P!nk: The Discography Rate (Results #128) | The Popjustice Forum

P!nk: The Discography Rate (Results #128)

Discussion in 'Charts, rates etc' started by Lost Boy, May 28, 2019.

  1. [​IMG]

    Over 20 years in the industry.
    40+ million album sales.
    75+ million single sales.

    Alecia Beth Moore, better known as P!nk, has soundtracked the growth of an entire generation; her empowering gusto in music inspiring millions of fans to follow her all the way from her urban debut to her latest album, Hurts 2B Human - a surprise heavy hitter that showcases exactly why P!nk stands tall among her peers.

    Her story is one we all know: from trailblazing edgy teenager to Hot AC soccer Mum. Her power comes in her total dedication to music and performance, frequently breaking records around the globe and blowing the minds of fans with jaw-dropping acrobatics. Whilst musically her edgy ways became polished as the years went on, her performance strength only ever grew. You'd be hard pressed to predict her next performance style - will she be performing on a building? will she be dancing above the audience? will she be dropped from a box 200 feet in the sky? If you ask the question and it sounds like something an artist would never do, she's probably planning it.

    With almost twenty years and eight albums under her belt, her music inspires a breadth of opinion. Many of us have grown with her, lived difficult childhoods as she did and felt a deep connection to her weary expose of harsh family life; 'Family Portrait' was one of the first songs I ever remember hearing, the sheer pain piercing right through me as I recognized myself inside of it. I found solace in that brutal contrast of begging to return to something normal despite everything falling down around you.

    It's that brutal honesty that has always been integral to P!nk, regardless of sound - her lyricism and vocal prowess cuts through in a way that many can't. 'What About Us', on paper a simple political bop with only three chords, revitalized her career and led to the biggest opening for any of her albums so far - as I again struggled through difficult personal times, the song bloomed and opened up for me in new ways, her defiant but melancholic delivery unparalleled.

    With artists like this, and music that can really delve deep into the human psyche of each one of us, I ask that we all approach these songs with some kindness. Naturally there's an entirely contrasting side to P!nk, a goofy and charismatic one that likes to experiment and try out new sonic experiments... that don't always pay off. We'll either be endeared to them or despise them, and that's fine.

    Join me in reliving the career of one of the greatest performers of our time, and an artist that is already recognized as the living legend that she is. Together we'll discuss how we've grown together with each album, how songs remind us of people we've lost and friends we've loved. And we'll discover P!nk's very best song.​


    Rules:

    1.You may give one eleven and one zero. Neither are compulsory.
    2. Rate all of these songs from 1 - 10. Decimals are allowed, I would advise to quarters.
    3. Commentary is appreciated but please don't make jokes that may offend and be considerate to others. Think about what you're commenting and why people would want to read it. It makes for much better commentary and a better rate for all.

    Song List:
    Can't Take Me Home
    01. Split Personality
    02. Hell Wit Ya
    03. Most Girls
    04. There You Go
    05. You Make Me Sick
    06. Let Me Let You Know
    07. Love is Such a Crazy Thing
    08. Private Show
    09. Can't Take Me Home
    10. Stop Falling
    11. Do What U Do
    12. Hiccup
    13. Is It Love
    XX. Leaving for the Last Time

    M!ssundaztood
    01. M!ssundaztood
    02. Don't Let Me Get Me
    03. Just Like a Pill
    04. Get the Party Started
    05. Respect
    06. 18 Wheeler
    07. Family Portrait
    08. Misery
    09. Dear Diary
    10. Eventually
    11. Lonely Girl
    12. Numb
    13. Gone to California
    14. My Vietnam
    XX. Catch-22

    Try This
    01. Trouble
    02. God is a DJ
    03. Last to Know
    04. Tonight's the Night
    05. Oh My God
    06. Catch Me While I'm Sleeping
    07. Waiting for Love
    08. Save My Life
    09. Try Too Hard
    10. Humble Neighborhoods
    11. Walk Away
    12. Unwind
    13. Love Song
    14. Hooker
    XX. Feel Good Time
    XX. Delirium
    XX. Free

    I'm Not Dead
    01. Stupid Girls
    02. Who Knew
    03. Long Way to Happy
    04. Nobody Knows
    05. Dear Mr. President
    06. I'm Not Dead
    07. Cuz I Can
    08. Leave Me Alone (I'm Lonely)
    09. U + Ur Hand
    10. Runaway
    11. The One That Got Away
    12. I Got Money Now
    13. Conversations with My 13 Year Old Self
    XX. I Have Seen the Rain
    XX. Heartbreaker
    XX. Centerfold
    XX. Fingers
    XX. Disconnected
    XX. Crash & Burn
    XX. Words

