☽ Rate Talent. Rate LOOΠΔ. ☾ the pre-debut rate • FINISHED | The Popjustice Forum

☽ Rate Talent. Rate LOOΠΔ. ☾ the pre-debut rate • FINISHED

Discussion in 'K-pop' started by vague, Sep 1, 2018.

  1. [​IMG]

    Fifty tracks.
    Twelve girls.
    Three units.
    Two years in the making . . .

    Exactly two years ago, on September 1st, 2016, the LOOΠΔ pre-debut project kicked off with the unveiling of the group's first member, HeeJin. Her self-titled solo single album followed a month later on October 5th. Between October 2016 and May 2018, eleven more girls, three sub-units, thirty music videos, and over fifty tracks were released. Finally, on August 19th, LOOΠΔ officially debuted at their first concert, LOOΠΔbirth.

    To celebrate their debut, and all they've accomplished in the last two years, let's get to rating!



    ☽ SONG LIST ☾
    [​IMG]
    HeeJin
    01 ViViD × music video
    02 ViViD (Acoustic Mix) × music video



    [​IMG]
    HyunJin
    01 다녀가요 (Around You) × music video
    02 I'll Be There × music video



    [​IMG]
    HaSeul
    01 소년, 소녀 (Let Me In) × music video
    02 The Carol × music video



    [​IMG]
    YeoJin
    01 키스는 다음에 (Kiss Later) × music video
    02 My Sunday × music video
    03 My Melody × music video



    [​IMG]
    Love&Live
    01 Into the New Heart *
    02 지금, 좋아해 (Love&Live) × music video
    03 You and Me Together × music video
    04 Fairy Tale
    05 3월을 기다려 (Valentine Girl) × lyric video



    [​IMG]
    ViVi
    01 Everyday I love you (feat. HaSeul) × music video
    02 Everyday I need you (feat. JinSoul) × music video



    [​IMG]
    Love&Evil
    01 Love&Evil *
    02 알 수 없는 비밀 (Sonatine) × music video
    03 비의 목소리 51db (Rain 51db) × music video



    [​IMG]
    Kim Lip
    01 Eclipse × music video
    02 Twilight



    [​IMG]
    JinSoul
    01 Singing in the Rain × music video
    02 Love Letter



    [​IMG]
    Choerry
    01 Love Cherry Motion × music video
    02 Puzzle



    [​IMG]
    Mix&Match
    01 ODD *
    02 Girl Front × music video
    03 LOONATIC × lyric video
    04 Chaotic
    05 Starlight



    [​IMG]
    Max&Match
    01 ADD *
    02 Sweet Crazy Love × music video
    03 Uncover
    04 ODD Front



    [​IMG]
    Yves
    01 new × music video
    02 D-1



    [​IMG]
    The Carol 2.0
    01 The Carol 2.0 × lyric video



    [​IMG]
    Chuu
    01 Heart Attack × music video
    02 Girl's Talk



    [​IMG]
    Go Won
    01 One&Only × music video
    02 See Saw (feat. Kim Lip)



    [​IMG]
    Olivia Hye
    01 Egoist (feat. JinSoul) × music video
    02 Rosy (feat. HeeJin)



    [​IMG]
    beauty&thebeat
    01 dal segno *
    02 love4eva (feat. Grimes) × music video
    03 frozen
    04 one way
    05 rendezvous 18.6y



    [​IMG]
    favOriTe
    01 favOriTe × music video



    ☽ RULES ☾
    01 Please give all 44 songs listed above a score between 0 and 10, with your ONE favorite song getting an 11. Decimals points (.1, .25, .5, .75, etc.) are allowed, but keep it simple, please. I've created a song sorter for myself to help with my own scores; it may be useful to some of y'all, as well.
    02 The 5 asterisked intro tracks are also mandatory rating. They will, however, be ranked separately before the main rate begins.
    03 Commentary is greatly encouraged and very much appreciated since I'm typically a hoe of few words, but it's not mandatory.
    04 Please don't troll. I understand with a discography as diverse as LOOΠΔ's, everyone is not going to like every song, but, like, be reasonable.
    05 PM your finished scores, alongside any commentary you've written, to me by:
    October 7th @ 11:59 pm EST / 8:59 pm PST /
    October 8th @ 4:59 am BST / 5:59 am CEST / 8:29 am AFT / 11:59 am CST / 1:59 pm AEST.

    (dddd i hope that covers everyone's time zones - if not use this.)
    An extension is always a possibility, but, for now, count on votes being due then.
    06 Most importantly, have fun and stan LOOΠΔ! ❤​
     
    Last edited: Oct 1, 2018
  2. [​IMG]



    ViViD -
    ViViD (Acoustic Mix) -
    Around You -
    I'll Be There -
    Let Me In -
    The Carol -
    Kiss Later -
    My Sunday -
    My Melody -
    Love&Live -
    You and Me Together -
    Fairy Tale -
    Valentine Girl -
    Everyday I love you (feat. HaSeul) -
    Everyday I need you (feat. JinSoul) -
    Sonatine -
    Rain 51db -

    Eclipse -
    Twilight -
    Singing in the Rain -
    Love Letter -
    Love Cherry Motion -
    Puzzle -
    Girl Front -
    LOONATIC -
    Chaotic -
    Starlight -
    Sweet Crazy Love -
    Uncover -
    ODD Front -

    new -
    D-1 -
    The Carol 2.0 -
    Heart Attack -
    Girl's Talk -
    One&Only -
    See Saw (feat. Kim Lip) -
    Egoist (feat. JinSoul) -
    Rosy (feat. HeeJin) -
    love4eva (feat. Grimes) -
    frozen -
    one way -
    rendezvous 18.6y -

    favOriTe -



    Into the New Heart -
    Love&Evil -
    ODD -
    ADD -
    dal segno -
     
    Last edited: Oct 2, 2018
  3. [​IMG]

