorque and Chezam like this.
  10. RJF

    RJF

    Well, here it is! All the data, and how the leaderboard changed with every ten votes. Everyone's commentary is also in there. Thank you again for participating! I think it took a lot of me creatively (and I haven't listened to Madonna since it finished nn) but it was a lot of fun, and I think I did it justice in the end.

     
  11. Thanks! Here's the "most compatible" thing for anyone that's interested. If you want to Ctrl+F yourself, note that I had to remove some characters from the usernames (spaces, dots, ', ’ and &), so search for your username without those symbols. The number next to each name is the strength of compatibility: the closer to 1000, the more compatible.
    EDIT: There was an error at first, sorry everyone. It's been fixed now though. Kinda embarrassed at first but then I remembered there were people that gave Like a Prayer a <9 score!
    EDIT 2: So... there was another error ddd. But NOW it's all ok! Sorry to Aester, BleuNoir, BreatheBox, Filippa, HEARTCORE, Michael17, Mvnl, funkyg and unnameable for the missing spaces in your lines! All others are the same (I tripled checked ddd).

    ABoysGot2Suffer4Fashion is most compatible with MilesAngel (581), followed by unnameable (543).
    Aester is most compatible with R27 (498), followed by Lila (492).
    AllGagaLike is most compatible with RetroPhysical (598), followed by letuinmybackdoor (586).
    AnaRaquel is most compatible with m_dimitrov (543), followed by _2014 (518).
    Andreas is most compatible with torontodj (584), followed by phoenix123 (564).
    AndrewL is most compatible with Mjg0806 (636), followed by Raichu (600).
    AndyFrench is most compatible with MirwaisAhmadzaï (714), followed by muddleddreams (707).
    Angeleyes is most compatible with MiklC (630), followed by Mjg0806 (629).
    AshtrayHeart is most compatible with RetroPhysical (668), followed by Mjg0806 (632).
    BESTFICTION is most compatible with eliminathan (766), followed by SloMover (655).
    BTG is most compatible with aux (751), followed by Endothelium (681).
    Babyface is most compatible with SloMover (694), followed by Endothelium (682).
    Babylon is most compatible with strangekin (763), followed by joe_alouder (750).
    BangersBops is most compatible with SloMover (703), followed by TheChoirgirlHotel (696).
    BeautifulChild2 is most compatible with CandyPerfumeGirl (670), followed by nikkysan (669).
    BleuNoir is most compatible with Andreas (505), followed by discoteca (498).
    BreatheBox is most compatible with Remorque (480), followed by phoenix123 (459).
    Butterfly is most compatible with soratami (595), followed by FrozenNight (565).
    CandyPerfumeGirl is most compatible with strangekin (732), followed by Nohaybanda (722).
    CasperFan is most compatible with nanafan (630), followed by WoW73 (521).
    Chezam is most compatible with Nohaybanda (643), followed by LucyHoneychurch (643).
    Coochi is most compatible with Jimmyandroid (600), followed by clowezra (556).
    CrispX is most compatible with SloMover (619), followed by Nohaybanda (591).
    Cutlery is most compatible with Fortune (673), followed by RJF (673).
    DJHazey is most compatible with MilesAngel (573), followed by HurricaneDrunk (545).
    DangerousMaknae is most compatible with Angeleyes (580), followed by SloMover (578).
    Daniel_O is most compatible with Markus1981 (633), followed by Maki (583).
    DigitalGhost is most compatible with NightmareBoy (724), followed by Nohaybanda (687).
    DinahLee is most compatible with SloMover (673), followed by RetroPhysical (656).
    Doenjang is most compatible with Fortune (752), followed by Robsolete (747).
    DominoDancing is most compatible with Nohaybanda (652), followed by Robsolete (630).
    Dreampopboy is most compatible with muddleddreams (714), followed by Nohaybanda (713).
    Drew is most compatible with Mjg0806 (639), followed by Joe (627).
