QUIRKY POP RATE: EVOLUTION | It's done.

Quirky-Pop-Rate-Evolution-2-18.png


by @pop3blow2



Pop culture comes at you fast.

If you read my other two Little Boots write ups for @soratami’s Quirky Girl Rates my love & adoration of one Victoria Hesketh is pretty clear.

Ironically though, in the summer of 2015 there was a disruption in the force. Three syllables : E•mo•tion. Three letters: CRJ.

I say ironically, because in the summer 2012, one Carly Rae Jepsen found herself in my angsty pop crosshairs. It wasn’t that I didn’t like her, but on more than one occasion I pretentiously pointed to ‘Call Me Maybe’ as a frustrating example of how the GP ‘gets it wrong’. I mean, how could a fine, but kinda mediocre song like ‘Call Me Maybe’ become a global hit & launch this former Canadian Idol Contestant to global acclaim… while my dear Little Boots was producing far superior music & languishing? It just wasn’t fair.

Oh, irony can be cruel.

Working Girl released in early July of 2015. Like her previous two albums, I was pretty hyped… though admittedly maybe slightly less so than the last two. There was no real reason for this. The album is a bit of a mood & that’s how it goes sometimes. I was enjoying the singles from the album & while the vibe was certainly different from her previous efforts, I was enjoying the indie-ness of the whole thing.

That said, after a month with the album it was starting to grow on me quite a bit more. Things were clicking. I really started appreciating the whole story that album was telling about nature of working women & a meta look at Little Boots as a self-made-indie-boss-lady.

It was clicking up until mid August when the booming of saxophone of track one of an a little album by that other aforementioned artist in this rate.

For all practical purposes my music year was over after hearing Emotion. The grip that album had on me was intense. Mandy Moore & Vanessa Carlton could’ve recorded an album together produced by Nelly Furtado & it would’ve struggled to get my full attention.

Slowly though, by the end of year, I started to assemble my year end playlists & revisit some other music. Emerging from my Carly-Rae haze, I was like, ‘oh yeah, Little Boots put out a record this past summer.’

So, I started to revisit more. Doing my typical weird comparison game…. I started to put it up track for track against Emotion. It was then that I started to realize how truly amazing it was. Since I had decided Emotion was the ’Thriller’ of its generation , I basically landed on Working Girl being the ‘1999’. Yeah, I know, come for me…. I guess!

Sometimes my brain applies macro concepts to my little micro world. This comparison is probably the perfect example of that! Not only were Michael Jackson & Prince on a complete other level of global stardom in 1982 than my two beloved pop queens, they were, well, men. This creates a whole other interesting cultural lens for my brain to dissect the two albums through, but I’ll have to that another time.

Sonically the the comparison hold up a little. Emotion had its experimental moments, but was designed to be perfect pop record in the tradition of those great albums of the 80s. Working Girl on the other hand, was clearly the work of someone in a more experimental mode. It’s a concept album for all practical purposes. Sure there are bops on Working Girl, but there’s also a certain anxiety & very millennial claustrophobia that run through a lot of the album.

Of course, commercially speaking that analogy is trash for both albums, but on artistic level I think the comparison holds up to an extent. Also, growing up I read more than my fair share of pieces about Thriller. There were some for 1999, but it clearly felt overshadowed. In recent years though, I feel the album getting more love & pointing to just how important it was.

Really the macro/micro comparison I’m clinging onto here stems from one thing. Much like Thriller sucked most of the oxygen out of the pop discussion in 1982, Emotion did that for me in 2015. There was a period where literally noting else mattered & honestly I’m still waiting to hear something else that capture my imagination the same way.

Even Little Boots would become a smitten fan of our dear Carly though, eventually penning ‘Crying On The Inside’ as a song with her mind. What makes me cry on the inside is just how poorly two of my favorite pop people of all time fare commercially. *sigh*

While this rate included a couple of great songs from the album, there are sooooo many highlights on Working Girl. I could go on here much longer. ‘Help Too’ is the one, though. It’s quite possibly my second favorite Little Boots songs of all time (will anything ever top ’Stuck On Repeat’?), which is really all I need to say. Buried 10 tracks into this masterpiece of an album is 5 minutes of lush vulnerability I don’t think she’s topped since. It’s the only collaboration with Dan Nigro on the album & it’s so special. I can’t decide if I want her to work more with him or if I want this song to just exist as one-off state of perfection.

