D
Deleted member 29256
So stressful... I only have one 10!
#soon! Part Un - The 60s-00s Girl Band Debut Breakthrough Rate
- Thread starter berserkboi
- Start date
So stressful... I only have one 10!
He/Him
Time to say goodbye to a certified classic and winner of their era!
#7
70s Gold Medallist
The Emotions – Best Of My Love
Average Score: 8.336
Highest Score: 10 x 9 (@unnameable, @Remorque, @iheartpoptarts, @ohnostalgia, @2014, @londonrain, @Empty Shoebox, @Trouble in Paradise, @kermit_the_frog)
Lowest Score: 4 x 2 (@DJHazey, @DominoDancing)
#7
70s Gold Medallist
The Emotions – Best Of My Love
Average Score: 8.336
Highest Score: 10 x 9 (@unnameable, @Remorque, @iheartpoptarts, @ohnostalgia, @2014, @londonrain, @Empty Shoebox, @Trouble in Paradise, @kermit_the_frog)
Lowest Score: 4 x 2 (@DJHazey, @DominoDancing)
Here is where we lose our last song of the 70s (you're a winner, baby!!!), and the last not to garner a single 11! And what a classic it is! Best Of My Love is so tied with popular culture and moments of our life in general, it feels almost incorrect to even rate it? To me it somehow transcends my little rate with its charisma, charm and overall cultural impact, but no matter! - we did rate it and found it the #7 best track here. What a top end classic this is too! If this truly were PopJustice, it would most certainly be in the top 5 for how influential and timeless it is, but a slow gradual climb to #7 is still a very good result for it.
Despite not getting any 11s, I cannot say Best Of My Love struggled in the rate, it was always in the top 20 but the top 10 placements only came to be during the second half of voting. Some have been vocal about wanting this classic out and I have to assume it is due to them not connecting to the simple pleasure and euphoria of the track, possibly due to having expectations that were different to what they got? Because despite me giving it a 9.8 as opposed to a 10, I cannot fathom any reason to actively dislike a song like this!
Best Of My Love is everything a classic from the disco era should be – it is a happy track, with simple but well layered instrumental and vocals for days! The song was composed by Earth, Wind & Fire’s Maurice White and Al McKay, giving it that funky edge that a lot of their own tracks had. Best Of My Love was a huge success for The Emotions, getting them not just a breakthrough song (and qualifying for the rate here after being active since 1962 without a breakthrough!) but a #1 smash too, spending 5 weeks at the top of the Billboard Charts!
Best Of My Love won a Grammy in the Best R&B Performance by A Duo or Group With Vocals in 1978 as well as the American Music Award for favourite Soul/R&B Single. Critics still rave about the quality of the track to this day. The song was ranked #87 on The Billboard Hot 100 All Time Top Songs and #10 on Billboard’s 100 Greatest Girl Group Songs of All Time.
Despite being so decorated, it was an uphill battle for The Emotions to become the success they were in the late 70s. The band had been active since 1962 without a breakthrough on the main charts. The closest they got to was So I Can Love You in 1969 which got them to #39. The Emotions is made up of sisters Wanda, Sheila and Jeanette Hutchinson (with youngest sister Pamela filling in for Jeanette in 1977 when she left to give birth to her second child). Their biggest era came through their association with Earth, Wind & Fire including the song we are rating today and potential part 2 bop Boogie Wonderland. These days, the girls are still active and perform in TV specials a fair bit. They featured in Snoop Dogg’s single Life more recently.
Their music is often sampled, most notably on Mariah Carey’s two better hits Emotions and Dreamlover (the latter samples Blind Alley). Cheryl Lynn’s hit Got To Be Real is also based on Best Of My Love’s bridge. It is safe to say – even if you didn’t know Best Of My Love, you would be familiar with aspects of it through its long lasting influence on pop music.
What did so called PopJustice think of this one?
Zar-Unity (6) means funky, although with that abysmal score, maybe not - Pretty fucky, solid performance here! Nice rhythm! Tech: 4 Taste: 2 = 6 points. Kermit_The_Frog (10) can always be relied on for taste with receipts! - Proof that even “basic disco” (anything written for the charts but not by Chic or Giorgio Moroder) can be equally as wonderful as the pioneers - for people of my age (cough mid-late 30s), this has probably been ruined by local radio and TV adverts. It was only when I watched Boogie Nights that I rediscovered it with new ears. Now I have no shame - stone-cold classic…
Riiiiiiiii (9.7) keeps losing favourites as we get to the tail end of the competition - Very camp but very good. Spillett (8.5) thinks the block of Nolans, Baccarat and Emotions is one of the best ever! (it was the 70s top 3 after all! - (glad the latter part of the 70's allowed for some fantastic tunes after the rather dull released in the middle). Filippa (8) has swapped with DominoDancing as rate villain since the top 10 was revealed, but for how long? - Well, actually I own this song. It’s on one of these samplers I have bought … I love the voices and the energy of this song.
