The Mariah Carey Discography Rate Pt.1 • FINISHED

Wonderful rate @vague ! Thank you for your dedication and knowledge. Amazing host.

If anyone's interested ...I did a comparison between this rate's results and the 2014 results... ddddd
For clarity purposes I removed all the Rainbow tracks and new additions from the ranking.

Spoiler: Not the Hot 100

Last rate | This rate | Track | Difference

03 | 01 | Fantasy | +2
01 | 02 | Honey | -1
09 | 03 | The Roof | +6
04 | 04 | Emotions | =
05 | 05 | Always Be My Baby | =
02 | 06 | All I Want for Christmas Is You | -4
06 | 07 | My All | -1
11 | 08 | Breakdown | +3
07 | 09 | Vision of Love | -2
08 | 10 | Dreamlover | -2
13 | 11 | Someday | +2
12 | 12 | Prisoner | =
14 | 13 | Underneath the Stars | +1
17 | 14 | Can't Let Go | +3
10 | 15 | Make It Happen | -5
16 | 16 | Anytime You Need a Friend | =
18 | 17 | Butterfly | +1
15 | 18 | Without You | -3
24 | 19 | Love Takes Time | +5
29 | 20 | Slipping Away | +9
22 | 21 | Fourth of July | +1
19 | 22 | One Sweet Day | -3
36 | 23 | Melt Away | +13
30 | 24 | When You Believe | +6
27 | 25 | Close My Eyes | +2
25 | 26 | Forever | -1
21 | 27 | Fantasy (Bad Boy Remix) | -6
37 | 28 | Looking In | +9
31 | 29 | Vanishing | +2
20 | 29 | Whenever You Call | -9
39 | 31 | Long Ago | +8
34 | 32 | Do You Think of Me | +2
43 | 33 | Outside | +10
28 | 34 | Babydoll | -6
47 | 35 | Sent From Up Above | +12
32 | 36 | Hero | -4
33 | 37 | Now That I Know | -4
26 | 38 | I'll Be There | -12
38 | 39 | All In Your Mind | -1
48 | 40 | There's Got to Be a Way | +8
58 | 41 | Everything Fades Away | +17
42 | 42 | I Don't Wanna Cry | =
41 | 43 | Fly Away (Butterfly Reprise) | -2
55 | 44 | Anytime... (C+C Mix) | +11
23 | 44 | I Still Believe | -21
56 | 46 | You're So Cold | +10
49 | 47 | I Still Believe / Pure Imagination | +2
40 | 48 | Daydream Interlude | -8
50 | 49 | Sweetheart | +1
35 | 50 | My All/Stay Awhile | -15 * @londonrain ha impact? *
60 | 51 | You Need Me | +9
45 | 52 | I've Been Thinking About You | -7
51 | 53 | To Be Around You | -2
44 | 54 | Open Arms | -10
54 | 55 | Music Box | -1
67 | 56 | The Wind | +11
53 | 57 | Alone in Love | -4
52 | 58 | Miss You Most | -6
68 | 59 | If It's Over | +9
61 | 60 | The Beautiful Ones | +1
62 | 61 | Till The End Of Time | +1
63 | 62 | I Am Free | +1
57 | 63 | Endless Love | -6
46 | 64 | When I Saw You | -18
59 | 65 | And You Don't Remember | -6
64 | 66 | All I Ever Wanted | -2
66 | 67 | Never Forget You | -1
65 | 68 | So Blessed | -3
70 | 69 | Do You Know Where You're Going To | +1
69 | 70 | Just To Hold You Once Again | -1

Only included last time:
Always Be My Baby (Def Club Mix)
Rainbow

Not included last time:
Jesus Born On This Day
Always Be My Baby (Mr. Dupri Mix)
Honey (So So Def Remix)
Whenever You Call (with Brian McKnight)

Observations:

• "I Still Believe" fell the hardest with 21 spots. It's also the only song to get a lower average this time around (7.63 vs. 7.71)
• "Everything Fades Away" jumped the most positions.
• "The Wind" was the greatest gainer in points (+1.393) [7.173 vs. 5.82]
• "Free", "End of Time" and "Beautiful Ones" left in the same order in both rates.

 

Yes, same here, good way to start the new year with another Mimi rate!

