I’m like that as well. I don’t know what it is but it feels odd to me when she remembers songs from her catalogue even if they’re from only a few years ago, and I love it when she does.
Last year, when she remembered I'll Remember and This Used To Be My Playground enough to say they were too dreamy and laid-back for her "rawwwr rgggghrrr rrrRRRRrrrr" shows, my heart skipped a beat. And then when she actually said she'd consider Rescue Me for the tour and told the interviewer "your love has given me hope" I was like "OH YOU REMEMBER THESE THINGS, I SEE YOU."
When you think about your life, you've gone through thousands of days and you can't remember them all. Some of them are just lost. I wonder if she still remembers the day she put down vocals for Vogue or Frozen or Live To Tell, or if any of them have become some of those "lost days." I'm sure she can give you a to-the-minute rundown of what happened the day she recorded Candy Shop, but Easy Ride?