Our fantastic host & I had a tough decision nailing down the Little Boots’ songs for the this rate. The parameters were needed for the rate to even happen in fair way, but leaving so many potentially great Boots songs on the sideline was painful.

I fought for ’No Pressure’ which sonically I think captures the overall vibe of the album better than anything. ’Taste It’ & ‘FROOT’ will forever remain tied together in my head. Not only do they kinda tackle some of the same concepts through similar metaphors, but they came out around the the same time. It’s every bit as quirky as ‘FROOT’, too. I fear it would’ve gotten destroyed here, though. (It is the most played song from the album on Spotify, which is a tad interesting to me.)

‘Real Girl’ & Business Pleasure’ also deserve a quick shout out, here. I also love the little interludes that tie the album together. It really is a complete work.

Ultimately, for this die-hard Little Boots fan Working Girl has become my favorite album by her. I really do think it’s a bit of a masterpiece & I wish it got more attention. Maybe its day will come.

“In my head a thousand words
I don't want to cause you trouble
Without you I'm just a girl
No reward without the struggle
I've tried so hard”



 
#2


Jessie-Ware-What-s-Your-Pleasure.jpg


WHAT'S YOUR PLEASURE?

JESSIE WARE 1/6
9.19
11 (3) @2014 @Aester
@m_dimitrov | 10 (23) @dontkillmyvibe @Sleet soratami @No hay banda @boombazookajoe @pop3blow2 @spaceship @Butterfly @Stradiwhovius @eatyourself @godspeed @Ana Raquel @Island @klow @Remorque @Trinu 3.0 @Untouchable Ace @Verandi @Oleander @Trouble in Paradise @berserkboi @Music Is Death @Serg. | 9.75 @Conan
6 @lovechoerrymotion | 6.5 @aux

#4 - #2 - #2 - #2 - #2

Putting up a great fight, even if it never actually managed to reach the #1 spot at any point throughout the voting period, despite coming very close at points, it's time to say goodbye to our runner-up What's Your Pleasure?... and with it to this rate's last chance of being represented in the next winners rate, oh well. To think out of the four winners we've had (Cosmic Love, Green Light, Number One Fan and now Froot), Number One Fan is the only one to appear in the winners rate... Well, the other three are so excellent, it's no wonder they won multiple rates. Back to What's Your Pleasure, it is, fittingly, the song with the second most 10s in the rate, coming second only to the winner, and also tied for the second most 11s, once again, only less than Froot. It's also the last of the only six songs in the rate not to get any scores below 6.

What's Your Pleasure?, which, just like Spotlight, was written by Jessie, Shungudzo, Danny Parker and James Ford and produced by the latter, was released in July 2020 as the sixth single from the album of the same name. Speaking about it, Jessie said "we had been writing and writing all day, and nothing was working. We’d gone for a lunch, and we were like, ‘You know, sometimes this happens.’ Later, we were just messing about, and I was like, ‘I really want to imagine that I’m in the Berghain and I want to imagine that I’m dancing with someone and they are so suggestive, and anything goes.’ It’s sex, it’s desire, it’s temptation. We were like, ‘Let’s do this as outrageously as possible.’ So we imagined we were this incredibly confident person who could just say anything. When we wrote it, it just came out—20 minutes and then it was done. James came up with that amazing beat, which almost reminds me of a DJ Shadow song. We were giggling the whole time we were writing it. It’s quite poppy accidentally, but I think with the darkness of all the synths, it’s just the perfect combination”. Hearing the creation process described like that is pretty endearing honestly. What's Your Pleasure? is just it, an absolutely immaculate banger in every way. I've been a huge fan of Jessie from the start, but there's no denying this is one things she's ever released. Running is and will probably always be my #1, but this definitely comes close. I really would have loved for this to win even if I do like Froot more because, as I mentioned above, it'd mean this rate would have a new winner rather than a repeat one, but honestly, coming second only to a mammoth like Froot in a rate as stacked as this is in itself a win.