    Endothelium is most compatible with RetroPhysical (774), followed by LTG (742).
    EpicChocolat is most compatible with nanafan (563), followed by paullypaul (530).
    Euphoria is most compatible with theelusivechanteuse (525), followed by Nohaybanda (521).
    Filippa is most compatible with Jimmyandroid (472), followed by Coochi (455).
    Fortune is most compatible with RJF (839), followed by joe_alouder (838).
    FridayNight is most compatible with Babylon (665), followed by LTG (662).
    FrozenNight is most compatible with SloMover (695), followed by Babylon (693).
    Fuchsia is most compatible with RetroPhysical (658), followed by HurricaneDrunk (643).
    FutureLover is most compatible with Dreampopboy (676), followed by Fortune (675).
    GimmeWork is most compatible with strangekin (593), followed by TheChoirgirlHotel (585).
    HEARTCORE is most compatible with MrBlonde (501), followed by sexercise (498).
    HollySomething is most compatible with MiklC (692), followed by K94 (634).
    HurricaneDrunk is most compatible with Fuchsia (643), followed by sfmartin (641).
    JMRGBY is most compatible with muddleddreams (604), followed by RetroPhysical (587).
    Jimmyandroid is most compatible with Coochi (600), followed by phoenix123 (569).
    Joe is most compatible with beyoncésweave (737), followed by SloMover (736).
    JonBcn is most compatible with DigitalGhost (590), followed by PopLife (576).
    Jonathan27 is most compatible with LTG (746), followed by Babylon (721).
    Jwentz is most compatible with strangekin (762), followed by SloMover (741).
    K94 is most compatible with SloMover (750), followed by RetroPhysical (718).
    KingBruno is most compatible with SloMover (686), followed by aaronhansome (665).
    LTG is most compatible with Fortune (793), followed by joe_alouder (786).
    Lila is most compatible with RetroPhysical (705), followed by SloMover (702).
    LucyHoneychurch is most compatible with Mister_G (704), followed by muddleddreams (676).
    M24 is most compatible with Rogue (696), followed by Mjg0806 (629).
    Maki is most compatible with Daniel_O (583), followed by eliminathan (559).
    Markus1981 is most compatible with MiklC (634), followed by Daniel_O (633).
    Michael17 is most compatible with KingBruno (498), followed by FrozenNight (498).
    MiklC is most compatible with Robsolete (818), followed by Mjg0806 (700).
    MilesAngel is most compatible with Touchofmyhand (622), followed by m_dimitrov (615).
    MirwaisAhmadzaï is most compatible with Suburbia (781), followed by RetroPhysical (756).
    MissLange is most compatible with Rogue (736), followed by Mjg0806 (726).
    Mister_G is most compatible with LucyHoneychurch (704), followed by RetroPhysical (676).
    Mjg0806 is most compatible with Rogue (755), followed by MissLange (726).
    Modeblock is most compatible with clowezra (693), followed by ufint (649).
    MrBlonde is most compatible with RetroPhysical (702), followed by SloMover (701).
    MrMannacroix is most compatible with SloMover (686), followed by K94 (673).
    MusicIsDeath is most compatible with RetroPhysical (699), followed by Babyface (659).
    Mvnl is most compatible with Markus1981 (520), followed by Drew (449).
    NightmareBoy is most compatible with DigitalGhost (724), followed by PopLife (651).
    Nohaybanda is most compatible with SloMover (759), followed by strangekin (758).
    OSHi is most compatible with TheChoirgirlHotel (593), followed by CandyPerfumeGirl (582).
    PNutButter is most compatible with joeee (711), followed by muddleddreams (706).
    PhoneticsBoy is most compatible with Nohaybanda (516), followed by SailOn (494).
    PopLife is most compatible with NightmareBoy (651), followed by Modeblock (595).
    Push is most compatible with _1991 (654), followed by TheChoirgirlHotel (617).
    R27 is most compatible with nametag (691), followed by Nohaybanda (690).
    RJF is most compatible with Fortune (839), followed by joe_alouder (784).