    Funhouse
    01. So What
    02. Sober
    03. I Don't Believe You
    04. One Foot Wrong
    05. Please Don't Leave Me
    06. Bad Influence
    07. Funhouse
    08. Crystal Ball
    09. Mean
    10. It's All Your Fault
    11. Ave Mary A
    12. Glitter in the Air
    XX. This Is How It Goes Down
    XX. Boring
    XX. Why Did I Ever Like You
    XX. Could've Had Everything
    XX. Push You Away
    XX. When We're Through

    Greatest Hits... So Far!!!
    xx. Whataya Want from Me
    xx. Raise Your Glass
    xx. F*cking Perfect
    xx. Heartbreak Down

    The Truth About Love
    01. Are We All We Are
    02. Blow Me (One Last Kiss)
    03. Try
    04. Just Give Me a Reason
    05. True Love
    06. How Come You're Not Here
    07. Slut Like You
    08. The Truth About Love
    09. Beam Me Up
    10. Walk of Shame
    11. Here Comes the Weekend
    12. Where Did the Beat Go?
    13. The Great Escape
    XX. My Signature Move
    XX. Is This Thing On?
    XX. Run
    XX. Good Old Days
    XX. Chaos & Piss
    XX. Timebomb
    XX. The King is Dead but the Queen is Alive

    Beautiful Trauma
    01. Beautiful Trauma
    02. Revenge
    03. Whatever You Want
    04. What About Us
    05. But We Lost It
    06. Barbies
    07. Where We Go
    08. For Now
    09. Secrets
    10. Better Life
    11. I Am Here
    12. Wild Hearts Can't Be Broken
    13. You Get My Love

    Hurts 2B Human
    01. Hustle
    02. (Hey Why) Miss You Sometime
    03. Walk Me Home
    04. My Attic
    05. 90 Days
    06. Hurts 2B Human
    07. Can We Pretend
    08. Courage
    09. Happy
    10. We Could Have It All
    11. Love Me Anyway
    12. Circle Game
    13. The Last Song of Your Life
    xx. More

    BONUS
    XX. Bridge of Light
    XX. Today's the Day
    XX. Just Like Fire
    XX. Setting the World On Fire
    XX. Waterfall
    XX. A Million Dreams
    XX. Halfway Gone
    XX. White Rabbit

    Easy list:
    Split Personality
    Hell Wit Ya
    Most Girls
    There You Go
    You Make Me Sick
    Let Me Let You Know
    Love is Such a Crazy Thing
    Private Show
    Can't Take Me Home
    Stop Falling
    Do What U Do
    Hiccup
    Is It Love
    Leaving for the Last Time

    M!ssundaztood
    Don't Let Me Get Me
    Just Like a Pill
    Get the Party Started
    Respect
    18 Wheeler
    Family Portrait
    Misery
    Dear Diary
    Eventually
    Lonely Girl
    Numb
    Gone to California
    My Vietnam
    Catch-22

    Trouble
    God is a DJ
    Last to Know
    Tonight's the Night
    Oh My God
    Catch Me While I'm Sleeping
    Waiting for Love
    Save My Life
    Try Too Hard
    Humble Neighborhoods
    Walk Away
    Unwind
    Love Song
    Hooker
    Feel Good Time
    Delirium
    Free

    Stupid Girls
    Who Knew
    Long Way to Happy
    Nobody Knows
    Dear Mr. President
    I'm Not Dead
    Cuz I Can
    Leave Me Alone (I'm Lonely)
    U + Ur Hand
    Runaway
    The One That Got Away
    I Got Money Now
    Conversations with My 13 Year Old Self
    I Have Seen the Rain
    Heartbreaker
    Centerfold
    Fingers
    Disconnected
    Crash & Burn
    Words

    So What
    Sober
    I Don't Believe You
    One Foot Wrong
    Please Don't Leave Me
    Bad Influence
    Funhouse
    Crystal Ball
    Mean
    It's All Your Fault
    Ave Mary A
    Glitter in the Air
    This Is How It Goes Down
    Boring
    Why Did I Ever Like You
    Could've Had Everything
    Push You Away
    When We're Through

    Whataya Want from Me
    Raise Your Glass
    F*cking Perfect
    Heartbreak Down

    Are We All We Are
    Blow Me (One Last Kiss)
    Try
    Just Give Me a Reason
    True Love
    How Come You're Not Here
    Slut Like You
    The Truth About Love
    Beam Me Up
    Walk of Shame
    Here Comes the Weekend
    Where Did the Beat Go?
    The Great Escape
    My Signature Move
    Is This Thing On?
    Run
    Good Old Days
    Chaos & Piss
    Timebomb
    The King is Dead but the Queen is Alive

