Pink: The Discography Rate ∞ WINNER! | Page 91 | The Popjustice Forum

Pink: The Discography Rate ∞ WINNER!

Discussion in 'Charts, rates etc' started by swim, May 28, 2019.

  1. I was so close to throwing a bitch fit about ‘Raise Your Glass’ being unfairly cut (seriously, what do you guys have against fun?) but then I saw y’all did the right thing with ‘Miss You Sometimes’. I should have scored it even lower to be honest. Can I retroactively give it a zero?
     
    Untouchable Ace likes this.
  2. You said 'what do you have against fun?', yet dislike "(Hey Why) Miss You Sometime" - that's a complete contradiction.
     
    swim, LiK, soratami and 1 other person like this.
  3. I’m going to campaign to have you removed from this thread.
     
    swim, soratami and Maki like this.
  4. Looking back, Raise Your Glass really was the beginning of the end when it comes to her quality control. A cynical, dumb and empty piece of music. Not that the other pop girls were doing much better at the time. Fireworks, We R Who We R, Born This Way and, later, Stronger were all #1 that dumbed down every single thing that made those girls special; they all aged like milk.
     
    Last edited: Sep 4, 2019
  5. I LOVE ALL OF THESE. I'm so basic, I love it.
     
    swim and Untouchable Ace like this.
  6. Fireworks and Born This Way are iconic though.
     
  7. [​IMG]
    41. Fucking Perfect
    Average score: 7.83
    Highest score: 11 (@Music Is Life)
    10x4: (@Lost Boy, @Sprockrooster, @Sideout, @Remorque)
    Lowest score: 2 (@LiK)


    Spare a thought for @Music Is Life, who loses their beloved eleven just before the top 40. Unfortunately I've seen a lot of criticism for this, that I really don't think it deserves, because it's a fairly cliche empowerment anthem. Originally written as a love song for Carey, P!nk recognised the potential and began turning it into an anthem for her fans - many of whom struggle daily with personal insecurities.

    I started writing ['F**kin' Perfect'] about Carey. And then I started writing it for the fans, and for all these little girls, and then it just became about me and it was just sort of for everybody. And then it was about this thing inside of me that I didn’t even know yet. It’s just all of it.


    And for me that just adds to the charm, I've never really seen it as just an empowerment anthem and it wasn't written with that solely in mind. It encapsulates love, worth, self-acceptance, and is essentially just a very well written love song. Lyrically it has one of the strongest opening verses I know, and some really hard hitting lines in the verses that reference her past hits, and melodically it is absolutely stunning. It really did feel like a moment when she released it and it still kind of feels like one now? As though this song was always sitting inside of her waiting to be written, and it is integral to her career.

    Sometimes I feel like it's really easy to shit on tracks like this that are built at helping people, as though people shouldn't ever be in a position to require them, but quite honestly these tracks are so necessary to some people. Hearing the emotional vulnerability on display here makes me feel less alone for four minutes and that's kind of what music is really all about?

    I also adore the production and the middle-8 section, despite a few people calling that out as a reason for them not liking it. There's this nostalgic classic feeling that comes with it that kind of reminds me of 'Where Is the Love?'. Personally I think this song is just timeless.

    Commentary corner:
    @Music Is Life: (11) So yeah. This is my 11. From the moment this rate was put into the queue, I was 100% positive this would be my 11, and the only time I’ve really questioned that is with happy, so for one, P!nk did that in 2019 on her new album. Before I get to why it’s this, I need to talk about the actual song. Ignoring the lyrics for now, I love the production. It’s very uplifting and anthemic, especially in like the final minute with the drums and the strings, which I’m sure was on purpose. And the acoustic guitar throughout, it’s one of my favorite uses of that instrument in any song by any artist. And the melody is so catchy and perfect and amazing. And the lyrics, are maybe a little clunky and awkward, but so is P!nk.

