The Ashlee Simpson vs. Lindsay Lohan Rate - I Didn't Steal Your Boyfriend

logo.png

two.jpg


Misunderstood. Underappreciated. Ashlee Simpson & Lindsay Lohan may have been known more for their US Weekly headlines, reality show antics and assorted PR problems throughout the years, but many have forgotten the strength and influence of their musical output. Both disciples of The Church of Dioguardi, these two songstresses were always willing to get a little more personal (raw) than their squeaky clean peers Jessica & Hilary, not afraid to let themselves be vulnerable for the world to see -- fearlessly genre-hopping from the guitar-driven, anthemic pop rock of the mid 00's, to synthed-out electronic & even in hip-hop & R&B in their later years. What they lacked in *vocal prowess* they made up for in earnestness and sheer unbridled charisma. They say the flame that burns twice as bright burns half as long, and these girls burned bright.

Let's now all revisit the careers of our favorite underdogs as they square off against each other:

200w-6.gif
tenor-2.gif


ASHLEE

promoted-media-optimized-53ce8bb39aeaa.jpg

Autobiography (2004)
1. Autobiography
2. Pieces of Me
3. Shadow
4. La La
5. Love Makes the World Go Round
6. Better Off
7. Love Me for Me
8. Surrender
9. Unreachable
10. Nothing New
11. Giving It All Away
12. Undiscovered
Bonus:
13. Harder Everyday
14. Sorry
15. Endless Summer
16. Just Let Me Cry

51p-U-2-Wuv-L.jpg


I Am Me (2005)
1. Boyfriend
2. In Another Life
3. Beautifully Broken
4. L.O.V.E.
5. Coming Back For More
6. Dancing Alone
7. Burnin’ Up
8. Catch Me When I Fall
9. I Am Me
10. Eyes Wide Open
11. Say Goodbye
Bonus:
12. Kicking and Screaming
13. Fall in Love with Me
14. Get Nasty
15. Invisible

71-Gc-Of3-Wjo-L-SL1089.jpg


Bittersweet World (2008)
1. Outta My Head (Ay Ya Ya)
2. Boys
3. Rule Breaker
4. No Time For Tears
5. Little Miss Obsessive
6. Ragdoll
7. Bittersweet World
8. What I’ve Become
9. Hot Stuff
10. Murder
11. Never Dream Alone
Bonus:
12. I’m Out
13. Can’t Have It All
14. Follow You Wherever You Go

Extra:
1. Bat For a Heart (2012)
line-png-32.png

LINDSAY

8b0bac4ba49265a2448837bf7da356f06e73dd54.jpg

Speak (2004)
1. First
2. Nobody ’Til You
3. Symptoms of You
4. Speak
5. Over
6. Something I Never Had
7. Anything But Me
8. Disconnected
9. To Know Your Name
10. Very Last Moment In Time
11. Magnet
12. Rumors

d1792235f38eb13f87062ac8bd774ad0-999x1000x1.jpg


A Little More Personal (Raw) (2005)
1. Confessions of a Broken Heart (Daughter to Father)
2. Black Hole
3. I Live for the Day
4. I Want You to Want Me
5. My Innocence
6. A Little More Personal
7. If It’s Alright
8. If You Were Me
9. Fastlane
10. Edge of Seventeen
11. Who Loves You
12. A Beautiful Life (La Bella Vita)

b8dffc5a907547f0b19257faeb3a1480.jpg

Spirit in the Dark (2008, unreleased -- optional)
1. Bossy
2. Walka Not A Talka (feat. Snoop Dogg)
3. Can’t Stop Won’t Stop
4. I Wanna Be Bad
5. Too Young to Die
6. Stuck
7. Stay
open-uri20150422-12561-11pqvrr-c01aab13.jpg


Soundtrack songs (2003-2004-- optional)
1. I Decide
2. Ultimate
3. Drama Queen (That Girl)
4. What Are You Waiting For
5. A Day in the Life
6. Don't Move On / Living for the City / Changes

line-png-32.png

Good luck girls!

