Natalia Kills Discography Rate | Page 5 | The Popjustice Forum

Natalia Kills Discography Rate

Discussion in 'Charts, rates etc' started by RMK, Aug 26, 2017.

  1. RMK

    RMK

    Sorry for the hiatus of eliminations, they'll be coming in quick now....






























    Especially since things are about to get extremly interesting........



























    34.
    [​IMG]
    Cruel Youth - Diamond Days

    Highest: @Rooneyboy @Weslicious (9)
    Lowest: @GhettoPrincess (4)

    Score: 7.071

    My score: 7.00
    Our first elimination from Cruel Youth, and it was a single. Sad.
    Comments:
    Rooneyboy - the best Cruel Youth recording, shows her vocals off superbly.

    Pecans - The production to Diamond Days is so stunning. It makes for a brilliant closing track, doesn’t it?
     
  2. RMK

    RMK

    33.
    [​IMG]
    Natalia Kills - Zombie
    Highest: @DJHazey (9)
    Lowest: @GhettoPrincess @Hurricane Drunk @Weslicious (6)

    Score: 7.143

    My score: 7.00
    Honestly, I've never understood the love for this song. When I realized this would be the second song leaving Perfectionist I had to double check everything because I've seen nothing but ridiculous praise for this in years past. It's definitely nice enough, but it's nothing worth an 11, or a 10. Glad people here agree!

    Comments:
    Weslicious - I preferred Activate My Heart of the pre-album singles.

    GhettoPrincess - I actually think the vocal effect really takes away from the song which is a shame.
     
  3. Poor Zombie. It was one of the first songs I had ever heard from her and was stunned by what sounded like such a fresh sound at the time. I kind of fell out of love with it and Wonderland and ended up responding to this slightly more after years having not heard it.
     
  4. Yeah I agree with everybody on Zombie. It’s a great song but nowhere near one of her bestt works.

    As for Diamond Days going... eh. It’s a stunner, but comparing it to songs like Mr. Watson, Mirrors and Problem it kind of loses its ground.
     
  5. Fucking Hell, I love "Zombie". (Haven't voted tho, whoops)
     
  6. RMK

    RMK

    Two eliminations from a great album tonight...















































    32.
    [​IMG]
    Natalia Kills - Rabbit Hole

    Highest: @Weslicious @DJHazey (10)
    Lowest: @GhettoPrincess (4)

    Score: 7.214

    My score: 7.5​

    Comments:
    Weslicious - Gwen Stefani meets Peaches teebs.
    Rooneyboy - Another song that reminds me of Gwen Stefani.





































    31.
    [​IMG]
    Natalia Kills - Daddy's Girl

    Highest: @DJHazey (9)
    Lowest: @GhettoPrincess (4)

    Score: 7.286

    My score: 7.5
    Comments:
    Weslicious - Not here for the Hall and Oates sample, but it’s ok.
     
    Pecans and DJHazey like this.
  7. Heaven and Zombie are out already?... What?! But I'm another guilty one who hasn't voted :-0
     
    RMK likes this.
  8. Daddy's Girl should be top 20 at the very least!!

    (I also gave it a 9 btw)
     
    RMK likes this.
  9. Oh dear. Thankfully Natalia isn't on the forum to kill me.
     
    RMK likes this.
  10. Daddy's Girl had to go.
     
  11. RMK

    RMK

    So I messed up number 32, because of a tie. So the actual order is....





    32.
    [​IMG]

    Cruel Youth - I Don't Love You
    Highest: @Pecans (10)
    Lowest: @DJHazey (4)

    Score: 7.214

    My score: 8






    31. Natalia Kills - Rabbit Hole

    30. Natalia Kills - Daddy's Girl



     
    Last edited: Nov 19, 2017
    DJHazey and Pecans like this.
  12. [​IMG]
    Noooooo, I Don't Love You is cold-hearted amazingness.
     
  13. RMK

    RMK

    29.
    [​IMG]

    Natalia Kills - Broke
    Highest: @RMK, @Pecans (10)
    Lowest: @DJHazey, @GhettoPrincess, @Weslicious, @Rooneyboy (6)

    Score: 7.357

    My score: 10​

    Jesus.
    No one hated this song, but you all seemed to deem it average (6) which hurts even more. Yeah, the lyrics are a bit stereotypical, but Natalia knows how to execute them them perfectly. It's a beautiful, beautiful song.​

    Comments:
    Pecans - “Don’t want the memories that echo in my head” is one of my favourite lyrics from Natalia. Broke is such a beautiful ballad and Natalia has proven that she can deliver vulnerability with this song.
     
    DJHazey and Pecans like this.
  14. [​IMG]

    THIS IS WRONG! Justice for Broke.
     
    spicyhot likes this.
  15. RMK

    RMK

    28.
    [​IMG]

    Cruel Youth - Florida Blues
    Highest: @Hurricane Drunk @Pecans (10)
    Lowest: @DJHazey (5)

    Score: 7.429

    My score: 8​

    Comments:
    Pecans - There’s a certain sadness in Florida Blues that just makes it really click with me. It’s a gorgeous track and feels like a real continuation from Natalia’s Trouble music.
     
    DJHazey and Pecans like this.
  16. Not me turning into a bit of a rate villain.
     
    RMK likes this.
  17. RMK

    RMK


    27.

    [​IMG]
    Natalia Kills - Activate My Heart
    Highest: @Pecans (9)
    Lowest: @Hurricane Drunk (6)

    Score: 7.57

    My score: 7​

    Comments:
    Weslicious - Sounds demoish,but I still use.






































    26.
    [​IMG]
    Natalia Kills - Controversy
    Highest: @Pecans (10)
    Lowest: @GhettoPrincess (0)

    Score: 7.58

    My score: 9
    No Natalia song EVER deserves a zero. I'm judging.
    Comments:
    Ghetto Princess - No thanks.
    Rooneyboy - Another mess. (this is factually wrong but I posted it anyway)
    Weslicious - *Drinks KoolAid, whilst 'paying' for McDonalds*[/QUOTE]
     
  18. Yeah, that 0 is a bit questionable but I don't consider Controversy to be essential either.
     
  19. [​IMG]

    Me pretending to listen to these opinions about my zero.
     
    Rooneyboy likes this.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.