    Raichu is most compatible with muddleddreams (735), followed by Mjg0806 (719).
    RainOnFire is most compatible with joe_alouder (681), followed by Fortune (671).
    Ramalama is most compatible with Fortune (686), followed by LTG (674).
    Remorque is most compatible with Mjg0806 (657), followed by strangekin (616).
    Remyky22 is most compatible with FutureLover (553), followed by RetroPhysical (546).
    RetroPhysical is most compatible with Fortune (787), followed by SloMover (783).
    Robsolete is most compatible with MiklC (818), followed by Doenjang (747).
    Rogue is most compatible with Mjg0806 (755), followed by MissLange (736).
    SailOn is most compatible with Nohaybanda (741), followed by SloMover (720).
    Sideout is most compatible with MiklC (634), followed by BTG (620).
    Skyline is most compatible with nametag (636), followed by R27 (634).
    Sleepycat is most compatible with Nohaybanda (697), followed by SailOn (684).
    SloMover is most compatible with RetroPhysical (783), followed by Fortune (779).
    Sprockrooster is most compatible with TrueBeliever (402), followed by gezza76 (401).
    Suburbia is most compatible with MirwaisAhmadzaï (781), followed by muddleddreams (720).
    Syzygyz is most compatible with joe_alouder (654), followed by strangekin (652).
    TheChoirgirlHotel is most compatible with Mjg0806 (696), followed by BangersBops (696).
    Tigerlily is most compatible with RetroPhysical (687), followed by nikkysan (671).
    Touchofmyhand is most compatible with SloMover (758), followed by RetroPhysical (735).
    Trinu30 is most compatible with Joe (708), followed by MissLange (696).
    TrueBeliever is most compatible with MilesAngel (601), followed by Markus1981 (590).
    UpDownSuite is most compatible with Mjg0806 (662), followed by TheChoirgirlHotel (598).
    Vasilios is most compatible with Mjg0806 (551), followed by Robsolete (539).
    Verandi is most compatible with Trinu30 (503), followed by sfmartin (503).
    VeryPSB is most compatible with Modeblock (633), followed by SloMover (625).
    Weslicious is most compatible with RetroPhysical (604), followed by Fortune (580).
    WoW73 is most compatible with tommylander (562), followed by Sideout (559).
    Xanax is most compatible with strangekin (665), followed by TheChoirgirlHotel (649).
    Zdarlight is most compatible with RetroPhysical (667), followed by SloMover (665).
    _1991 is most compatible with SloMover (762), followed by Nohaybanda (727).
    _2014 is most compatible with Joe (612), followed by Nohaybanda (611).
    aaronhansome is most compatible with MirwaisAhmadzaï (724), followed by Doenjang (718).
    acl is most compatible with Fortune (741), followed by joe_alouder (695).
    aux is most compatible with BTG (751), followed by Endothelium (666).
    beyoncésweave is most compatible with Joe (737), followed by strangekin (729).
    cheida is most compatible with Raichu (633), followed by Trinu30 (631).
    citoig is most compatible with strangekin (636), followed by Joe (631).
    clowezra is most compatible with strangekin (708), followed by Nohaybanda (699).
    dancingwithmyself is most compatible with happiestgirl (538), followed by EpicChocolat (518).
    discoteca is most compatible with Raichu (691), followed by RetroPhysical (673).
    djmakemewet is most compatible with japanbonustrack (702), followed by RetroPhysical (691).
    dodoriazarbon is most compatible with joe_alouder (710), followed by Dreampopboy (667).
    dylanaber is most compatible with strangekin (638), followed by SloMover (627).
    eatyourself is most compatible with SloMover (647), followed by TheChoirgirlHotel (613).
    elear is most compatible with AndyFrench (687), followed by RetroPhysical (687).
    eliminathan is most compatible with BESTFICTION (766), followed by RetroPhysical (603).
    evilsin is most compatible with K94 (577), followed by SailOn (558).
