Controversial opinion alert.
I think Super Extra Gravity is a better album than Long Gone Before Daylight.
I think they're two great albums, and Super Extra Gravity is such a good evolution from Long Gone Before Daylight. Long Gone lulls you in with it's gloomy warm melancholy and then Super Extra Gravity kicks you in the butt so you can get up again. But it's still dealing with the same emotions, just from a different viewpoint.
Such a damn shame they went on that forever-hiatus after that...
Also, maybe even more unpopular, but my favourite album of theirs is probably Life. It might as well be a different band, but it's just such a nice easy-breezy listen. Play it whilst cleaning, play it whilst having friends over for drinks, play it in the car, play it in the garden, it always works.