Pink: The Discography Rate ∞ WINNER!

[sapnu puas]

WHAT THE FUCK

 

[Verandi]

...

 

[Dātura]

I love the final two songs but WRONG.

 

[Sideout]

Omg! I thought Who Knew had it in the bag. I gave my 11 to Just Like A Pill. I feel it truly is Pink's best song after all these years. Let's go Just Like A Pill.

 

[Verandi]

Lowest score: 5.8 @Untouchable Ace

...

 

[swim]

Also let me reiterate that this was like 1 point away from winning, the top three is SO close.

 

[R27]

U + Ur Hand is a tune, but also a tune that is clearly out of its depth and should have left a few eliminations ago. Just Like a Cure to Poor Taste better win this.

 

[Sideout]

U + Ur Hand deserves to be in the top 10 since it "saved" Pink's commercial success on top 40 radio. It does not deserve to be top 2 though.

 

[R27]

I mean I don't think the impact it had on her commercial success should have any pertinence on how it places in this rate, but I can see how its hand in helping revive her career could make it extra special for many fans.

 

[Robsolete]

Oh wow, I was sure that would win. It deserved better than #3 but c'mon my 11!

 

[Verandi]

Yeah I can only hope U + Ur Hand wins now. It would be a minor victory at least.

 

[LiK]

03. Who Knew
Average score: 9.73
Highest score: 11x6
@AllGagaLike @Verandi @Sail On @tylerc904 @Remorque @HollyDunnSomething
10x22
@Lost Boy @Sanctuary @JMRGBY88 @nikkysan @The Hot Rock
@Sprockrooster @soratami @Reboot @kal @rick
@playboy69 @abael @Robsolete @Sideout @sapnu puas
@LiK @Music Is Life @Maki @əʊæ @Duppe @savilizabeths
Lowest score: 5.8 @Untouchable Ace
​

WOOOOWWW! @soratami

 

[LiK]

Anyways joking aside Who Knew is a career highlight and I absolutely adore it, but I can't say I'm bothered by this plot twist elimination.

#TeamJustLikeAPill

 

[nikkysan]

I...

Just Like A Pill's kinda limp production beat this?

 

[jawow_]

@Lost Boy as we approach the end of the rate I cannot express to you truly how much of an amazing experience this has been for me. Rediscovering Pink’s discography (which is usually unfairly criticised on PopJustice), having people share their experiences; and most importantly your write ups. I can honestly say it’s been an emotional ride and I’m pleased and lucky to have shared that with you. Thank you so much. Your work has been thoroughly appreciated and I wish somehow Pink herself could see it. Don’t let it go to waste. Capture this in a book or something because it’s been an amazing experience. This was the first rate I followed and I have to say you set the bar really high. So all that is left to say is THANK YOU.

 

[Music Is Life & Death]

Okay, I really hope U + Ur Hand wins this. It'd be amazing.

 

[Remorque]

Well, fuck me.

Who Knew is most definitely her best song for me. It kinda starts out as a lovely little mid-tempo, but then that chorus sets in and it only builds from then on. The way P!nk lets her vulnerability show, especially in that middle 8, without losing power is something only she's capable of and which is why I was such a stan back in the day.

It's not the winner here, but it's my winner.

 

[savilizabeths]

I’m actually really happy Who Knew is out. I gave all of the final three 10s but I wanted the final result to be more interesting than Who Knew taking the crown.

 

[Music Is Life & Death]

I would also like to say Who Knew is the first song by her I ever remember hearing so it's always going to be a fave.

 

[fatyoshi]

Part of the final push to giving my 11 to Sober (I was already 90% there) was being almost certain Who Knew would win. I'm a clown.

Pulling for Just Like a Pill.