    The lyrics are also heartfelt and honest, something that also applies to this beautiful, amazing woman. And they’re the main reason my 11 is going to this song is as well as everything it’s done for me. I was 10 years old when it came out and already a huge P!nk fan. But as soon as I heard it for the first time, it became my favorite P!nk song. Because for years throughout elementary school, I was bullied. Consistently, especially by one person who I used to trust and think was a friend. This led to a breakdown of my mental health as a kid, and a desire to make everything stop. If I hadn’t known what it would do to my parents and if I had any real knowledge of how to do it, I would have committed suicide. As it was, I forced myself to endure school almost every day, though I would fake being sick whenever I could. Those distractions were mostly reading – I’d read anything I cpould get my hands, cause books always took – and continue to take – me to a world that was better, and music, because with headphones in, I couldn’t hear what everyone was saying. But after this song came out, that’s when I started to really turn to music. I had always loved music, listening to it and jamming out. But this song was the first time I had ever felt like something had been made for me.

    Like it was something P!nk wanted me to hear specifically, cause she knew what I was going through. I know that’s a little ridiculous, but remember, I was 10. But because I felt like she was singing to me, even though I didn’t believe her words, I believed her feelings. She wanted me to keep going so I did. Now, there were a bunch of songs with a message like this that came out for a few years, which I’m sure we all know. But this is the first one I can really remember hearing, or at least the first one that really hit me, and helped me. It would take me another 4-5 years before I could really start exploring music, but P!nk and this song is what helped lead me to trying that. And it’s because of this song that one of my first CDs was her greatest hits, which I think I got when I was like 12 or 13, and it ended up being the clean edition, but I ended up getting two more copies, but explicit, of the album, so it’s all good. This song is also why I will always, always be here for P!nk and her music. So yeah, this is my 11 and that’s why. I know this isn’t well liked on here but please, please let it make top 30.

    @Sprockrooster: (10) That extra adlib in the non-explicit version sends me to heaven every damn time.

    @rick: (9) She gets accused of ‘Mom rock’ a lot but this is the best example of it. Still a great little ditty though

    @Sail On: (9) Corny and cheesy lyrics aside, this led the charge among the It Gets Better campaign era singles for me to not feel so "less than" when I was so young.

    @P'NutButter: (9) This does sound like a Kelly Clarkson track, but in the best way. I love the chorus.

    @savilizabeths: (9) “P!nk has a surprising amount of “inspirational” material in her discography, and I do like this one quite a lot. It’s not lyrically perfect, but it definitely makes up for that in passion and melody. It does make me feel better, and it has GODDAMN STRINGS! Some people seem to check out when they sing songs like this and just not care, I love that P!nk doesn’t do that at all.”

    @Laurence: (9) Yeah, I'm a sucker for these tracks and it's a beautiful one. From this moment on they started spinning P!NK so much for the female over 30? 40? age bracket on radio and the Dutch station 'skyradio' for it. Yeah, but I like the track anyway.

    @Maki: (8.75) My favorite new song on her greatest hits album, but it’s still not… well, perfect. There are traces of sadness in it that I definitely appreciate, but as a whole it doesn’t work as much as it could. The pre-chorus is beautiful, and the chorus is powerful, so why bother with the rap in the bridge? Still, the great elements of the song overpower the weak ones.

    @abael: (8) A brilliantly crafted song and very fitting for Pink. It just comes off as fake to me

    @Verandi: (6) This aged terribly

    @sapnu puas: (5) it’s like a parody of a Pink song.

    @R27: (4.5) I'm not used to hearing the explicit version, and that f-bomb feels so forced, as if P!nk and her team didn't believe the song had enough grit on it's own. I'll admit that she sings the song with conviction, but that awful bridge trivializes the more serious themes the song grapples with ("they don't like my hair"), and ultimately tarnishes most of the goodwill I have towards the song.


     
    GimmeWork, abael, Maki and 15 others like this.
  8. Tragic. But what else is new in this rate?
     
