Orange Caramel Discography Rate: WINNER | The Popjustice Forum

Orange Caramel Discography Rate: WINNER

Discussion in 'K-pop' started by Deja-Boo, Aug 16, 2017.

  1. [​IMG]

    Orange Caramel is undoubtedly one of the most iconic and recognizable K-pop groups, created as a sub-unit from parent girl group After School's third generation members Raina, Nana and Lizzy. The trio were picked to cover a concept and demographic that After School didn't reach, namely the quirky side of K-pop. But how can you approach something so widely done in a way that not only ensures that you stand out from the pack, but also leaves a mark on the industry, influencing future groups even after you've stopped having comebacks? Well, just turn it on its head and make it your own. Using innovative concepts, unique sources of creative inspiration and a consistent dedication to their craft, the trio became one of the most musically eclectic and artistically acclaimed groups in their genre. That’s Orange Caramel’s identity. But you don't have to take my word for it, just take a look below and see for yourself! And then come join me in celebrating and honoring the girls' legacy. Let's get rating!


    마법소녀 (Magic Girl)
    사랑을 미룰 순 없나요 (Love Does Not Wait)
    아잉♡ (A-ing♡)
    One Love
    아직… (Not Yet...)
    이곳에 서서 ( The Day You Went Away)
    방콕시티 (Bangkok City)
    Shanghai Romance (上海之戀)
    눈을 감아 (Keep Your Eyes Closed)
    어떤가요 (How Are You)
    Funny Hunny
    Bubble Bath
    밀크쉐이크 (Milkshake)
    립스틱 (LIPSTICK)
    클라라의 꿈 (Clara's Dream)
    흰눈 사이로 하이힐 타고 (Dashing Through the Snow In High Heels)
    안아줘요 (Hug Song)
    Cookies, Cream & Mint (クッキークリーム&ミント)
    The Angel's Wink (天使のウィンク)
    Lamu no Love Song (ラムのラブソング)
    My Sweet Devil (やさしい悪魔)
    Red Shoes (赤いくつ)
    Sleeping Forest (眠れる森)
    Sour Grapes (すっぱい葡萄)
    Meteor and Piercing (流星とピアス)
    까탈레나 (Catallena)
    So Sorry
    미친 듯이 울었어 (Cried Uncontrollably)
    아빙아빙 (Abing Abing)
    나처럼 해봐요 (My Copycat)
    강남거리 (Gangnam Avenue)
    Not an Easy Girl (쉬운 여자 아니에요)

    Goobye PMS (굿바이 PMS)

    1 마법소녀 (Magic Girl)
    2 사랑을 미룰 순 없나요 (Love Does Not Wait)
    3 아잉♡ (A-ing ♡)
    4 One Love
    5 아직… (Not Yet...)
    6 이곳에 서서 (The Day You Went Away)
    7 방콕시티 (Bangkok City)
    8 Shanghai Romance (上海之戀)
    9 눈을 감아 (Keep Your Eyes Closed)
    10 어떤가요 (How Are You)
    11 Funny Hunny
    12 Bubble Bath
    13 밀크쉐이크 (Milkshake)
    14 립스틱 (LIPSTICK)
    15 Superwoman
    16 클라라의 꿈 (Clara's Dream)
    17 흰눈 사이로 하이힐 타고 (Dashing Through the Snow In High Heels)
    18 안아줘요 (Hug Song)
    19 Cookies, Cream & Mint (クッキークリーム&ミント)
    20 The Angel's Wink (天使のウィンク)
    21 Lamu no Love Song (ラムのラブソング)
    22 My Sweet Devil (やさしい悪魔)
    23 Red Shoes (赤いくつ)
    24 Sleeping Forest (眠れる森)
    25 Sour Grapes (すっぱい葡萄)
    26 Meteor and Piercing (流星とピアス)
    27 까탈레나 (Catallena)
    28 So Sorry
    29 미친 듯이 울었어 (Cried Uncontrollably)
    30 아빙아빙 (Abing Abing)
    31 나처럼 해봐요 (My Copycat)
    32 강남거리 (Gangnam Avenue)
    33 Tonight
    34 Not an Easy Girl (쉬운 여자 아니에요)
    35 Goobye PMS (굿바이 PMS)

    As usual, give each track a score from 0 to 10 (decimals allowed), with your personal winner receiving the coveted 11/10. Commentary is optional but encouraged, and I'd be grateful if y'all could at least write something about your 11. Give me something to work with, and make it count! Also new rule, because I'm messy: if you want your scores tabulated, like the opening post, okay? Thank you.
    DEADLINE: September 17th, 2017, 00:00 KST.

