I’ve given this way too much thought but indulge my nerdiness. Basically, I’ve a&r’ed their new album.
If I were them, I’d be going for the uplifting, carnival, house dance pop feel. Not EDM, dance with a bit of rhythm to it, so modern disco I suppose. The whole thing would feel like a celebration, genuinely fun songs, that are just beaming with sunshine (lol) and euphoria. Then I’d sprinkle in a few more mature pop/R&b mid-tempos and one or two classic, big, shameless ballads.
I’ve scoured my library and I think these songs all have an “S Club in 2023” vibe (more in terms of vibe, not necessarily lyrically).
Louise - Straight to My Heart
This song completely sums up what I have in mind. The minute I heard it I was like “this sounds like a modern S Club song!”. It’s upbeat, euphoric, but it’s got that definite funky R&b warmth to it. This would be an absolute dream. It’s such a feel good, crowd pleaser of a song.
Justin Timberlake - Can’t Stop The Feeling
I’m well aware of what people think of him and this song, but you can’t deny, this is essentially a modern day Reach. Something like this which is undeniably pop would be amazing. The double chorus is a winner, and it’s incredibly well written. It’s got S Club written all over it, and if they had something this calibre it would be amazing.
HRVY and Matoma - Good Vibes
On paper, this should be naff but it’s so carefree and funky, there’s so much to enjoy. I think the fact it’s written by MNEK, somebody who just GETS pop is what makes the difference. It’s uplifting, but it’s got that harder, funkier bite to it. This would be a Paul/Bradley duet in an ideal world.
This is Heaven - Nick Jonas
This isn’t suitable lyrically but I could see this closing an S Club concert and it being magical. This gospel pop feels like a natural successor to midtempos like Let Me Sleep. Again, it’s euphoric and uplifting, and emotive, like all the best S Club songs.
Sigala - Feels This Good
I heard this on new music Friday and it clicked. It’s definitely more dance than other songs I have in mind, but again, it’s a genuine, feel good pop song. Sigala is great at these sunny, party bops. I can just hear Jo and Bradley all over this.
Dancing On a Sunny Day - Benjamin Ingrosso
This would be a Jon song, without a doubt. It’s a nice change of pace, to be more of a guitar, MOR type song, but again, it’s sunny and sparkly, like loads of great S Club songs.
Kylie - Magic
Again, this is just a classic, effortless pop song that leans more towards the funkier, disco vibe. Feels a bit obvious but this would be a flawless Rachel inclusion, and it fits alongside the more uptempo, disco-esque songs.
Zara Larsson - Look What You’ve Done
Another modern disco banger, with that sparkly, twinkly feel. Tina would be all over this.
Mabel - Let Love Go
This fits perfectly alongside the previous two songs, and has that cool, effortless, swooshy disco vibe. Another Rachel song.
Bruno Mars - Too Good to Say Goodbye
This is a bit out there but bear with. Basically, nobody does BIG, proper ballads any more, that break your heart and revel in the emotion. This is the most recent one I can think of, and although the production is definitely more classic soul than I would say suits S Club, the melody has shades of them throughout it.
Honourable mentions:
- Katy Perry - Birthday - Bit old and maybe “dated” now, but it’s so carefree and fun, S Club could nail it.
- Carly Rae Jepsen - Cut To The Feeling - Not 100% sure this feels like S Club, bit more 80s, but it’s the most euphoric song of probably the last decade, so it’s hardly a bad choice.
- Modern day versions of All In Love Is Fair, Show Me Your Colours, Never Had a Dream Come True - These are essential S Club songs but I can’t find modern day equivalents so I’d lock Cathy Dennis in a room and get her to write them.