r2.0: The Charli XCX Discography Rate 2021-22: Winner Crowned.

What is your favorite Charli XCX project?

  • Heartbreaks and Earthquakes

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Super Ultra

    Votes: 1 0.9%
  • True Romance

    Votes: 21 18.4%
  • Sucker

    Votes: 4 3.5%
  • Vroom Vroom EP

    Votes: 3 2.6%
  • Number 1 Angel

    Votes: 16 14.0%
  • Pop 2

    Votes: 39 34.2%
  • Charli

    Votes: 7 6.1%
  • How I'm Feeling Now

    Votes: 22 19.3%
  • XCX World

    Votes: 1 0.9%

  • Total voters
    114
she/her
That's a way better placement than what I imagined, so I've got no complaints here. That's peak pure pop Charli and to me, it's still far from being outshined.

Great top 5, btw!
 

2014

Staff member
DBSaqca.gif



5.

i8ymivlibvr41.jpg


forever
9.225

Highest scorers = 11 x 1 @Petty Mayonnaise & 10 x 31 @Andy French @aux @blissteria @boombazookajoe @clowezra @Crisp X @Cutlery @digitalkaiser @DinahLee @eatyourself @fatyoshi @finito @FunkyButChic @Glitterizer @Heartthrob @Jwentz @Laurence @lovechoerrymotion @MmmDani @Mr Blonde @Mushroom @nikkysan @No hay banda @ohnostalgia @Remorque @RUNAWAY @sesita @supercut @superultra @tea @unnameable
Lowest scorers = 7 x 3 @Conan @Phonetics Girl @tylerc904 7.5 x 1 @KingBruno



Whew, and just like that we're down to our final 4 with only 3 projects still left in tact; how I'm feeling now leading single forever bows out at a highly respectable 5th alternative. Not much good is to be remembered of 2020, but it did gift us a Charli lockdown album; she set herself a task to create a whole album in a certain number of weeks, with help from fans and friends to make it her most personal ever, and I don't think anyone could have really hoped for anything half as good as what we received - she did that.

forever had a huge job of being the first to represent what Charli was creating through quarantine, and it truly delivered; a ballad about wanting to be in someone's life forever, through the good and the bad, was completely relatable especially given what everyone around the world was going through in that time period. Premiered by Annie Mac in April 2020, it was produced by BJ Burton. Charli worked alongside her fans in order to select a single cover for the song, and famous friends such as Caroline Polachek also pitched in their ideas. This sense of collaboration between artist and fans was so good and a nice little, more fun distraction, from all the....everything else that was going on! It was listed by Pitchfork as one of their best singles of 2020 and how I'm feeling now itself was lauded by critics, getting a Mercury nod being included in multiple end of year lists.

For music that came out of such a tricky situation, I think it's all so extremely important in how relevant it was, and it all manages to stand up on its own merits because Charli's creative control blasts through, and while it's inevitable the whole record will be forever looked back as 'that lockdown album', it is much more than that and seeing the response it got in this rate, I think it'll forever go down as one of Charli's greatest achievements and something that helped bring a lot of us altogether through the hardest of times.









 

2014

Staff member
giphy.gif



4.

1275929.jpg


Unlock It (with Kim Petras x Jay Park)
9.389

Highest scorers = 11 x 2 @Aester @slaybellz & 10 x 38 @AllGagaLike @allyshone @Ana Raquel @Andy French @askew @blissteria @boombazookajoe @clowezra @Conan @Crisp X @ctrclub @Cutlery @digitalkaiser @eatyourself @Elysium @evilsin @fatyoshi @Glitterizer @iRyan @Jersey @Jwentz @KingBruno @klow @Laurence @Los Ageless @lovechoerrymotion @LukePreston @MmmDani @Mr Blonde @Mushroom @Petty Mayonnaise @Remorque @Remyky22 @RUNAWAY @sesita @sexercise @superultra @unnameable
Lowest scorers = 6 x 1 @2014 7 x 1 @GimmeWork



Welp here it is - I'm the lowest scorer of a song that's received (by quite a margin) the most 10s yet in the rate. Cancel me as the rate host nn. But seriously, Pop 2 fared superbly here getting 2 tracks in the top 5, but it can't quite get them both in the final 3 as Unlock It has to take up 4th spot. It's a cute song and I love Charli's bit and the infectious chorus and the production but....this is another example for me of the features not really living up to their surroundings. Maybe a 6 is harsh, but I really obviously wasn't feeling it when it came to rating. Out of this final 4 it is easily the weakest for me, but I'm glad to see the major love for it - I'm missing taste here it seems.

Featuring Kim Petras and Jay Park, Charli first came up with the signature hook on the way to a Halsey show (ha impact). Pitchfork described it as 'over-the-top and blissfully artificial' and it is a bit of a sugar-rush, huh? Produced by the ever reliable A.G. and Life Sim, it samples Cook's own track Beautiful and managed a resurgence last year thanks to TikTok. Unlock It was released as a promotional single on Dec 15th 2017, and hyped everyone up even more for the whole project. Charli x Kim have worked extensively together since then and on this song more than ever I feel like their vocals are so similar? It's a fine enough song overall but it is a weaker moment on Pop 2 and it wouldn't feature in my own personal top 10 teebs x








 

Top