Spice Girls

I love Darkchild but his production is SO him that it really did water down the spice. It felt like material any of the R&B groups at the time could have recorded. Some say it's because Geri wasn't there and she had a lot of input into lyrics and song ideas, some say the girls just weren't invested in the group anymore.. I think it was probably an amalgamation of it all. I do enjoy forever as a pop/R&B album by one of my favourite R&B producers but as a Spice Girls album it's lacking sadly.

But, on the flip side of this, the album does flow cohesively as a body of work. Sonically, the sound flows across each track and weaves them together collectively, which is both a positive and a negative.

A negative in the sense that coming from their Magnus Opus, ‘Spice World’ which was an array of sounds and styles, ‘Forever’ felt more generic than it should have been, when it actually is a good album.

As for the positives, the harmonies are a lot tighter and on certain tracks, you can hear all the girls singing their parts perfectly. It’s also distinctive enough that it stands up on its own, away from Spice World to be considered a really strong pop/R&B album in its own right.

The only thing I would have changed would have been to ditch ‘Time Goes By’, get Jimmy Jam & Terry Lewis to make 1 or 2 more hits in the same style as ‘If You Wanna Have Some Fun’ and include a few more of the funkier (unreleased) third album tracks alongside bringing the album to 13/14 tracks. If it were to be the final album, they could have made it a bigger collection and gone all out as they had the material.
 
Forever just becomes so anonymous after a couple of tracks. All I hear is sound, absolutely nothing stands out.

The songs are decent on their own but as a an album it's just so boring to listen to.
 
Forever just becomes so anonymous after a couple of tracks. All I hear is sound, absolutely nothing stands out.

The songs are decent on their own but as a an album it's just so boring to listen to.

Controversially, but this is how I feel about ‘Spice’ as an album. Apart from a handful of tracks tacked into a Spice Girls Playlist, it is the album of theirs I listen to least in its entirety.
 
Controversially, but this is how I feel about ‘Spice’ as an album. Apart from a handful of tracks tacked into a Spice Girls Playlist, it is the album of theirs I listen to least in its entirety.

I agree. For me, Forever is a more cohesive 'album' and I listen from beginning to end without skipping and it flows. It is still my most listened to Spice Girls album. Obviously though their biggest hits still are their best songs but Forever - for me - is their most 'listenable' album as a whole. Weird really?
 
I agree. For me, Forever is a more cohesive 'album' and I listen from beginning to end without skipping and it flows. It is still my most listened to Spice Girls album. Obviously though their biggest hits still are their best songs but Forever - for me - is their most 'listenable' album as a whole. Weird really?

No not at all, and that is exactly how I feel too. Especially when I curate a playlist with the girls solo material - songs like ‘Tell Me’, ‘We’re Not Gonna Sleep Tonight’, ‘Let Your Baby Show You How to Move’, ‘This Groove’Let Your Head Go’ and a few others - they tend to gel together better. This is probably as they came from the same cloth/sound they were working within at the time, but it feels like a more cohesive era.
 
There was a pop album before they went the Forever route. We have all these leaks, WOMAN being on the setlist in Christmas in SpiceWorld. Too bad we didn’t get that one when they recorded it (they did a book ForeverSpice in 1999 while they were recording third album). I mean Forever is a good album and it aged very well (I listen to it now and then), but when I listen to all those leaked songs they are more “Spice” in the vein of Spice and Spice World.

I know we won't get Forever25 with all those songs being polished but one can dream.
 
There was a pop album before they went the Forever route. We have all these leaks, WOMAN being on the setlist in Christmas in SpiceWorld. Too bad we didn’t get that one when they recorded it (they did a book ForeverSpice in 1999 while they were recording third album). I mean Forever is a good album and it aged very well (I listen to it now and then), but when I listen to all those leaked songs they are more “Spice” in the vein of Spice and Spice World.

I know we won't get Forever25 with all those songs being polished but one can dream.

This is why I created my own version of Forever with the leaked tracks (see track listing above). They fit perfectly and just add another dimension to the album. Plus, there is no doubt other songs from the sessions we have yet to hear either.
 
I love Wasting My Time but it's still so weird that Mel B isn't on it at all, did they ever address why that was? Given Melanie's attitude towards the band at the time, it almost feels like the wrong Mel ended up in the vocal booth for that session.
 
Their first two albums may not be “cohesive” (I disagree with that word choice) but they all work together. It’s not like they went from a pure country bop to a heavy metal statement in the same tracklist.

Forever is just boring. After “Holler” everything just sounds like the same song (I don’t count “Goodbye” since it was released a whole two years prior) And lacks personality. This could’ve been the second Honeyz album.
 
Their first two albums may not be “cohesive” (I disagree with that word choice) but they all work together. It’s not like they went from a pure country bop to a heavy metal statement in the same tracklist.

Forever is just boring. After “Holler” everything just sounds like the same song (I don’t count “Goodbye” since it was released a whole two years prior) And lacks personality. This could’ve been the second Honeyz album.

I’m not sure if my post and choice of words has been misinterpreted, but when I use the word cohesive in regards to ‘Forever’, it was in no way meant as a slight to ‘Spice World’ as I have already stated it is one of the best pop albums of all time.

The cohesion I talk about with regards to ‘Forever’ is the sound that Darkchild created which runs through each of the tracks, causing it to almost play like one long song. For some this can be irksome and tiring, for others it’s means the albums flows but it doesn’t put it ahead of Spice World, no. At this point, it feels like the girls were shedding their previous Spice image and attempting to go head to head with similar groups on the scene, but what they forgot was what made them so magical to begin with.

The thematic jumps that the girls take on Spice World work so collectively because it’s like they are covering the sounds of the world, their world, their ‘Spice World’. From Samba, to Motown, to R&B to Latin and more, the album is a brilliant collection and would not work if the same sound ran throughout each, as they are defined by their individuality and the personality they bring out in each of the girls.
 
Finally bit the bullet. After holding out for the anniversary (in the hopes of something great) I ended up buying the original cover repress of Spiceworld, because that silver mess isn’t going anywhere near my collection.
 
Holler and Let Love Lead the Way really should have been a single to promote a greatest hits. Then include If You Wanna Have Some Fun and be done with it. There was no need to make a new album and Forever never felt like anyone other than Emma and maybe Victoria were even invested in it. Melanie C was still plugging her solo album and Mel B had just released hers. It was a bit of a mess, even if I can still enjoy it occasionally. The album cover is horrific too.
 
Top