The Mariah Carey Discography Rate Pt.1 • FINISHED

Mariah: 8.6
Emotions: 7.3
Music Box: 5.5
Daydream: 7.9
Butterfly: 9.0

I'm surprised Emotions got over 6.0
Butterfly is THAT album, isn't it? Whew.
Close to sending, just have the remixes left to score. I’ll share my averages in the meantime.

Mariah Carey - 8.8 (10 x 3, 7 x 1)
Emotions - 7.9 (10 x 3, 5 x 1)
Music Box - 7.1 (10 x 1, 3 x 1)
Daydream - 8.5 (10 x 4, 6 x 1)
Butterfly - 9.2 (11 x 1, 10 x 7, 5 x 1)

Everything Fades Away and Do You Think of Me being left off Music Box was homophobic.


Staff member
As someone using this rate to get more acquainted with Mariah's catalogue, I am baffled that Music Box seems to get such low it because of Without You being "that song" from a fan perspective?
Because of the "where are the bops" crew.

It may have plenty of schmaltzy ballads (and I think Hero in particular isn't loved around here) but it's still an amazing album.

I really should start scoring ddddd

Edit: whheeew just saw there's an extension
cannot wait for Breakdown or Fourth of July to win :*