    fancygreen is most compatible with Doenjang (657), followed by muddleddreams (611).
    fatyoshi is most compatible with Tigerlily (587), followed by Doenjang (582).
    funkyg is most compatible with Mjg0806 (502), followed by Joe (493).
    gezza76 is most compatible with JonBcn (513), followed by happiestgirl (508).
    godspeed is most compatible with muddleddreams (623), followed by Dreampopboy (601).
    happiestgirl is most compatible with Push (594), followed by K94 (572).
    japanbonustrack is most compatible with SloMover (714), followed by joe_alouder (708).
    joe_alouder is most compatible with Fortune (838), followed by muddleddreams (799).
    joeee is most compatible with PNutButter (711), followed by RetroPhysical (707).
    letuinmybackdoor is most compatible with Mjg0806 (662), followed by Joe (638).
    m_dimitrov is most compatible with _1991 (688), followed by Rogue (670).
    madgemad is most compatible with nametag (545), followed by AshtrayHeart (544).
    matthew is most compatible with joe_alouder (652), followed by RJF (633).
    maverick_79 is most compatible with Endothelium (666), followed by Nohaybanda (660).
    muddleddreams is most compatible with joe_alouder (799), followed by Fortune (797).
    nametag is most compatible with Nohaybanda (721), followed by Raichu (712).
    nanafan is most compatible with CasperFan (630), followed by EpicChocolat (563).
    nikkysan is most compatible with RetroPhysical (777), followed by Fortune (746).
    paperboyfriendd is most compatible with Doenjang (637), followed by Rogue (624).
    paullypaul is most compatible with phoenix123 (545), followed by EpicChocolat (530).
    phoenix123 is most compatible with NightmareBoy (574), followed by Jimmyandroid (569).
    rav4boy is most compatible with Mjg0806 (549), followed by Raichu (546).
    rdp is most compatible with Doenjang (636), followed by Dreampopboy (613).
    relby is most compatible with PNutButter (635), followed by Raichu (619).
    scottdisick94 is most compatible with Rogue (585), followed by Doenjang (569).
    sexercise is most compatible with MissLange (669), followed by K94 (650).
    sfmartin is most compatible with SloMover (651), followed by HurricaneDrunk (641).
    soratami is most compatible with Touchofmyhand (641), followed by SloMover (626).
    strangekin is most compatible with Babylon (763), followed by Jwentz (762).
    theelusivechanteuse is most compatible with Xanax (634), followed by TheChoirgirlHotel (633).
    tom71 is most compatible with muddleddreams (648), followed by Mjg0806 (648).
    tommylander is most compatible with Mjg0806 (647), followed by WoW73 (562).
    torontodj is most compatible with Raichu (643), followed by joeee (625).
    tylerc904 is most compatible with sfmartin (549), followed by Joe (546).
    ufint is most compatible with strangekin (655), followed by clowezra (654).
    unnameable is most compatible with ABoysGot2Suffer4Fashion (543), followed by gezza76 (476).
    wintersleep is most compatible with Mjg0806 (614), followed by FutureLover (579).
     
    Last edited: Jan 9, 2021
  12. Hello.

    I've finally caught up with the rate and this is simply iconic. There will never be another rate like that as well as there will never be another @RJF. Standing ovation.
    [​IMG]
     
    GimmeWork, dirtypony, Raichu and 6 others like this.
  13. Taste! @K94 @Mikl C
     
    K94 likes this.
  14. Every so often I think about how Thief Of Hearts didn’t get a write up - and nobody cared.
     
  15. [​IMG]
    @beyoncésweave
     
  16. @RJF could you post the rankings by album on the 1st page as well?
     
    GimmeWork, RJF and Maki like this.
  17. Mjg0806 and Raichu like this.
  18. RJF

    RJF

    Done!
     
  19. Me being highly compatible with @RainOnFire and @RJF? I'll take the company of icons
     
    RJF, Pop Life, beyoncésweave and 4 others like this.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.