  9. THE TOP 40:

    Can't Take Me Home
    2/14

    Most Girls
    There You Go



    M!ssundaztood
    4/15

    Don't Let Me Get Me
    Just Like a Pill
    Get the Party Started

    Family Portrait



    Try This
    4/17

    Trouble
    God is a DJ
    Last to Know

    Feel Good Time



    I'm Not Dead
    12/20

    Stupid Girls
    Who Knew
    Long Way to Happy

    Dear Mr. President
    I'm Not Dead
    Cuz I Can
    Leave Me Alone (I'm Lonely)
    U + Ur Hand
    Runaway
    I Got Money Now

    Heartbreaker
    Fingers




    Funhouse
    9/18

    So What
    Sober
    I Don't Believe You

    Please Don't Leave Me
    Bad Influence
    Funhouse

    It's All Your Fault
    Ave Mary A
    Glitter in the Air




    The Truth About Love
    3/20

    Blow Me (One Last Kiss)
    Try
    Timebomb



    Beautiful Trauma
    3/13

    Beautiful Trauma
    Whatever You Want
    What About Us




    Greatest Hits... So Far!!!
    1/4

    Whataya Want From Me




    Hurts 2B Human
    2/14


    90 Days
    Happy




    Extras
    0/8
     
    GimmeWork, Maki, Sail On and 10 others like this.
  10. kal

    kal

    Well.
     
    Maki, berserkboi, soratami and 6 others like this.
  11. Whataya Want from Me being the last track standing from the Best Of is correct.
     
    Maki, swim, tylerc904 and 6 others like this.
  12. I cannot deal with the lack of taste you guys have. Honestly. It’s borderline offensive that you even call yourselves fans of her when you’re booting out her career highs and saying they’re crap and yet every single from her worst album is still in the running. Truly tragic.
     
  13. No it isn't.

    I will save my thoughts for tomorrow.
     
    swim, Maki, Sprockrooster and 2 others like this.
  14. 'Fucking Perfect' is another one of these tracks that really only P!nk could get away with. It's fluffy pop through and through, but the overall sentiment and her vocals really boost it above the norm.
     
    Music Is Death, Maki and swim like this.
  15. Hit single doesn't always equate quality song. We've almost reached the 8 mark anyway so...
     
    Maki, swim, ssa and 4 others like this.
  16. LiK

    LiK

    This is now bitter sweet since I tanked @Music Is Life #11 so sorry <3

    But gawd do I loathe this darn song. I don't know if it's because I just couldn't escape it, everyone tweeting the words, or making it facebook their status. The entire thing just feels like a boardroom creation for a self empowerment slogan.
     
    Maki, Untouchable Ace and Verandi like this.
  17. LiK

    LiK


    I feel like you're projecting a biT through this post.
     
    abael, Maki, tylerc904 and 4 others like this.
  18. Fucking Perfect is another song I used to absolutely hate when it was inescapable, but listening to it now it's actually alright.

    Your commentary was great @Music Is Life. It's easy to turn our noses up at these types of songs, but it's fantastic how they actually can have a positive impact on people's lives.
     
  19. Where did I mention “hit single”? I said career highs.
     

  20. [​IMG]

    40. I Got Money Now
    Average score: 7.84
    Highest score: 11x2 (@Maki, @kal)
    10x3 (@Lost Boy, @Sprockrooster, @soratami)
    Lowest score: 3 (@Verandi)


    You don't have to like me anymore
    I got money now
    I don't care what you say about me anymore
    I got money now.


    I'm not really sure that I can do justice to this song in words, but I'll try. Both @Maki and @kal gave this their full score of 11, though only Maki provided commentary, and I think I'm in agreement at this being one of her best songs. At least we can take solace in it reaching the top 40?

    'I Got Money Now' is written with and produced by Mike Elizondo, who is mostly known for his collaborations with Dr. Dre and Eminem, and is a melancholic and almost desperate attempt to convince everybody that they really don't need the bridges they've burned after all because money can replace it all. Considering the attachment Elizondo has, it's kind of amazing to see an anthem dedicated to having money be subverted in such a way and turned into a despondent ballad.

    Despondent is how I would describe this, and that's not to take away from it at all, because something about that low-key melancholy just works so well with the subtly sweet production; it never soars or switches gears, it's simply a love song to money with the biggest addition being some reverb-soaked ad-libs near the end. Perhaps it would be easy to write this off as a cliche, but that would be to ignore the obvious contradictions they're playing for here.

