Discussion in 'Pop & Justice' started by dewzero, Oct 7, 2019.
I swear if they're going to pay Born This Decade dust.
I really hope MAYA is on that list, sure it received a lukewarm reaction when it came out, but it was truly ahead of its time, musically, aesthetically and thematically.
I think it's a really good list. Although none of the Beyonce songs they chose would be in my top 200.
My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
Good Kid, M.A.A.D City
To Pimp A Butterfly
A Seat at the Table
Modern Vampires of the City
Carrie & Lowell (maybe wishful dd)
I mean, they didn’t even bother reviewing it so there’s your answer
Not my wish, just my guess haha
Yeah it's strange to see so much shock at Lady Gaga not appearing in the list when Pitchfork has only ever reviewed The Fame Monster (7.8), Joanne (6.9) and A Star Is Born (7.4), plus "Chillin'," "Hey Girl" and "Shallow". It would've been a far bigger surprise if any of her songs had made the list in my opinion.
The most egregious omission in my view? "Into You".
And none for Ed Shitrag
Azealia, Grimes and Lana all co-existing in the top ten is a kii
She’s always been a Pitchfork darling, but Mitski in the Top 10 is what she deserves.
Justin Bieber having more songs in the top 200 than Gaga, Katy, Taylor, Ariana, Kacey, Janelle, Florence, Carly, St. Vincent, Björk, Fiona, Tinashe, SZA, Lizzo...
But hopefully not Born To Decade
Holy crap, yes. Where the hell was Janelle?!
Yeah, I was pretty shocked when I realised Janelle was not in the list at all, especially when her three albums were all released this decade. A mess.
Pitchfork had a very bullshit review for Dirty Computer, if I recall
I'm surprised they went with XO over Drunk In Love or Partition. It's a great song but so overrated.
Also yeah, Tightrope or Cold War being paid dust too is weird. Maybe they forget those songs are from this decade because I did dddskskfhehww.
Pynk is right there.
Plus it has their fave Grimes.
Has Pitchfork only listened to Pink Friday: Roman Reloaded and Pink Friday: Roman Reloaded only? Because "Beez In The Trap" and "Come On A Cone" ain't it, sis.
Separate names with a comma.