I suppose it is time we return to our regular programming, hey?
Berserk is back with you, sadly he has to take an 11 with him this time!
No one wanted to have their 11 cut on Christmas, right? Two days later - and it’s still as painful losing this one I must admit!
#43
Manau - La Tribu De Dana
Picked By: Berserkboi
Credentials: #1 France (12 weeks), 23 Weeks In The Top 3 (!!), 2nd Best Selling Single of 1998 In France, 19th Best Selling Single Of All Time In France, 1415000 Units SOLD, Certified Diamond in SNEP, #1 Belgium (5 Weeks), 25 Weeks In The Top 10, 3rd Best Selling Single Of 1998 in Belgium, 4th Best Selling Single Of All Time In Belgium, #2 Netherlands
Average Score: 7.1840
Highest Score: 11 @Ezz 10
@If You Go @jtm @Remorque @Phonetics Girl @berserkboi
Lowest Score: 3
@DominoDancing
Team Germany is starting to kick us where it hurts now! Sinking five 10s and an eleven - Mr. Dancing’s got some splainin to do Dddd
Jokes aside, it is fairly obvious now I am a big sucker for great storytelling in my French music and La Tribu De Dana provides with a shining example of this. Possibly the most epic track we have on the playlist, and similar to another favourite in Les Lacs Du Connemara in that it borrows a lot from Ireland and the country folklore (who knew The Lost Classics Rate would be all about France stanning Ireland, hey?) - the tale of La Tribu De Dana never fails to bring a tear to my eye.
Sung/recounted as the tale of an epic battle waged by
Tuatha Dé Danann’s only survivor (and as a result king) - Manau go as far as creating a brand new genre of French music combining French Rap and Breton melodies. I’d imagine this was instrumental in making the song stand out upon release, with the gambit really paying off commercially with the credentials you can see above!
I remember the success of La Tribu De Dana took me a little by surprise when I first heard the song as a teenager as it’s not really what you’d call instant. Yet the musicality, tune and flow were very unique and my friends and I would discuss it in school. Listening to it as an adult, just a passing liking for La Tribu De Dana turned into substantial love for it - with its epic essence taking greater scope for me with some life experience behind me. You go through a fair few hurdles and sacrifices by your mid-30s - and a lot of the text that talks about one’s tribe, trials, what we leave behind etc has more weight and emotional impact which I can appreciate and process better when listening to the song at this stage in my life.
The standout element of La Tribu De Dana for me would easily be Martial Tricoche’s rap verses. I am not the best judge of rap music since it is not a genre I follow too closely but the urgency with which Tricoche builds his delivery - with the second and third verses when he depicts himself in battle and the fallout of this battle (seeing all his fallen comrades and the massacre left behind) - notably by adding heaviness and elements of breathlessness to his tone transports me into the battlefield with him. There is absolute justice done to the impactful lyrics here by my ears.
@jtm (10) sees a bit of Game Of Thrones in the visuals - Ddd at the video being overly dramatic, but I‘ll always love this even though I should take some of the score off for the shitty fade out ending.
@DominoDancing (3) is not into this at all (I will say all members of Manau’s ancestry can be traced back to Brittany/Armorica so I am glad at least cultural appropriation is not something we had to deal with here) - Oh Jesus Christ, what is this supposed to be? Medieval rap? Get out. A couple of points for a catchy chorus, but apart from that everything about this rubs me the wrong way.
@WowWowWowWow (6) gives us - points solely for the music of it. The vocals are whatever "pas pour moi" is when it's quadrupled. (Dddd - watch that change from Pas Pour Moi x 4 change to Pour Moi Seul x 100 when he sees what Martial looks like nowadays!)
@Filippa (5) enjoys the musicality first and foremost - I do like the chorus and the instrumentals. The rest not so much.
@daninternational (6.5) might have been me when I first heard the song 22 years ago! - It has its moments, but it's so.... Weird.
@Phonetics Girl (10) brings up an unexpected (or maybe not) act, and is stanning French men so you know this must be great!! - what kind of French medieval rap excellence? poor The Corrs!
@berserkboi (10) AKA moi! Was right to be pre-emptive! - Such an AMAZING song and story, and preemptively giving it a full score as I expect we will be throwing zeroes here undeservingly!
@pop3blow2 (7.5) is also a Wowzer with this one - I like parts of the track, but this vocal is not for me.
@Ezz (11) is my boy and I am so proud! - I LOVE the fusion here, it works beautifully, and the name of the band being the old name for the Isle of Man really appeals given that's in my neck of the woods. Will be exploring them further for sure. Awarded my 11 as it was my new discovery of the rate.
@MilesAngel (4.5) might need more time with this one - As rap songs go this isn't bad and some of the instrumentation is nice. I like the idea more than the execution.
@Sprockrooster (9) potentially hints at a high score for a track that has yet to fall - It is hard to fill the big shoes that is Narcotic preceding this track on the playlist for this rate, but it holds its own. Such a weird track for me to love, but I can't help but bop.
We have ascended with this choral backing!
This was a follow-up of theirs, which also made #1 in France and Belgium though the Total Sales (nothing to sneeze at) of 490000 is barely a third of what La Tribu De Dana achieved!
@soratami will hear a very similar tune here Ddddd
Alan Stivell's Tri Martolod which the song borrows the melody of in portions