Taylor Swift - Midnights

Ready For It
Blank Space/You Belong With Me
Style/Wildest Dreams
I Knew You Were Trouble
Look What You Made Me Do
You Need to Calm Down/We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together
All Too Well
Love Story (1989)
Shake It Off

is what I more or less imagine a Super Bowl show looking like if it were to have happened now. I don't think she'd do anything from Folklore/Evermore in a setting like that.
Yeah, she's not doing Folklore cuts at the Super Bowl. Like, that's def the time for her biggest and most anthemic hits to shine.
I don't think there's any version of a Taylor Super Bowl show that does not include New Year's Day and Lover. The setlist for a Super Bowl would be all the glitter gel pen songs, and maybe a few sharpie-burn-book songs like Ready For It and Should've Said No.
We’ll get something along the lines of
Love Story
You Belong With Me
Sparks Fly
We Are Never Getting Back Together
I Knew You We’re Trouble
Shake It Off
Blank Space
Bad Blood
Look What You Made Me Do
And something new

Most of the slower stuff doesn't really work here. Which kinda disqualifies folklore and Evermore. I kinda feel like All Too Well wouldn’t be done justice with only 30 seconds to a minute. 3 songs from 1989 seems a lot but those are probably the only 3 likely.
"Lover" will be there as the requisite ballad and the representative from that era. It's the most streamed song on the album and consistently the most streamed daily (literally more than the other three singles combined).
Ready For It is pretty much a given, since it already has ties with Saturday Night Football and practically sounds like a hype song for large sports events. The Superbowl would be the one arena she'd be most focused on pandering to the broadest audience possible, so I feel like she'd probably throw the country audience a bone and play something from the debut. I can unfortunately definitely see her doing something like bringing out Tim McGraw for a Tim McGraw/Highway Don't Care duet. It would be an effective way of promoting the TS version of the debut at the very least nn.

If she were to do one of her ballads I think Wildest Dreams would be the most likely, maybe the great mashup with Enchanted she did on the 1989 tour.