Discussion in 'Charts, rates etc' started by soratami, Sep 13, 2019.
Do nawt let me forget to vote! Great choices all around.
10 @elektroxx @Rei Ayanami @vague @londonrain | @berserkboi @Music Is Life @Conan
2.5 @CasuallyCrazed | 4 @Empty Shoebox | 6 @livefrommelbs @abael
My score: 9
5: #21 (8.4)
10: #29 (8.45)
15: #25 (8.357)
20: #32 (8.025)
25: #34 (7.78)
30: #39 (7.783)
35: #38 (7.909)
All: #40 (7.866)
Call Me was released in April 2002 as the second single from Tweet's debut album Southern Hummingbird, which had been released two weeks before. Like Oops (Oh My) beofre it, it was written by Tweet and Missy Elliott and produced by Timbaland. It charted at #31 in the Billboard Hot 100, at #9 in the Billboard R&B/Hip-Hop chart and at #35 in the UK, making it Tweet's second biggest hit in both countries (after Oops (Oh My) obviously). It also did decently in Australia and a few other countries.
Call Me seemed to be a song y'all generally liked but didn't love, as shown by the lack of 10s (tied with two other songs for the second least in the top 40) and of commentary as well. It didn't received many low scores either however, hence the middle of the board placement. The song received a radio mix for its European release, which makes it pop a lot more than the relatively mellow original, and I imagine would have bumped its score somewhat. I know it would have made me give it a 10 instead of a 9, but unfortunately I only found out about it after the reveals had already started.
Appelle mon numéro:
@godspeed (7.5) "Timbaland and Missy Elliott are behind this track once again. This is ultimately a very catchy song with a great hip hop-infused beat, but it lacks a bit of character and is a bit faceless. Tweet has shown a lot of personality and charisma in the rest of her singles discography so I think this already good song could have been much more than what it is."
@Untouchable Ace (8.8) Although it seems reminiscent of other big songs it's solid.
@lalaclairi_ (9) Not as good as "Call Me, Beep Me", but Christina Milian's teen pop era was great overall. (Speaking of Call Me, Beep Me!, don't forget to vote in R&B BOP QUEENS RATE PART II: THE FAN FAVOURITES)
@berserkboi (9.5) Quite awesome!
@Music Is Life (9.5) I wanna dance. I really wanna dance.
@Rei Ayanami Call Me (10) Was always my favorite Tweet song.
Side note, how stunning is Tweet? A literal goddess.
And with that, Tweet joins Ashanti in the "two songs left" club. I'd said this batch of six eliminations were by six different acts, and Christina, Kelis, Ashanti and Tweet already lost one each. Guesses for the other two? A hint: one of the two songs has the least 10s in the top 40.
"Is It You" and "Million Dollar Girl" perhaps?
I desperately want all of Keri's songs with Timbaland to leave, but I'll settle for just one to start. Return the Favor, please?
"The Way I Are" is iconic though.
Can't wait to dive into the Part II songs!
Not to throw a spanner in the works @soratami but I did also pick Do It f/ Lil Wayne as my fave not included from Christina Milian, so it should be in the list.
Submitted my ballot for Part II. Here are my averages:
Amerie – 9.10
Ashanti – 9.75
Cassie – 6.88
Christina Milian – 9.57
Ciara – 9.07
Kelis – 9.6
Keri Hilson – 8.75
Tweet – 8.63
We love to see this!
Oh, I'm sorry, I just realised I completely missed your extra picks! Might have been because yours was the last ballot I received and at that point I was more focused on starting the eliminations that the extra songs. I'm going to tally them now and see how they change things.
So, with @Butterfly's favourites added to the list, Ciara got one more individual voter pick:
Livin' It Up (feat. Nicki Minaj) (@Butterfly)
And more importantly, these two are now part of the rate:
I already added them to the song list/playlist, so don't forget to score them!
What a shame Finest Dreams only got one vote though. I forgot about it when picking my faves, but if I hadn't I might've gone for it.
Scream (Timbaland feat. Keri Hilson & Nicole Scherzinger)
Keri Hilson 8/9
10 @londonrain @Sprockrooster @Riiiiiiiii @Music Is Life @Untouchable Ace @Conan @Remorque | 9.5 @livefrommelbs @godspeed
4 @abael | 5 @Hurricane Drunk @Empty Shoebox @Verandi
My score: 8
5: #44 (7.5)
10: #53 (7.845)
15: #44 (7.818)
20: #35 (7.91)
25: #39 (7.688)
30: #44 (7.623)
35: #42 (7.863)
All: #39 (7.87)
Scream was released in November 2007 as the fourth single from Timbaland's second album Shock Value, which came out during Timbaland's mid-late 00s commercial peak and nearly 10 years after his debut. The song was written by Timbaland, Keri and Danja and produced by Timbaland and Danja. Keri and Timbaland were frequent collaborators, and she also appears in two other songs in the album - The Way I Are and Miscommunication. Scream was a big hit in Europe, charting at #12 in the UK and in the top 10/20 in several other countries, and it also charted at #20 in Australia, but it didn't do much in the US, not even making the top 100 (it peaked at #22 in the Bubbling Under charts), which is surprising given the album's three previous singles all made top 3. The US really wasn't here for solo Nicole at all huh?
I have to say Scream I've never liked Scream all that much, and it's definitely my least favourite song Keri song here. Listening to it for the rate actually made me appreciate it a bit more, but it's for me it's still only nice enough, it's no The Way I Are or Give It to Me, that's for sure. All the moaning is a bit much, and let's not even get into the mess that is Timbaland's spoken outro (which admittedly isn't in the single version, so we could just ignore it). Y'all were generally here for it though, with it receiving seven 10s and also the highest lowest score so far.
@Verandi (5) A song featuring both Keri and Nicole should be much much better than this. The production is weak, the chorus is weak, the final dirty talk by Timbo is a hate crime. A lost opportunity but hey at least it gave us Nicole faking an orgasm?
@Rei Ayanami (6) I do like the “can I have some of your cookies?” part.
@berserkboi (8.2) Should be better considering who is involved…
Let it all out:
@slaybellz (8.5) This is so much better than "The Way I Are", why did it get half the attention? Timbaland's awful vocals took me out of it near the end though. (Better than The Way I Are? I don't think so sweaty)
@livefrommelbs (9.5) Struggling to articulate why this one slaps so hard. It's sultry, sensual and kinda dark and moody all at once. So good.
@godspeed (9.5) "The Shock Value album was a moment in this boy life and this particular song was, of course, a big part of it. I remember how special it felt to have Nicole Scherzinger and Keri Hilson on the same track at the time it was released. I miss 2007! Anyway, this is brilliant. Another great Timbaland joint. The background vocals on the breakdown after Nicole's verse are an especially nice moment!"
@Sprockrooster (10) Oh, I am screaming. YES.
@Music Is Life (10) Loving that chorus. Actually loving this in general. That production is so good. And their vocals are great.
Legends only (except for will.i.am):
Boy was that one overdue! Thank goodness it's out!
(Will remember to put more distance between favourites and non-favourites in Part 2 - that's for sure Ddddd)
Keri not losing a song between #62 and #39 is the longest gap in the rate between two cuts from the same section.
Next up is the sixth out of the six eliminations from different sections, so that means either Amerie, Cassie or Ciara are losing a song.
I'm going to the part 2 playlist right now and I love how varied it is. Christina definitely made some points on Call Me, Beep Me!
I forgot what the Scream single cover looked like. It's really a crime against taste and Photoshop.
An undeserved loss. Wtf
Separate names with a comma.