Trouble In Paradise (10) is all about facts are facts!! - Some songs are classics for a reason. Empty Shoebox (10) gives you a rundown of everything that works perfectly and succinctly - At least the girls give it three verses before repeating to fade. Outside of that, the arrangement is top notch and the 'non-lyrical vocals' (if that's a term. You know, the 'oh's and 'ahs') sound good without being too strained. It's a winner. Londonrain (10) returns to support a classic! - Amazing. I discovered this thirty years later through an American Idol performance and I still think the original is pure gold. What a song.
DominoDancing (4) gives this a surprisingly low score! - Boring. Lot's of big notes, no hooks. Iheartpoptarts (10) is all for hyperbole with this one! - As far as I’m aware this is the best song of the 70s, ever. Ufint (8) ‘s detective school classes are really paying off! - The fact that this sounds a lot like “Emotion” by Mariah Carey is the funniest thing about this. Like, can you believe it girls? Unnameable (10) is a classmate! – so good Mariah had to steal. DJHazey (4) was clearly not paying that much attention in class - I swear I've heard that chorus numerous times in my life and it's not getting any better, my apologies.
Despite not getting any 11s, I cannot say Best Of My Love struggled in the rate, it was always in the top 20 but the top 10 placements only came to be during the second half of voting. Some have been vocal about wanting this classic out and I have to assume it is due to them not connecting to the simple pleasure and euphoria of the track, possibly due to having expectations that were different to what they got? Because despite me giving it a 9.8 as opposed to a 10, I cannot fathom any reason to actively dislike a song like this!
Best Of My Love is everything a classic from the disco era should be – it is a happy track, with simple but well layered instrumental and vocals for days! The song was composed by Earth, Wind & Fire’s Maurice White and Al McKay, giving it that funky edge that a lot of their own tracks had. Best Of My Love was a huge success for The Emotions, getting them not just a breakthrough song (and qualifying for the rate here after being active since 1962 without a breakthrough!) but a #1 smash too, spending 5 weeks at the top of the Billboard Charts!
Best Of My Love won a Grammy in the Best R&B Performance by A Duo or Group With Vocals in 1978 as well as the American Music Award for favourite Soul/R&B Single. Critics still rave about the quality of the track to this day. The song was ranked #87 on The Billboard Hot 100 All Time Top Songs and #10 on Billboard’s 100 Greatest Girl Group Songs of All Time.
Despite being so decorated, it was an uphill battle for The Emotions to become the success they were in the late 70s. The band had been active since 1962 without a breakthrough on the main charts. The closest they got to was So I Can Love You in 1969 which got them to #39. The Emotions is made up of sisters Wanda, Sheila and Jeanette Hutchinson (with youngest sister Pamela filling in for Jeanette in 1977 when she left to give birth to her second child). Their biggest era came through their association with Earth, Wind & Fire including the song we are rating today and potential part 2 bop Boogie Wonderland. These days, the girls are still active and perform in TV specials a fair bit. They featured in Snoop Dogg’s single Life more recently.
Their music is often sampled, most notably on Mariah Carey’s two better hits Emotions and Dreamlover (the latter samples Blind Alley). Cheryl Lynn’s hit Got To Be Real is also based on Best Of My Love’s bridge. It is safe to say – even if you didn’t know Best Of My Love, you would be familiar with aspects of it through its long lasting influence on pop music.
What did so called PopJustice think of this one?
Zar-Unity (6) means funky, although with that abysmal score, maybe not - Pretty fucky, solid performance here! Nice rhythm! Tech: 4 Taste: 2 = 6 points. Kermit_The_Frog (10) can always be relied on for taste with receipts! - Proof that even “basic disco” (anything written for the charts but not by Chic or Giorgio Moroder) can be equally as wonderful as the pioneers - for people of my age (cough mid-late 30s), this has probably been ruined by local radio and TV adverts. It was only when I watched Boogie Nights that I rediscovered it with new ears. Now I have no shame - stone-cold classic…
Riiiiiiiii (9.7) keeps losing favourites as we get to the tail end of the competition - Very camp but very good. Spillett (8.5) thinks the block of Nolans, Baccarat and Emotions is one of the best ever! (it was the 70s top 3 after all! - (glad the latter part of the 70's allowed for some fantastic tunes after the rather dull released in the middle). Filippa (8) has swapped with DominoDancing as rate villain since the top 10 was revealed, but for how long? - Well, actually I own this song. It’s on one of these samplers I have bought … I love the voices and the energy of this song.
Trouble In Paradise (10) is all about facts are facts!! - Some songs are classics for a reason. Empty Shoebox (10) gives you a rundown of everything that works perfectly and succinctly - At least the girls give it three verses before repeating to fade. Outside of that, the arrangement is top notch and the 'non-lyrical vocals' (if that's a term. You know, the 'oh's and 'ahs') sound good without being too strained. It's a winner. Londonrain (10) returns to support a classic! - Amazing. I discovered this thirty years later through an American Idol performance and I still think the original is pure gold. What a song.
