Discussion in 'Charts, rates etc' started by vague, Jun 3, 2019.
I'm rooting for Fantasy now my 11 is gone.
Ok but Underneath The Stars would have looked cute in the Top 10.
Vision Of Love our next please.
I feel like All I Want For Christmas is You shouldn't have even be eligible for the rate, it exists in it's own world and seeing it up against all her other heavy hitting singles feels odd.
I'm proud of the Butterfly pulling it out in the homestretch though -- I want Breakdown to win it all.
I feel like everyone here feels the same way about All I Want For Christmas - it's amazing, it's iconic, the best modern Christmas song of all time etc etc. but no one actually wants it to win the rate.
Sis. Multiple people including me want to see it win and said so a few pages ago.
You know what, I think I actually do want it to win.
I’ve tried so many times to put a top 10 or even 20 together but it’s nigh on impossible. Every day it would be different. It’s a testament to the quality of her music.
That really is such a super strong and near iconic top ten, that I can almost forgive the two debut album bops being booted out back to back. Almost...
Absolutely. Her quality control is just near second to none.
Also I always forget how good Vision of Love is. Masterclass vocals
The greatest debut single of all time. This song just has it all.
'Someday' was one of my early Mariah favourites back when I bought #1s on CD. My sister didn't like it... no wonder we don't speak now.
The top 10 is like classic moment after classic moment. But 'Honey' is the one.
Rooting for All I Want For Christmas Is You for the....breakdowns.
The Roof would look good as a winner too x
But you don't like dramatics... kii.
That's a pretty fabulous top 10 people! Well done everyone. Let's celebrate that!
All I Want For Xmas
+ 4 Sevens.
I have a feeling Emotions could be the next one out. Could well be wrong though and would like to be. NOT in place of my #11 going out instead though, of course...
FINALLY caught up and I all I have to say is THANK you all for sending my 11 into the top 10 (cause the way this was going I wasn't sure it would make it) and SCREW you all for not sending Prisoner there!
@vague this is gorgeous. The red looks so good!
Dreamlover, My All, and All I Want for Christmas Is You are the only ones that I didn't really need in the Top 10 (they're definitely Top 20 worthy though) so overall this seems like a successful result.
Separate names with a comma.