@DJHazey (9) "It would be an amazing experience to hear this playing as you walked into a high-class adult establishment. My first thought was having it on the same strip club playlist that Goldfrapp was on in one of the GTA games."

@Isobel (9.5) "Sleek and dangerous. I have this on a playlist next to “One Night in Bangkok” and the transition is next level – try it!"

@R27 (9.5) "It’s a shame we couldn’t have rated more songs from What’s Your Pleasure? so Jessie could have showered with more high scores."

@pop3blow2 (10) “Someone who understands how to make your title track go off.”

@spaceship (10) "Obviously always knew how talented Jessie is but this song really painted her in a new light for me."

@Stradiwhovius (10) "Did anyone ever think to ask what Jessie's pleasure was?"

@godspeed (10) "She’s insane for that one."

@Trouble in Paradise (10) "This should be my 11 and should win this rate if Florence doesn't. Jessie said oh the faguettes are jealous of me getting dicked down by my DILF of a husband and are calling me boring, time to DECIMATE THEM! And with laser sharp accuracy she vaporized us. Special shout out to the dance video with the most attractive person in the world owning every minute on the screen."

@berserkboi (10) "What kind of Goldfrapp amazingness???"

@Aester (11) "Per Spotify, this was my most played song of 2020 and 2021. It will probably be up there for 2022 too. It is a slinky, soul-saving bop of the highest order, and I will always be grateful to Jessie for giving us such an excellent album to escape with during the worst days of the pandemic."





 
#1

MARINA-Froot.jpg


FROOT

MARINA 1/6
9.364
11 (5) @No hay banda @Crisp X @Butterfly @Stradiwhovius @Maki | 10 (24) @DJHazey @Dijah. @BubblegumBoy @dontkillmyvibe @2014 @Sleet @unnameable soratami @Aester @MilesAngel @m_dimitrov @eatyourself @Ana Raquel @Phonetics Girl @Island @Attis @j267 @Trinu 3.0 @Untouchable Ace @Oleander @Trouble in Paradise @berserkboi @Music Is Death @Conan | 9.25 (2) @pop3blow2 @R27
5 @lovechoerrymotion | 6 @boombazookajoe

#1 - #1 - #1 - #1 - #1

And we have our winner! With the most 10s, the most 11s, and staying at the top position throughout the voting period, Froot really dominated the rate. Which isn't to say it wasn't at times close, there were definitely points when it really looked like What's Your Pleasure? or Spotlight could overtake it, but it never quite happened. It was only on the 32nd/33rd voter mark, when What's Your Pleasure? got two back to back 6s from @j267 and @Sprockrooster, who gave Froot a 10 and a 9, respectively, that I knew it'd be very hard for anything to overtake Froot. And so it went, with Froot eventually ending up a full 8 points ahead of the runner-up. While as I mentioned Froot winning means this rate won't feature in the next winners rate, it does mean Froot gets to join its Quirky Pop Rate winning sisters Cosmic Love and Green Light in the elite multiple rate winners club.

Froot was released in November 2014 as the lead single, and first Froot of the Month (represented by grapes), from the album of the same name, Marina's third. While in her sophomore Electra Heart Marina worked with many of the biggest songwriters and producers in the game, such as Stargate, Rick Nowels and Greg Kurstin, for her third project Marina wanted to show she didn't need all that, and so she wrote the entire album by herself, and co-produced it with a single other producer, David Korsten. Marina described Froot as "the most eccentric song on the record. It has disco-inspired production, which shocked even me because I do not like funky music. But somehow it infused itself in the track and it’s definitely one of the oddest tracks I’ve done." and, as for the song's meaning, "I think a lot of people assume it's about sex, but it's not. Strictly. Most of it is not. It's really about being ready for happiness, and being ready to love somebody, and being fully-realised as a person. I like that it's a really positive message to start on. I needed that. It would've been easy to go with something like Happy, which is a ballad and kind of stripping everything back to its bare bones, and I felt like that would be predictable." So, wow, WHAT. A. SONG. There have been many, many amazing songs in these rates, but it's rare for one to just stop you on track and really just be in awe of the talent on display. Off the top of my head, Little Boots' Stuck on Repeat (the 7 minute version), is the only one that has the same effect on me. Between the unconventional structure, the extremely evocative lyrics, the production and Marina's beautiful vocals, it's just... brilliant and an absolutely perfect song. The way the song is five minutes and a half long and yet it feels like it goes by in a flash and you just want to play it again as soon it finishes? The way every single line in the song is memorable? The way the song is somehow literally hook after hook despite its structure and length? That fact that all of the above is true, when Marina wrote the entire thing by herself? THAT is talent. And, without a doubt, an extremely deserving winner.