DominoDancing (4) gives this a surprisingly low score! - Boring. Lot's of big notes, no hooks. Iheartpoptarts (10) is all for hyperbole with this one! - As far as I’m aware this is the best song of the 70s, ever. Ufint (8) ‘s detective school classes are really paying off! - The fact that this sounds a lot like “Emotion” by Mariah Carey is the funniest thing about this. Like, can you believe it girls? Unnameable (10) is a classmate! – so good Mariah had to steal. DJHazey (4) was clearly not paying that much attention in class - I swear I've heard that chorus numerous times in my life and it's not getting any better, my apologies.
Final thought – A top cut to end our 70s era with, Best Of My Love depicts all the great sounds and influences of the era in 3.37 minutes (disco, funk, soul, R&B). A decorated classic too, it just feels right for it to be our last standing track of its era!
Expect a 70s recap
#soon!
ohnostalgia
Staff member
She/her
I cannot imagine listening to Best Of My Love and not feeling joy.
He/Him
Well, I can't really be mad at "Best" missing the top six (of my personal chart) -- especially seeing how it did after all beat Baccara AND showed why the best disco was always funky instead of.. you know, clunky and stolen and gimmicky and diluted for the central european masses heheh...
he/him
Loud and clear. My thoughts exactly on "If This Is Love".
she/her
I think I learned it from this.
Poor my life.
(Bop though.)
Poor my life.
(Bop though.)
Haha omg, yeah I definitely meant "funky"!
londonrain
Staff member
I feel this way about both If This Is Love and Best of My Love.
Both are songs that instantly lift my spirits.
He/Him
70s Recap
#57 - The Pointer Sisters - Yes We Can Can
----------------------------------------------------------
#50 - Silver Convention - Fly Robin Fly
#47 - Love Unlimited - Walkin' In The Rain (With The One That I Love)
#46 - High Inergy - You Can't Turn Me Off (In The Middle Of Turnin' Me On)
#43 - Sister Sledge - Mama Never Told Me
----------------------------------------------------------
#35 - Honey Cone - Want Ads
#32 - First Choice - Armed And Extremely Dangerous
----------------------------------------------------------
#30 - Peaches - Substitute
----------------------------------------------------------
#18 - The Three Degrees - When Will I See You Again?
#13 - The Nolans - I'm In The Mood For Dancing (70s Bronze)
----------------------------------------------------------
#8 - Baccara - Yes Sir, I Can Boogie (70s Silver)
#7 - The Emotions - Best Of My Love (70s Gold)
Average Placement: 32.166 / 60
So, this is how the decade fared with voters. Mid tier for you all with iconic Pointer Sisters & Sister Sledge some of the first casualties, a choice of sorts! One of my top pick (& discovery) of the decade - Love Unlimited is still one of the most shameful early exits, considering the experimental and seductive nature of the tune, still sounding fresh today. We will see how these acts all fare in Part 2 with some more signature numbers.
The music genre covered with this list veered very much into Disco, with strong Soul/R&B flavour and hints of funk mixed in. Sexual overtones started to come through in much of the lyric as well, with more flirty dance qualities than in the previous decade. An overall very pleasant decade, I didn't have a subpar score here. Initially the decade many felt would struggle the most with voters, some tunes did do very well for themselves, the 5 that made the top 30 namely, as well as Baccara almost winning the whole thing for 3/4 of the voting period! The sound of the 70s is very distinct and not often appreciated amongst the PopJustice crowd so I was very happy to bring some of these cuts to you, hope you enjoyed!
The music genre covered with this list veered very much into Disco, with strong Soul/R&B flavour and hints of funk mixed in. Sexual overtones started to come through in much of the lyric as well, with more flirty dance qualities than in the previous decade. An overall very pleasant decade, I didn't have a subpar score here. Initially the decade many felt would struggle the most with voters, some tunes did do very well for themselves, the 5 that made the top 30 namely, as well as Baccara almost winning the whole thing for 3/4 of the voting period! The sound of the 70s is very distinct and not often appreciated amongst the PopJustice crowd so I was very happy to bring some of these cuts to you, hope you enjoyed!
The other decades recap to come,
#soon!
Last edited:
she/her
As it should. Disco was great.
she/her
I didn't think I'd be here for the 70s but it was actually such bops!
And I cannot even remember Best Of My Love, despite listening to it numerous times for this rate.
she/her
If we're discussing songs that we can't really remember, Sugababes?
ohnostalgia
Staff member
She/her
I think you mean Girls Aloud.
she/her
That song still gets played on the radio here.
ohnostalgia
Staff member
She/her
Fortunately they were pretty much irrelevant in Canada.
she/her
Not for me! That's why I started reading PJ way back when, because the UK was having more fun than us.
D
Deleted member 26234
Then we are talking about Alzheimer, right?
londonrain
Staff member