In place of Daughter to Father and whatever else is left by Lindsay aside from Rumors, Over and Bossy more like.
The Ashlee Simpson vs. Lindsay Lohan Rate - I Didn't Steal Your Boyfriend
- Thread starter CasuallyCrazed
- Start date
In place of Daughter to Father and whatever else is left by Lindsay aside from Rumors, Over and Bossy more like.
Wish Autobiography had made the top 10, but it's a good showing.
Sorry for my emotional ketchup burst mini-essay in my commentary (I'm prone to those, ha!). When I started the rate I put this album on first & had a wave of pent-up nostalgia that came pouring out.
Sorry for my emotional ketchup burst mini-essay in my commentary (I'm prone to those, ha!). When I started the rate I put this album on first & had a wave of pent-up nostalgia that came pouring out.
Only one more elimination until we hit the coveted Top 10!
Will Ashlee la-la-lose any of her pieces? Ay ay ay ay yah...
Will Lindsay be over first? Or will we let her live?
What do you really want?
What do you want to know?
What do you want to see?
What do you want to go?
Will Ashlee la-la-lose any of her pieces? Ay ay ay ay yah...
Will Lindsay be over first? Or will we let her live?
What do you really want?
What do you want to know?
What do you want to see?
What do you want to go?
He/Him
Not gonna happen.
Everybody's got a point of view
And the right to their own opinion
So don't be scared of what I'm gonna do
When you let me know your intuition
11
Speak
8.452
(4th out of 12 from Speak)
Highest: 10 x 8 (@Cathal, @DJHazey, @imaduck, @jmmc13,
@Music Is Life, @Remorque, @Sprockrooster, @Untouchable Ace)
Lowest: 5 (@iheartpoptarts, @Seventeen Days)
And the right to their own opinion
So don't be scared of what I'm gonna do
When you let me know your intuition
11
Speak
8.452
(4th out of 12 from Speak)
Highest: 10 x 8 (@Cathal, @DJHazey, @imaduck, @jmmc13,
@Music Is Life, @Remorque, @Sprockrooster, @Untouchable Ace)
Lowest: 5 (@iheartpoptarts, @Seventeen Days)
Sprockrooster - 10
My 11 if I were to give it to Lindsay as this definitely the pinnacle in her discography. Lyrically this is very linked to The Fame, so clearly ahead of it's time. But a great track lyricwise for that moment in her life too and basically applicable for the whole high school era nowadays involving social media. Like I said, ahead of it's time. Perfectly sugarcoated in a rocky versus electronic soundclash that easily doesn't age.
imaduck - 10
Lindsay Lohan invented 80's electropop, who knew.
DJHazey - 10
The way Lindsay rides the beat on this song could save lives.
Untouchable Ace - 10
She should have done more with this. That better be her whispering and not a session singer.
[I am 100% sure that is Kara ddd]
Music is Life - 10
This is more dance-than pop-rocky but it works. This is a great title track, and I love it.
spillett - 9.5
The strongest chorus out of all Lindsay's music.
unnameable - 9
I love how uptempo most of this album is.
CasuallyCrazed - 8.5
Melodically it's such a hit, that chord progression is genius... The tempo could be a little faster though, it drags a bit considering what an absolute corker it could be.
orbison - 8
Another favorite of mine from this record. I still need someone to make a good remix of this.
pop3blow2 - 7.5
Song starts out with some oomph… but really starts to run out gas towards the end.
niccolo - 6.7
This is icy pop rock. It sounds so cold and shiny.
iheartpoptarts - 5
Could’ve been higher but the chorus kind of lost me.
Seventeen Days - 5
Another middler for me. Feels a bit like filler, unfortunately.
He/Him
he/him
Hey you lost a 10 as well, oh but wait those don't hurt you nearly as much as they do for other people. xx
I like that both ladies are walking into the top 10 with 5 songs apiece. whew, we love a balanced chart.
too bad First didn't bite it 20+ spaces ago like it should have
too bad First didn't bite it 20+ spaces ago like it should have
He/Him
Yeah I did, but that's expected by now. Most of my low scores have left already. As long as the top 5 in no particular order is:
La La (or Boyfriend)
L.O.V.E.
Rumors
First (or Over)
Confessions
I'm happy. Also I checked, and I should have several songs left a 10.
He/Him
Did I place it in my top 5/7?
he/him
He/Him
Oh I bet I know what it is, and honestly it better be top 3. If it goes next I'll help you fight someone.
We have finally arrived at the coveted top 10 of the Lohan-Simpson canon and it is still a 2 horse race to the finish.
The singles effect was very strong with these ladies, as every song left was officially released.. (Congrats to "Speak" for being the highest ranking album track. And "Autobiography" as runner up and Ashlee's #1 non-single.)
Also in a somewhat astonishing & mindboggling turn of events...
Every single song in the Top 10 has scored at least one 11...
The favorites won out y'all. (except for @jmmc13 & @Seventeen Days 11s crashing & burning at #55 and #63. Justice for "My Innocence" & RIP "Say Goodbye").
Who will fall at the final hurdle? And whose 11s will overcome the rest?
The singles effect was very strong with these ladies, as every song left was officially released.. (Congrats to "Speak" for being the highest ranking album track. And "Autobiography" as runner up and Ashlee's #1 non-single.)
Also in a somewhat astonishing & mindboggling turn of events...
Every single song in the Top 10 has scored at least one 11...
The favorites won out y'all. (except for @jmmc13 & @Seventeen Days 11s crashing & burning at #55 and #63. Justice for "My Innocence" & RIP "Say Goodbye").
Who will fall at the final hurdle? And whose 11s will overcome the rest?
Last edited:
He/Him
Agreed.
Ashlee's top 5 is amazing, and I stan for most of Lindsay's top 5. Well voted everyone!