Pink: The Discography Rate ∞ WINNER!

LiK

LiK

I think Waterfall was my lowest rated song, had I known I could give a song a zero it would have gotten it on a platter.

If it was only P!nk on the song, I probably would have scored it better, but Sia makes my ear drums wanna rupture. The production also sounds like something they threw together quickly in garage band.
 
Maki

Maki

Not satisfied with this elimination, but it would've been worse. The title of the worst single could've went to at least 5 other songs.
I don't hear a bad song in "Waterfall", but it is undeniably Sia by-the-numbers and I can understand that her vocals are not for everyone. Especially in this song, Sia's vocals seem to be really sharp. But the melody and especially parts which P!nk sings are excellent.

Don't know what led them to release this as a single, but it most certainly is taken from one of the thousands Sia's 'five minute writes'.

Also, P!nk and Sia are quite a random collaboration.
But imagine if Sia worked with P!nk around 2004-2008...

tylerc904 said:
Things are going quite well, proud Can’t Take Me Home has dodged the first five.
Click to expand...
Me too, hopefully only one (correct) song from it will leave in the next five.
 
Maki

Maki

Verandi said:
Ok but write them under a spoiler tag to spice things up x
Click to expand...
Ready...?
Setting the World on Fire
Just Like Fire
Raise Your Glass
Dear Mr. President
Nobody Knows
True Love
God Is a DJ
"Can We Pretend" and "A Million Dreams" if they count as singles, too.

Oops, I mentioned more than five songs.
 
Last edited:
Verandi

Verandi

Maki said:
Ready...?
Setting the World on Fire
Just Like Fire
Raise Your Glass
Dear Mr. President
Nobody Knows
True Love
God Is a DJ
"Can We Pretend" and "A Million Dreams" if they count as singles, too.

Oops, I mentioned more five songs.
Click to expand...
We disagree only on God Is A DJ. I'd put in its place Today's the Day or There You Go. Can We Pretend tho... I can pretend it doesn't exist
 
SlowGinFizzzz

SlowGinFizzzz

@Maki I'm so sorry, I edited my post so that your least favourite songs + the two tracks in bold that accidentally must have slipped in as well are hidden again.
Nobody Knows is beautiful and Dear Mr. President literally turned 10 y/o me into a stan when I looked up the lyrics and my mum helped me translate/understand them. I'm getting old...
 
Maki

Maki

SlowGinFizzzz said:
@Maki I'm so sorry, I edited my post so that your least favourite songs + the two tracks in bold that accidentally must have slipped in as well are hidden again.
Nobody Knows is beautiful and Dear Mr. President literally turned 10 y/o me into a stan when I looked up the lyrics and my mum helped me translate/understand them. I'm getting old...
Click to expand...
No problem, I edited my post, too.
And those are not among my lowest rated songs overall (okay, maybe just one), but my lowest scored singles, so most of their scores float around 6-7 area.
 
Music Is Life & Death

Music Is Life & Death

He/Him
Perfectly fine with these two being gone as they're among my lowest scores. And yeah, I definitely read somewhere that Hooker is about Linda, not Xtina. But it's still some of the worst lyrics in her catalog.
Maki said:
Ready...?
Setting the World on Fire
Just Like Fire
Raise Your Glass
Dear Mr. President
Nobody Knows
True Love
God Is a DJ
"Can We Pretend" and "A Million Dreams" if they count as singles, too.

Oops, I mentioned more than five songs.
Click to expand...
I like to love all of these.
Dear Mr. President is a career highlight and should make top 10.
 
Maki

Maki

The songs I listed were just the singles that I like less than "Waterfall", there are way more album tracks and B-sides I would like to leave next.

As for "Dear Mr. President", I was never too keen on the song melody, but the lyrics are beautiful (looking at its score now, I think that I slightly underscored that song).
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Top