The Mariah Carey Discography Rate Pt.1 • FINISHED

[Deleted member 21339]

Yassss I’ve been waiting for this. Butterfly coming for that 8.5+ album average.

 

[Lapras]

I’m joining too!

Is there a limit for using too many 10s though.

 

[WhatKindOfKylie?]

The divine debut album, better not get neglected people!

 

[WhatKindOfKylie?]

I’m joining too!

Is there a limit for using too many 10s though.

I hope there will not be! SO many are worth that high score I think.

 

[tylerc]

My four favorite Mariah albums (and Rainbow) being rated? I am pumped.

 

[Lost In Japan.]

Yes!! I didn't participate in @P'NutButter's rate because I hadn't fully delved into Mariah until the post-rate wave of love that swept the forum, but she has since lodged herself as an all-time fave so I cannot wait to do this.

 

[WhatKindOfKylie?]

In terms of all the full albums on offer, I've decided to re listen too and rate Daydream first. That first half is particularly like a mini Greatest Hits! All top tier Mimi.

 

[Music Is Life & Death]

I’m joining too!

Is there a limit for using too many 10s though.

Uh, I'm in trouble if there is.

When I first saw this queued, I started rating so I already have the first four albums done. I could literally get this done and in today, and I think I will so I don't have to worry about it.

My four favorite Mariah albums (and Rainbow) being rated? I am pumped.

Rainbow isn't in this part.

 

[playboy69]

This is going to be so hard, my second favourite artist of all time and some of her best albums...

 

[WhatKindOfKylie?]

Mariah Carey was the #1 artist of the 1990s for a reason. And this rate provides the proof that's for sure.

 

[Andrew]

How can I choose between Prisoner or Fantasy as my 11?

 

[Music Is Life & Death]

How can I choose between Prisoner or Fantasy as my 11?

Spoiler

Pick Fantasy, as it's mine. (Prisoner was a contender for me as well.)

 

[tylerc]

Uh, I'm in trouble if there is.

When I first saw this queued, I started rating so I already have the first four albums done. I could literally get this done and in today, and I think I will so I don't have to worry about it.

Rainbow isn't in this part.

Not sure why my brain thought the #1's songs came after Rainbow but it did. These are genuinely my 4 fav Mimi albums so I am going to struggle to be objective.

 

[Island]

Y'all are not ready for the level of professionalism and talentry @vague has when running rates. Wigs will be wiped off clean.

Also, I will do this and try to stay awake when listening to Music Box.

 

[Sprockrooster]

I am here!

 

[WhatKindOfKylie?]

Trying to chose my #11 in this rate, is without a doubt the hardest choice I've ever had to make here in a Popjustice rate.

 

[WhatKindOfKylie?]

This rate has made me re evaluate higher this lovely gem:

 

[irishlamb]

@vague

Any chance this could be included with the other remixes in the rate? If it’s too much hassle I understand.

 

[vague]

@vague

Any chance this could be included with the other remixes in the rate? If it’s too much hassle I understand.

you know, I actually went back and forth on which of her remixes to include for the final song list, and this was one I cut at the last minute (along with the C+C radio mix of “Anytime You Need A Friend”), just to keep the song list a little shorter, but I have no problem adding it back. is everyone else good with that?

have I left out any other remixes that y’all feel are essential, while we’re at it?

 

[irishlamb]

you know, I actually went back and forth on which of her remixes to include for the final song list, and this was one I cut at the last minute (along with the C+C radio mix of “Anytime You Need A Friend”), just to keep the song list a little shorter, but I have no problem adding it back. is everyone else good with that?

I have left out any other remixes that y’all feel are essential , while we’re at it?

Oh no pressure haha if it makes it easier to have an even 70, then that’s cool with me.