The Miley Cyrus Discography Rate Part 1: WINNER ANNOUNCED! FINISHED!

What's your favorite album featured here?

  • Meet Miley Cyrus

    Votes: 3 7.5%

  • Breakout

    Votes: 7 17.5%

  • The Time Of Our Lives

    Votes: 2 5.0%

  • Can't Be Tamed

    Votes: 24 60.0%

  • A Hannah Soundtrack

    Votes: 4 10.0%
  • Total voters
    40
Music Is Life & Death

Music Is Life & Death

He/Him
I literally can not with you people, what the fuck...



































































































#41 (Tie Part 2) - Stay: 7.33
Stay.png
(created by Suburbia)
Highest: 1x11 (@Mirwais Ahmadzaï) 2x10s (Me @AbCF15) 2x9s (@Sprocky's BF @Remorque) <- Taste I love you.
Lowest: 1x2 (@phily693) 1x3 (@Ana Raquel) 1x4 (@iheartpoptarts) <- I love you all but WORMS FOR BRAINS.
My Score: 10
Favorite Lyric: Usually when I don't put something here, it's because there's just nothing that grabs me, but with this song, I literally just can't choose. I love every single second of it. I'm so mad at you guys.
Trajectory
5 Voters: #62
10 Voters: #56
15 Voters: #56
19 Voters: #41
Total Points: 139.25
​
Stay was written by Miley and John Shanks, and produced by John, for Miley's third album Can't Be Tamed. Starting off as a piano ballad, it builds into a more arena ready, elecronic ballad with drums, and synth handclaps, giving it a more anthemic feel production wise, with Miley's intimate, captivating, and heartbreaking vocals expressing how hard it is to be in a long distance relationship. I'm so pissed. Of all the songs from the album - of all the songs left - this is what you decide to kick out right before the top 40? I can't fucking deal with the balladphopia. The song is a lyrical and musicl masterpiece, simple, but perfect. Miley sounds amazing, and she makes me wanna cry every single time I listen to this. It was this close to being my 11 - it was down to this and Who Owns My Heart - and now I wish I went with this just to give it a better fate! UGH! The song is very clearly about Liam, and the struggle of dating him while they were both busy with their careers, probably ending it at some point because of that, despite still loving each other. Honestly, it's so sad to think about, I can't. The song was only performed on the Gypsy Heart Tour once, in San Jose. Anyway, personal story time: When I was 15 and finishing up my sophomore year of high school, my friend had me start talking to an online friend of her's, because he was curious and confused about his own sexuality. She showed me a picture of him and I thought he as really cute, so I was like Yeah I'll help him, and maybe something will come of it. So I started talking to him that day on Facebook, and we started with a bit of small talk, but eventually I asked him why he was curious, and we just kept talking about it, and me, being a very ballsy almost 16 year-old, suggested that onve we get to know each other more, we could start dating, and he said he would like that. I was over the moon, because this is the first guy I felt I had a chance with - I had recently gotten over my first real gay crush - and I was hoping for more. We continued talking, and a couple days later I realized I didn't actually know where he was from - I figured around my area, since he was friends with one of mine - but when I asked him he revealed he acutally lived in Nicaragua - which, if you don't know, is a tiny country in Central America, aprroximately 3,000 miles away from me. I decided to not let this be a deal breaker for me. I figured could still work out right? So we kept talking, and about two weeks after we met, about midnight on June 14th, we officially started dating. Even though we had only ever texted on Facebook, it felt like something to me. And it continued to. We never got past that level of communication, but most of the time, it was enough for me. We continued to be together, talking as often as possible, and being very very dorky in our messages - there were a lot of cutesy sticker exchanges - and by the time my 16th birthday rolled around, I was completely smitten with him. We talked about any and everything that we thought of, and it wasn't long before I realized I had fallen in love with him. And yes, I did love him, and who he was, not some image of him in my head, depsite the distance/communication barriers. He spoke English fluently so that was never an issue, and I had taken it upon me to learn more Spanish so I could talk to him in his first language. Eventually I even told him about my struggle with mental health, which I'm always scared to tell anyone, and everything he told me afterwards just made me love him more. We had hoped to make it so he could visit me, but there were a lot of issues - hopefully by the time my junior prom rolled around so we could go together, but it never worked out and I ended up going alone. Now, if you had asked me about it, I would've said I was fine. But I wasn't. The cracks in us we're starting to show, but I did evrything I could to cover them, because at this point I was scared to lose him. So I stayed, and I fell deeper, even as we fell apart. Eventually I realized that it just wouldn't work anymore, and I felt like he wanted to, but couldn't end it, so I did. He didn't seem to handle it well at first, but I think that was more for my sake then anything else. But I knew it was better for both of us. We were together from June 14, 2016-January 11, 2018. A year and a half. He was my first boyfriend, and the first person I had ever fallen in love with. We stopped talking for a while after that, but eventually we started again, just to see how the other was doing. He had also become really close with my closest, oldest friend, and it was clear they were interested in each other, so I gave them both the go-ahead. This is quite a while later and I had extremely moved on. But he revealed to her that what he and I had was a once-in-a-lifetime thing, and while he had loved me, he would never date another guy, and this confirmed the suspicions I had gathered in my head that he was more straight then bisexual, which is what we both assumed. While I wish things had gone differently, I'm glad I had been able to share that experience with him, and help clear his confusions up. So, even though we never "met", he could never "come back home" because he had never been here, but I relate to this song on such a deeply personal level, and I can't believe you heathens kicked it out befoe top 40/30/20/10. Tasteless. Critics didn't have much or anything important to say about the song, so I'm just going to give the floor to y'all.