@saviodxl (8.5) "The storytelling here is bigger than the melody, but the end result is fruitful. See what I did there?"

@godspeed (8.5) "As someone who’s not really a fan of MARINA’s music, this might be one of my favorite songs of hers. It’s catchy but not as obvious and over-the-top as the Electra Heart album while still serving just the right amount of ridiculousness and disco-flavored bopery – and 5 years before this was even a trend nonetheless!"

@Isobel (9) "Of everything here, this really waves the QUIRKY POP banner. The songwriting is truly bizarre, in the most wonderful way. That verse about the birds and worms is WILD."

@spaceship (9) "It's simply a fun song. You just have to get it to get it."

@Sprockrooster (9) "WHEW. The way this pops off after those two half baked Lorde songs in the playlist. Soratami placing this next... the mind of a mastermind"

@pop3blow2 (9.25) “I know ’Taste It’ by Little Boots was ruled out for this rate, but this song & that one are bonded in my brain. They both came out the same month & seemed to be tapping into some of the same things.”

@DJHazey (10) "The Marina song everyone gets behind and I have no arguments against it. What a bop that only Marina could pull off."

@unnameable (10) "I love Marina at her poppiest"

@Phonetics Girl (10) "I support FROOT Supremacy, yes dear! it's a once in a career behemoth and my raspberry's still swirling [Tori Amos reference, look it up if you haven't welcomed From the Choir Girl Hotel into your life yet] along to its thicc melodies"

@Attis (10) "Serving camp right in the eye"

@Trouble in Paradise (10) "I'm glad Marina and the Diamonds released this top tier bop before retiring."

@berserkboi (10) "Okay - this is actually pretty fantastic, you win this one ‘The Marinas!’ "

@Crisp X (11) "Honestly I think Marina peaked with this. It sounds like nothing else on earth, it’s completely bonkers and accessible at the same time thanks to the neverending amount of hooks and memorables lyrics."

@Stradiwhovius (11) "This is mostly me projecting I'm sure but this song feels like such a rich text. On the surface the song is really just a groovy beat and sexy fruit puns, but her career trajectory and themes since suggests a bit more to me. When she sings 'I've been saving all my summers for you' hugging her faceless lover in the video she looks miserable. And from what she's said since about Love + Fear being written while she was quite depressed and sort of deluding herself… It feels to me like the same thing is going on here? That saving all your summers is futile, tragic even. Intentional or not, it creates an interesting picture where you think you have what you want but still aren't happy. And since Froot, maybe realising that… Summer can't last forever. "





 
Well, shit.


Very happy to see that Froot has comfortably cinched this! I've spoken quite a few times here about how it and the rest of the album helped me through a really rough time of my first year at university. And maybe it's because Prioritise Pleasure and If My Wife New I'd Be Dead are fulfilling something similar through another rough patch I'm going through at the moment but it will always hold a special place in my heart for that. I might not often listen to, or even relate particularly strongly with, tracks like Happy or I'm A Ruin any more. But Froot has survived as a mainstay of my most played. A song that has just resonated with me and that I've processed in a range of different iterations over the years.

It also slaps.

Thank you as ever for hosting, @soratami. There have been some... interesting results in this rate. But as much as I do enjoy Venus Fly Trap more than most of the voters I'd shove it under a bus for Froot in a heartbeat.
 

Top