    Good luck and don't fuck it up
    Last edited: Mar 9, 2018
  2. [​IMG]
    35. 어떤가요 (How Are You) - 4.42
    34. 안아줘요 (Hug Song) - 5.23
    33. 사랑을 미룰 순 없나요 (Love Does Not Wait) - 5.31
    32. 눈을 감아 (Keep Your Eyes Closed) - 5.42
    31. 흰눈 사이로 하이힐 타고 (Dashing Through the Snow In High Heels) - 5.78
    30. The Angel's Wink (天使のウィンク) - 5.81
    29. 아직… (Not Yet...) - 5.84
    28. Cookies, Cream & Mint (クッキークリーム&ミント) - 5.89
    27. Red Shoes (赤いくつ) - 5.97
    26. Lamu no Love Song (ラムのラブソング) - 6.00
    25. Meteor and Piercing (流星とピアス) - 6.05
    24. Superwoman - 6.18
    23. My Sweet Devil (やさしい悪魔) - 6.39
    22. 클라라의 꿈 (Clara's Dream) - 6.44
    21. 이곳에 서서 (The Day You Went Away) - 6.63
    20. Sour Grapes (すっぱい葡萄) - 6.73
    19. Goodbye PMS - 6.76
    18. 아잉♡ (A-ing ♡) - 6.81
    17. One Love - 7.34
    16. Funny Hunny - 7.50
    15. Sleeping Forest (眠れる森) - 7.52
    14. Tonight - 7.60
    13. 밀크쉐이크 (Milkshake) - 7.63
    12. 미친 듯이 울었어 (Cried Uncontrollably) - 7.81
    11. 마법소녀 (Magic Girl) - 8.13
    10. Not an Easy Girl (쉬운 여자 아니에요) - 8.15
    9. 강남거리 (Gangnam Avenue) - 8.31
    8. 방콕시티 (Bangkok City) - 8.57
    7. Bubble Bath - 8.63
    6. So Sorry - 8.86
    5. 아빙아빙 (Abing Abing) - 9.10
    4. 나처럼 해봐요 (My Copycat) - 9.13
    3. Shanghai Romance (上海之戀) - 9.15
    2. 립스틱 (LIPSTICK) - 9.84
    1. 까탈레나 (Catallena) - 10.36
    Last edited: Aug 25, 2019
    vague, Ceir, send photo and 1 other person like this.
  4. One of the best discographies in K-pop. So many well-deserved 11s... I'm gonna have trouble.
    vague and Deja-Boo like this.
  5. I'm pretty sure what my 11 is going to be (alongside a bundle of 10s) but I've only listened to around half of these before so who knows what treasures might be unlocked.
    vague and Deja-Boo like this.
  6. This rate will be a race for the #2 spot because we all agree that Catalena is #1, right ?
    vague, Mill. and Deja-Boo like this.
  7. Question is, can I go 4/4 with rates where the winner has a 10+ average?

    Don't let me down, sistren! Every 11 counts.
    vague, send photo and Slice of Life like this.
  8. Oh and one more thing
    vague, Island, Slice of Life and 3 others like this.
  9. Just because:

    (for 1:22 - 2:01 alone.)
    roblognick, vague and Deja-Boo like this.
  10. Remember the Chun-Li Triplets?

  11. I'm surprised nobody has posted this yet

    roblognick, vague, He and 4 others like this.
  12. Tag me incessantly.
    D is for Danger! and junglefish like this.
  13. Deja-Boo likes this.
  14. Making this due right around my birthday is a crime.

    Someone yell at me when it gets closer.
  15. So I got one set of votes so far and their average score is 10.03. Now that is how you stan. I mean, it does fuck all for the ranking in the grand scheme of things (basically the point of a rate), but I didn't - nay, couldn't - disqualify the ballot for trolling because, if giving every Orange Caramel song a 10 is wrong, then what's the use of being on a pop forum eh?
    vague, send photo, Ceir and 2 others like this.
  16. Unnie I'm here and ready to participate.

    Shamelessly admitting that I learn the 'My Copycat' dance as a part of my cardio regime. #Noragrets

    Edit: Just realised I know literally all of the Orange Caramel dances from just how much I've watched them perform...
    Last edited: Aug 20, 2017
  17. Goodbye PMS >>>>>
    Ceir likes this.
  18. I wanna do this to finally give their discography a chance, but don't want to spoil the results for superfans and end up as yet another rate villain.

    vague, Ceir and Dangerous Maknae like this.
  19. You thinking I would even open the PM given your history with rates
    vague, Serg., junglefish and 5 others like this.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.