I was watching the All Too Well shortfilm yesterday with more critical lens and to be honest, she's pretty great from a technical point of view. It's very standard but the whole thing is very well done from shooting, framework, actors... The "fight scene in the kitchen" wasn't very good because it looks very exaggerated but, at same time, I can imagine that being more of a conscious decision.
With that in mind, I'd say the only thing that she'd have to work is fine tuning some of her instincts. Anti-Hero and Bejeweled are great videos and the execution on both is great, just a little over the top. Lavender Haze feels a little more stripped but could do without some of the extra on-the-nose CGI (the cloud over her head, the "constellation" shoot). Karma is... an exercise about After Effects so she can get the Marvel coin soon I guess. From her songwriting alone we know she's very much capable of showing a lot without saying much, so there's no need to use some of the literal images and metaphors as a director.
I truly think I'll be seated for Taylor'sDirectionalDebut (tm) dd