    Beautiful Trauma
    Revenge
    Whatever You Want
    What About Us
    But We Lost It
    Barbies
    Where We Go
    For Now
    Secrets
    Better Life
    I Am Here
    Wild Hearts Can't Be Broken
    You Get My Love

    Hustle
    (Hey Why) Miss You Sometime
    Walk Me Home
    My Attic
    90 Days
    Hurts 2B Human
    Can We Pretend
    Courage
    Happy
    We Could Have It All
    Love Me Anyway
    Circle Game
    The Last Song of Your Life
    More

    Bridge of Light
    Today's the Day
    Just Like Fire
    Setting the World On Fire
    Waterfall
    A Million Dreams
    Halfway Gone
    White Rabbit



    Please let me know if you're having trouble finding songs or I have missed anything obvious. All missing songs are linked above.

    You have until 13th July (by Sunday) to send in votes via PM.
    (This is preliminary and may change if needed)

     
    Last edited: Jul 11, 2019
    abael, Conan, GimmeWork and 22 others like this.
  2. Voters
    [​IMG]

    abael
    AllGagaLike
    Bpffer
    Daniel_O
    Duppe
    Happiest Girl
    HollyDunnSomething
    Hurricane Drunk
    JckHnn
    JMRGBY88
    Kal
    Laurence
    LiK
    Lost Boy
    Maki
    Music is Life
    Nikkysan
    P'NutButter
    Playboy69
    R27
    Reboot
    Remorque
    Rick
    Robsolete
    Sail On
    Sanctuary
    Sapnu Puas
    Savilizabeths
    Sideout
    Soratami
    Sprockrooster
    The Hot Rock
    Txetxu
    Tylerc904
    Untouchable Ace
    Verandi
    əʊæ

    Total: 37.

     
    Last edited: Jul 14, 2019
    savilizabeths, JMRGBY88, kal and 7 others like this.
  3. So in for this! It does mean that I will have to get on with listening to the last 2 albums...
     
    kal, Mvnl, Terminus and 2 others like this.
  4. Fully expecting the majority from the last 2 albums to get 4 and 5s.

    I'm in for the golden years.
     
    Maki and HollyDunnSomething like this.


  5. This is an eleven contender though.
     
  6. Oh nice, I just checked Spotify and had no idea they put up so many of her b-sides on there. Will get stuck into this tomorrow, looking forward to hearing Hurts 2B Human for the first time after seeing the reception on here was surprisingly positive. There's a lot of songs to get through so I will at least provide commentary for my 11 and 0.

    Definitely gunning for I'm Not Dead, Try This and the Truth About Love bonus tracks to triumph.
     
  7. I really want to do this, I'm just hoping I have the time management to pull it off.
     
    Music Is Life and Maki like this.
  8. I might do this. Love the no-zero rule; if any rate was going to attract attention-seekers who give out dozens of zeroes, it was this one.
     
  9. I would have done a singles rate but I shall watch this!
     
    Maki likes this.
  10. Looking forward to this! Never actually listened to her first and last albums, as well as to a lot of the extras, so it should be nice to make some discoveries.
     
    Music Is Life, Mvnl and Maki like this.
  11. So to take part I DM @Lost Boy with my scores? Sorry if it's a dumb question but I have always wanted to take part in rates but never quite knew how.
     
    Maki likes this.
  12. Yeah, copy the list and PM me your scores from 1-10 for each song. You can give one zero and one eleven, though neither are compulsory.
     
  13. I'm super excited about this, she does have quite an impressive discography!
    Now the big question is – which of the Eminem features deserves my zero points? Hmmm...
     
    Maki likes this.
  14. I didn't even know there were more than one. I just looked it up and that makes me realise I've never actually listened to The Truth About Love in full.
     
    Maki likes this.
  15. Ok y'all

    You can all set fire to the last two albums and I won't care BUT



    This is one of her strongest songs and I will riot if you mistreat it. My 11 is already set in stone but this song needs respect. Thank you for coming to my TEDxTalk.
     
    Last edited: May 28, 2019
    Secret, PushyBakerFriend, Rem and 9 others like this.
  16. The melodies in this still make me quiver.
     
    Music Is Life, Maki and Verandi like this.
  17. A long overdue rate for this amazing artist, such a justice we're finally getting it.
    So happy(.mp3) that this is happening!

    Now, a month to rate and comment all of the songs, and it will both be tough and a pleasure to do that.
     
    Music Is Life and Mvnl like this.
  18. I haven’t listened to most P!nk albums in full. Any suggestions for a listening order? Chronological? Classics first?
     
  19. Different people will tell you different things. What singles do you like? I’d say go chronologically because it’s nice seeing the development between each. The first four are so wildly different and great.
     
    Rem, Music Is Life, Mvnl and 2 others like this.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.