    Despite singing about how money has solved all of her problems, despite claiming that she wouldn't trade a single dime to have friends again, you can almost hear the barrier of belief she has put up: a lonely and cavernous place in which you fully believe you don't need anybody because they've done nothing but hurt you. Trust me, I know it. It's so easy to break away from everything you love and replace it with materialistic things because they can't possibly hurt you, and on paper the lyrics do not suggest this at all... on paper, this is literally just an ownership anthem, but it's all in the delivery.

    It's all in the way 'It's alright' creeps out from her lips, it's in the constantly repeated 'You don't have to like me anymore', it's in the blink-and-you'll-miss-it 'so it seems' that closes off a final harrowing bridge. The entire song is as though she's repeating something just to believe it herself, and that's not to say there isn't belief here:


    There is no heartache if you can afford
    Everything delivered right to your door
    Responsibilities
    This life is easy
    So now girl with everything
    How could she complain
    Cause she's got it made
    Yeah she's got it made
    I don't need to be tucked in at night
    Told that everything is gonna be alright
    Is gonna be alright
    Cause I don't have to fight


    What an incredible little verse that sums it all up perfectly. There's a simple truth here; money buys you time, it allows respite from worries and responsibility, and those of us that grow up in poverty will tell you that we all dream of climbing that ladder ourselves and pulling ourselves out of that pit... but we'll also tell you that it has given us an awareness that money can't buy you everything.

    Commentary corner:

    @Maki: (11) Well, how do I start… I can vividly remember when I heard this song for the first time. I started laughing out loud because I couldn’t believe a song could be that good. If I made my own song, it would sound like this. It has a special place in my heart.

    The melody, the lyrics, the guitar riff and vocal delivery are all on point. There is a feeling I get when listening to it that I can't really describe. I have to stare at the certain point for some time, like my whole attention is drawn to the song, no matter what is happening around. However, I don't personally connect to the song. There is a bound in a way that I sympathize with P!nk, I want to give her a hug.

    Also, the emotion in the song is something she's never done before, so vulnerable and unique. And I find the way that it is written so genius. It is devastating and hopeful at the same time, while the lyrics are obvious and ambiguous at the same time. And at the point where I thought that sadness and melancholy can't get any better, the backing vocals in the final chorus kick in and devour me completely. Definitely reminds me of something she would create with Linda during the “M!ssundaztood” sessions.

    Every detail makes me speechless. Furthermore, it is one of my favorite songs of all time, too. I could talk about this song forever… Melancholic masterpiece.

    @Sprockrooster: (10) Due to @Maki and his comment for loving this song I have a newfound love for this song. Such a powerful message especially during that interview.

    @Music Is Life: (9.5) This is another song I used to not pay that much attention to when I first listened to the album, but recently I’ve realized just how truly great it is. The production is so fucking good, and she sounds so fucking sad despite trying to brag about how rich she is, then realizing that doesn’t matter at all, and she’d rather have people who love her. It’s so fucking sad and amazing. I love this. It’s not a 10 yet, but I’m sure it’ll get there, and I’ll end up regretting this score.

    @JMRGBY88: (9) when I first listened to the album, this was the filler track and yet with age it’s really become a favourite.

    @savilizabeths: (9) “This really paints a beautiful picture of having everything and still being miserable, even though it feels like you shouldn’t. Money really doesn’t buy happiness, I guess. It feels like you shouldn’t complain if you have good things in your life. This is quite sad really. It feels so hollow and empty. You can tell she doesn’t really mean the words she’s saying.”

    @P'NutButter: (8) I have a love/hate relationship with this song, as it does trigger my depression and I seem to hear this song in my head when I'm about to have a dark spell.

    @rick: (8) I'd love this life

    @R27: (7.5) It's such a cliched premise/concept, yet it remains surprisingly affecting.

    @Laurence: (7) A bit slow but could be better I guess... It's a nice relaxed vibe. Just getting over someone but the 'I got money now' is a bit shallow I think.

    @The Hot Rock: (6) God I Wish That Were Me. (being lonely with $$$ vs lonely and broke, I mean)

    @abael: (6) The cynical undercurrent of the album is starting to grate at this point, but otherwise this song is well crafted.

    @Verandi: (3) good_for_her.gif
     
    GimmeWork, tylerc904, kal and 16 others like this.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.