    [​IMG]
    LOOПΔ 1/3 & YeoJin
    LOOПΔ / ODD EYE CIRCLE
    LOOПΔ / yyxy
    LOOПΔverse



    [​IMG]
    05 dal segno — 7.398
    04 Into the New Heart — 7.477
    03 Love&Evil — 7.523
    02 ADD — 7.670
    01 ODD — 7.920



    [​IMG]
    What's First Out?
    44 Fairy Tale — 5.259
    43 The Carol 2.0 — 5.306
    42 The Carol — 5.597
    What's Next Out?
    41 ViViD (Acoustic Mix) — 5.694

    40 one way — 5.935
    39 3월을 기다려 (Valentine Girl) — 5.981
    What's Next Out?
    38 Everyday I need you (feat. JinSoul) — 6.042
    37 키스는 다음에 (Kiss Later) — 6.310
    36 My Melody — 6.426
    What's Next Out?
    35 다녀가요 (Around You) — 6.528
    34 My Sunday — 6.593
    33 비의 목소리 51db (Rain 51db) — 6.708
    What's Next Out?
    32 rendezvous 18.6y — 7.056
    31 You and Me Together — 7.120

    30 Twilight — 7.287
    What's Next Out?
    29 Starlight — 7.315
    28 소년, 소녀 (Let Me In) — 7.375
    27 I'll Be There — 7.583
    What's Next Out?
    26 One&Only — 7.611
    25 지금, 좋아해 (Love&Live) — 7.639
    24 ViViD — 7.741
    What's Next Out?
    23 Puzzle — 7.787
    22 알 수 없는 비밀 (Sonatine) — 7.824
    21 See Saw (feat. Kim Lip) — 7.833

    What's Next Out?
    20 D-1 — 7.894
    19 ODD Front — 8.079
    18 Girl's Talk — 8.093
    17 Rosy (feat. HeeJin) — 8.194
    16 Everyday I love you (feat. HaSeul) — 8.199
    15 frozen — 8.208
    14 Chaotic — 8.347
    13 favOriTe — 8.389
    12 Uncover — 8.426
    11 Love Letter — 8.606




    [​IMG]
    SOLOS
    12 HyunJin — 6.849
    11 ViVi — 6.867
    10 HaSeul — 6.967
    09 HeeJin — 6.971
    08 YeoJin — 7.033
    07 Yves — 7.696
    06 Go Won — 7.729
    05 Chuu — 7.883
    04 Olivia Hye — 7.957
    03 Choerry — 8.183
    02 JinSoul — 8.352
    01 Kim Lip — 8.436

    UNITS
    03 LOOПΔ 1/3 — 6.799
    02 LOOПΔ / yyxy — 7.497
    01 LOOПΔ / ODD EYE CIRCLE — 8.486

    ETC.
    02 Intros — 7.580
    01 Songs — 7.670
    00 Voters — 7.661
     
    Last edited: Oct 28, 2018
  4. Well, well well.....the day has finally come. Looks like I will have to come out of rate commentary retirement as I have a lot of things to say and have a whole theme planned out.

    Fair warning: If y'all do Olivia wrong, I will burn the thread to the ground.

    [​IMG]

    That goes for both Egoist and Rosy, by the way.
     
  5. Hopefully we have no "But Kim Lip and Eclipse are so overrated !11!!!!! My favorite songs are The Carol and the masterpiece that is 'Around You'!!! ADELE IS SHOOK!!!!".

    But also...if you guys do Chuuriana Chuuyoncé Chuuline Dion Whitney Chuuston wrong, you might hear a word or two from me. xoxo
     
  6. This sounds like fun and the perfect opportunity to get to know them even better. I've been wondering for a while what fans might consider their best and worst songs. (The Carol for "worst" hopefully.)
     
    Last edited: Sep 1, 2018
    GeiPanda, He, evilsin and 4 others like this.
  7. IT'S YOU, MY FAVORITE (RATE)

    YATHHHHHH BINCH I'M READY
     
  8. AND BEFORE I FORGET

    If ugly singles (I won't name names) won over iconique b-sides like Love Letter and See Saw, there will be blood. Y'all have been warned.
     
  9. The graphics you've been doing recently are amazing, I can't wait to see the rest. @vague
     
    GeiPanda, ohnostalgia, He and 10 others like this.
  10. [​IMG]

    I'm ready.
     

  11. [​IMG]

    You know what binch, I almost voted for you in "Worst taste in KPop", but then I was like "Nah, I like our maknae, he's sweet" and voted for Salami and his obsession with Sooyoung's hairstyles or something - but now I can officially confirm that you are cancelled and you have the worst taste in KPop.

    Bye Binch xoxo

    [​IMG]
     
  12. And I thought YG's Dungeon was a messy thread. This could be worse.
     
    GeiPanda, ohnostalgia, He and 11 others like this.
  13. I can't wait to do this but also this is going to be so hard for me in terms of finishing... I feel like some of y'all won't like me after this rate haha
     
    evilsin, Island, vague and 5 others like this.
  14. Some of the opinions in this thread... we are on the first page.

    [​IMG]
     
  15. Dddd I actually gave a high score to Eclipse, I just like to joke about Yves being the superior Loona girl.


    And I've already submitted cause I'm quick like that.


    O
    EC : 7.5 (10 x 4; 5 x 3)
    yyxy : 7.38 (10 x 3; 3.5 x 1)
    1/3 : 5.13 (10 x 1; 2 x 1)

    [​IMG]
     
  16. Obsession, it was one time!
     
  17. I'm here and I'm ready to swing my lightsaber.

    [​IMG]
     
    Last edited: Sep 1, 2018
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.