 

2 0 2 0 . 0 4 . 0 9

Spoiler: song list

Heartbreaker (feat. Jay-Z)
Can't Take That Away (Mariah's Theme)
Bliss
How Much (feat. Usher)
After Tonight
X-Girlfriend
Heartbreaker (Remix feat. Da Brat & Missy Elliott)
Vulnerability (Interlude)
Against All Odds (Take A Look At Me Now)
Crybaby (feat. Snoop Dogg)
Did I Do That? (feat. Mystikal & Master P)
Petals
Rainbow (Interlude)
Thank God I Found You (feat. Joe & 98°)

Loverboy (Remix feat. Da Brat, Ludacris, Twenty II, & Shawna)
Lead The Way
If We (feat. Ja Rule & Nate Dogg)
Didn't Mean To Turn You On
Don't Stop (Funkin' 4 Jamaica) (feat. Mystikal)
All My Life
Reflections (Care Enough)
Last Night A DJ Saved My Life (feat. Busta Rhymes, Fabolous, & DJ Clue)
Want You (feat. Eric Benét)
Never Too Far
Twister
Loverboy

Through The Rain
Boy (I Need You) (feat. Cam'ron)
The One
Yours
You Got Me (feat. Jay-Z & Freeway)
I Only Wanted
Clown
My Saving Grace
You Had Your Chance
Lullaby
Irresistible (West Side Connection)
Subtle Invitation
Bringin' On The Heartbreak
Sunflowers For Alfred Roy
Through The Rain (Remix feat. Kelly Price & Joe)
Miss You (feat. Jadakiss)
There Goes My Heart
Got A Thing 4 You (with Da Brat & Elephant Man)

It's Like That
We Belong Together
Shake It Off
Mine Again
Say Somethin' (feat. Snoop Dogg)
Stay The Night
Get Your Number (feat. Jermaine Dupri)
One And Only (feat. Twista)
Circles
Your Girl
I Wish You Knew
To The Floor (feat. Nelly)
Joy Ride
Fly Like A Bird
Sprung
Secret Love

Don't Forget About Us
Makin' It Last All Night (What It Do) (feat. Jermaine Dupri)
So Lonely (One & Only Part II) (feat. Twista)
We Belong Together (Remix feat. Jadakiss & Styles P.)

Heartbreaker / If I Should Ever Be Lonely (Junior's Club Mix)
Thank God I Found You (Make It Last Remix feat. Joe & Nas)
There For Me
I Know What You Want (with Busta Rhymes & Flipmode Squad)
U Make Me Wanna (with Jadakiss)
Lil' L.O.V.E. (with Bone Thugs-n-Harmony & Bow Wow)

—
​

if you'd like to get an early start, please feel free to do so! also, if there are any songs/remixes you think I've missed that deserve to be rated, please let me know asap! I'd like to get any additions to the song list fully sorted before the pt.2 thread actually opens~

 

Noooooooo, I don't have the time or strength for another rate, but for you, boo, I'll try as much as I can.

 

At last, time for part 2???

 

YES.

 

I've unfortunately missed the first part, but I'll try to be a part of this.

 

This is where I started to waiver in my love for Mariah. I haven’t really given many of these songs a proper listen.

 

Her best era in my opinion. I am perched!

 

Exciting! I've never listened to Glitter or Charmbracelet all the way through so this finally forces me to!

 

You'll be in for a real treat-believe me.

 

So excited to do this! Although I knew most of the songs in Part 1 I’m pretty unfamiliar with a lot of the stuff outside of The Emancipation of Mimi in this one so really looking forward to diving in!

 

I think I already know my #11 already!!

 

Seven songs in this list could easily get my 11... this is gonna be a tough one but I'm definitely looking forward to it!

 

Will contenders for my 11 be (relatively) obscure deep cuts once again?

 

I'm sad I didn't get to vote in part 1, but I'm absolutely voting in part 2. Justice for Glitter and Charmbracelet.

 

Speaking of 11s, I think I have 2 clear contenders this time around. We'll see if anything else presents itself in a new light to be able to compete with them.

 

It will be so hard to choose an 11.

 

Loverboy (club of love remix)
The one (so so def remix)
Dont forget about us (desert storm remix)
say something (so so def remix)

All of these have new vocals and sound (kinda) different from the original (and veRY GOOD).