Pink: The Discography Rate ∞ WINNER!

Maki

Maki

Lost Boy said:
I agree with ALL of this, except the last line. Maybe I just have a soft spot for the debut, but looking at my scores for the album I definitely gave it somewhat middling scores. I guess it didn't make as much of an impression as I thought, especially compared to how much I listen to the rest of her discography...
Click to expand...
I can totally understand and relate to this, I'm also very 'sensitive' towards her debut for some reason.
For example, losing a song that got an 8 from me feels different when it's from "Can't Take Me Home", than, let's say, "Beautiful Trauma" - I kind of sympathize with her debut.

P'NutButter said:
'Let Me Let You Know' is by far the most dull track in this rate...
Click to expand...
I agree, not necessarily in the entire rate, but it's the dullest song from the debut for sure.

"Stop Falling" is a masterpiece and better not leave until at least the top 50 (of course that's impossible).
 
abael

abael

I would have preferred Leaving For The Last Time over Hiccup as the first track leaving from that era, but it definitely could have been worse.
 
Maki

Maki

Lost Boy said:
The debut is about to take another hit, but which song do we think it is?
Click to expand...
Hopefully it's either "Let Me Let You Know" or "Do What U Do", because none of the other songs deserve to leave this soon.

Surprised that "Hurts 2B Human" avoided the first 10 eliminations (especially "Can We Pretend").
 
Maki

Maki

"Can We Pretend" is good and grew on me, but it's still one of the weakest songs from "Hurts 2B Human".
Still, I won't really care if it stays or not.

*continues praying that "Stop Falling" isn't going next*
 
swim

swim

he / him
P!nk's ten worst songs, according to all 37 of us, are as follows:

Revenge
You Get My Love
Here Comes the Weekend
Hooker
Waterfall
Misery
Free
I Have Seen the Rain
Hiccup

and









Is-It-Love.png

134. Is It Love?
Average score: 5.61
Highest score: 8x4 (@Daniel_O, @kal, @Music Is Life, @Maki)
Lowest score: 1 (@Laurence)
My score: 6

'Is It Love?' proves that sometimes dullness is just as bad as anything else, falling alongside 'Hiccup' in the bottom ten. Truthfully I could copy everything from the last elimination here and it would still apply - it barely leaves an impression, except for some gorgeous ad-libs. It barely managed to grab enough commentary too, save for the dedicated few who commented on almost every song!

Commentary corner:​

@rick: She warned me about fuckbois. Should have listened
​
@R27: I adore thevocal layering on the chorus, but what the actual fuck are these lyrics.

@savilizabeths: “It’s a pretty cool vibe but the song just doesn’t completely work for me. I could see it growing on me with time though.”

@abael: Pink is so easily able to convey emotion through her vocals, and their exhibition here helps separate it from the pack.

@Music Is Life: It’s a cute, boppy mid-tempo, and a nice enough official closer but Leaving For The Last Time would have been better.

@Maki: Lovely hook, great to hear her lower range in it. Kind of a filler track, but a really good filler. I love the fact that there are four verses (or two verses and two bridges), which instantly makes it more interesting. And you can tell that P!nk co-wrote the lyrics here.


​
 
Last edited:
R27

R27

This should have been the first song the debut lost. Like I said in the commentary, it sounds great but the lyrics are so messed up.
 
M

Mike

Maki said:
Hopefully it's either "Let Me Let You Know" or "Do What U Do", because none of the other songs deserve to leave this soon.
Click to expand...
Do What U Do is almost as boring as Love Is Such A Crazy Thing.

Stop Falling may not be her best, but at least she sings it like she cares about it, which is more than can be said for those two.
 
rick

rick

Some of the god awful bonus tracks like Delirium and Halfway Gone need to burn next.

Is it Love got a 7 from me and Hiccup a 6. Im surprised they both fell so early
 
Maki

Maki

I nearly died when I saw that @Lost Boy tagged me - thought that one of my 10's was gone.

Poor album tracks from "Can't Take Me Home" are going to suffer from the lack of high scores.

"Is It Love" definitely didn't deserve to leave this early. I'm a bit surprised it already left, since the production is really good and the song isn't bad at all. I gave it an 8, which makes it one of my better rated album tracks from her debut.
The lyrics are surely... unique. But the melody and her vocal delivery alone deserved at least top 100 placement. That 'do you feeeeeel good' bit is amazing.

And I forgot to post this after "Hiccup" was eliminated:

Her first movie appearance in "Ski to the Max" back in 2001.
Was "Hiccup" planned to be released as a single? We only know that is was a B-side to "Most Girls", so it got some 'promo'.
 
Verandi

Verandi

Maki said:
I nearly died when I saw that @Lost Boy tagged me - thought that one of my 10's was gone.

Poor album tracks from "Can't Take Me Home" are going to suffer from the lack of high scores.

"Is It Love" definitely didn't deserve to leave this early. I'm a bit surprised it already left, since the production is really good and the song isn't bad at all. I gave it an 8, which makes it one of my better rated album tracks from her debut.
The lyrics are surely... unique. But the melody and her vocal delivery alone deserved at least top 100 placement. That 'do you feeeeeel good' bit is amazing.

And I forgot to post this after "Hiccup" was eliminated:

Her first movie appearance in "Ski to the Max" back in 2001.
Was "Hiccup" planned to be released as a single? We only know that is was a B-side to "Most Girls", so it got some 'promo'.
Click to expand...

Scream the acting skills.
 
M

Mike

She's actually very good in Thanks For Sharing.

I haven't seen any of her other acting performances (unless you count her cameo as herself in Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping) and I think it's probably best kept that way.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top