ashlee-simpson-lindsay-lohan-gettyimages-105256562.jpg
 
Last edited:
anigif-enhanced-29641-1412279208-1.gif


giphy-9.gif


RESULTS:
83. Lindsay - I Want You to Want Me
82. Lindsay - Too Young To Die
81. Ashlee - Never Dream Alone
80. Lindsay - Don't Move On / Living for the City / Changes
79. Ashlee - Harder Everyday
78. Ashlee - Unreachable
77. Ashlee - Endless Summer
76. Lindsay - If You Were Me
75. Ashlee - Sorry
74. Ashlee - Follow You Wherever You Go
73. Lindsay - Stay
72. Ashlee - Just Let Me Cry
71. Ashlee - Fall in Love With Me
70. Lindsay - A Day in the Life
69. Ashlee - Get Nasty
68. Lindsay - I Wanna Be Bad
67. Ashlee - I'm Out
66. Lindsay - Anything But Me
65. Ashlee - Surrender
64. Ashlee - Eyes Wide Open
63. Ashlee - Say Goodbye
62. Lindsay - Walka Not a Talka
61. Ashlee - Giving It All Away
60. Lindsay - What Are You Waiting For
59. Ashlee - Can't Have It All
58. Ashlee - Love Make The World Go Round
57. Ashlee - Bat For a Heart
56. Ashlee - Nothing New
55. Lindsay - My Innocence
54. Lindsay - Disconnected
53. Ashlee - Beautifully Broken
52. Lindsay - Something I Never Had
51. Ashlee - Better Off
50. Lindsay - Can't Stop Won't Stop
49. Ashlee - Ragdoll
48. Ashlee - What I've Become
47. Lindsay - Very Last Moment in Time
46. Ashlee - Invisible
45. Lindsay - A Little More Personal
44. Ashlee - No Time For Tears
43. Ashlee - I Am Me
42. Lindsay - If It's Alright
41. Ashlee - Kicking & Screaming
40. Ashlee - Murder
39. Lindsay - I Decide
38. Ashlee - Shadow
37. Lindsay - Ultimate
36. Ashlee - Bittersweet World
35. Lindsay - A Beautiful Life (La Bella Vita)
34. Ashlee - Catch Me When I Fall
33. Lindsay - Symptoms of You
32. Lindsay - I Live For the Day
31. Ashlee - Rulebreaker
30. Ashlee - In Another Life
29. Ashlee - Burning Up
28. Lindsay - Black Hole
27. Ashlee - Little Miss Obsessive
26. Lindsay - Drama Queen (That Girl)
25. Lindsay - Fastlane
24. Ashlee - Undiscovered
23. Ashlee - Dancing Alone
22. Lindsay - The Edge of Seventeen
21. Lindsay - To Know Your Name
20. Ashlee - Hot Stuff
19. Lindsay - Who Loves You
18. Ashlee - Boys
17. Lindsay - Magnet
16. Ashlee - Coming Back For More
15. Lindsay - Nobody Til You
14. Ashlee - Love Me For Me
13. Lindsay - Stuck
12. Ashlee - Autobiography
11. Lindsay - Speak
10. Lindsay - First
09. Lindsay - Rumors
08. Ashlee - Pieces of Me
07. Lindsay - Over
06. Ashlee - L.O.V.E.
05. Lindsay - Confessions of a Broken Heart (Daughter to Father)
04. Lindsay - Bossy
03. Ashlee - La La
02. Ashlee - Outta My Head (Ay Ya Ya)
01. Ashlee - Boyfriend
 
Last edited:
he/him
I'll definitely give this a go, even though it's pretty much Ashlee + "Confessions of a Broken Heart" for me, but I only know a handful of Lindsay's songs so maybe I'll discover some new ones.
 
Rumors, Confessions and Outta My Head are the only possible top3 considering the *ahem* quality of the five albums.
 
I want to participate but I don't know if I'll have the time to listen to everything. I'll do my best. At first glance, Bossy is a strong contender for my 11 and I refuse to feel any shame.
 
@AndrewX
@andru
@BEST FICTION
@Blond
@BSpearsFan

Hello! There is an Ashlee Simpson vs. Lindsay Lohan discography rate happening and I'm tagging anyone who has ever breathed Ashlee or Lindsay's name on this forum. Let me know if you're interested in revisiting the classic autobiographies and confessions of the two most underrated rock-pop goddesses of the mid 00s!

5bd9e57fc92d4010257497.gif
5bd9e5ae2ae12578140412.gif
 

Top