All of our commentators at least liked the song, so I don't have to go on a rampage, even though you didn't give me much to work with. @M24 (7.7) makes me suspicious, but with that score I'll let it slide: Cute ballad. Can't say much more than that. That seems just a little too shady, but I'll leave you alone. For now. @pop3blow2 (8.8) has perfect ears: Very heartfelt vocal. Really like the production here, too. I can always trust your taste. I hope @savilizabeths (8) is upset about this, since it's one of the few songs she actually likes from the album: Very very pretty. We love a good piano moment. Yes. Yes we do. Well most of us anyway. Since @Mirwais Ahmadzaï didn't submit any commentary, I'll close out with @DJHazey (8.5) who thankfully saw the light: Definitely a song I haven't listened to once since the last time it was in a rate. Not sure why as it's not that bad, even if the catchiness is very subtle. I was probably like "oh slow song, see ya!" but I've grown a bit as a music fan. I'm going to make sure this gets alot more plays in the future. It did right? Please tell me it did.

Y'all don't deserve her:

The song live:

A couple of my favorites with similar lyrical themes
This was mine and his song:

And this one really helped get me to make the decision to end it:

The talent in this post, holy shit.​
 
DJHazey

DJHazey

he/him
It has gotten more plays, but I can say without thinking too hard that's it's not the top re-discovery as far as getting a lot of plays since rating, that's probably been 'Obsessed' which left far too early.
 
Music Is Life & Death

Music Is Life & Death

He/Him
Okay, it's been a tough road, but we've finally made it to...


Your Top 40!​

Hannah Montana - 5/9
01. The Best Of Both Worlds
02. Who Said
03. Just Like You
04. Pumpin' Up The Party
05. If We Were A Movie
06. I Got Nerve
07. The Other Side Of Me
08. This Is The Life
09. I Learned From You

Hannah Montana 2 - 4/10
01. We Got The Party
02. Nobody's Perfect
03. Make Some Noise
04. Rock Star
05. Old Blue Jeans
06. Life's What You Make It
07. One In A Million
08. Bigger Than Us
09. You & Me Together
10. True Friend

Meet Miley Cyrus - 7/10
01. See You Again
02. East Northumberland High
03. Let's Dance
04. G.N.O. (Girl's Night Out)
05. Right Here
06. As I Am
07. Start All Over
08. Clear
09. Good & Broken
10. I Miss You

Breakout - 7/14
01. Breakout
02. 7 Things
03. The Driveway
04. Girls Just Wanna Have Fun
05. Full Circle
06. Fly On The Wall
07. Bottom Of The Ocean
08. Wake Up America
09. These Four Walls
10. Simple Song
11. Goodbye
12. See You Again (Rock Mafia Remix)
13. Hovering
14. Someday

Hannah Montana: The Movie - 3/12
01. You'll Always Find Your Way Back Home
02. Let's Get Crazy
03. The Good Life
04. Don't Walk Away
05. Hoedown Throwdown
06. Dream
07. The Climb
08. Butterfly Fly Away
09. Let's Do This
10. Spotlight
11. What's Not To Like
12: The Best Of Both Worlds: The 2009 Movie Mix

Hannah Montana 3 - 1/9
01. It's All Right Here
02. Mixed Up
03. He Could Be The One
04. Just A Girl
05. I Wanna Know You
06. Supergirl
07. Every Part Of Me
08. Ice Cream Freeze (Let's Chill)
09. Don't Wanna Be Torn

The Time Of Our Lives - 4/7
01. Kicking & Screaming
02. Party In The U.S.A.
03. When I Look At You
04. The Time Of Our Lives
05. Talk Is Cheap
06. Obsessed
07. Before The Storm

Can't Be Tamed - 8/12
01. Liberty Walk
02. Who Owns My Heart
03. Can't Be Tamed
04. Every Rose Has its Thorn
05. Two More Lonely People
06. Forgiveness & Love
07. Permanent December
08. Stay
09. Scars
10. Take Me Along
11. Robot
12. My Heart Beats For Love

Hannah Montana Forever - 1/12
01. Gonna Get This
02. Que Sera
03. Ordinary Girl
04. Kiss It Goodbye
05. I'll Always Remember You
06. Need A Little Love
07. Are You Ready
08. Love That Lets Go
09. I'm Still Good
10. Been Here All Along
11. Barefoot Cinderella
12. Wherever I Go

Extras - 0/7
01. Zip-A-Dee-Doo-Dah
02. Part Of Your World
03. Ready, Set, Don't Go
04. I Thought I Lost You
05. I Hope You Find It
06. Send It On
07. We Belong To The Music
​
Wow. We've really cut down haven't we? I mean, no extras, two Hannah soundtracks down to only one song each, and Can't Be Tamed is now about even with Meet Miley Cyrus and Breakout. So, discuss! What do you feel like is seriously out of place and you want gone ASAP? What do you wish was still here? What are you hoping will win?
 
DJHazey

DJHazey

he/him
Nothing from the peanut gallery please, you asked for what I want out and you're getting it, no regrets:

  • Basically anything from HM1 can exit, especially "The Best of Both Worlds".
  • Anything except "Life's What You Make It" from HM2 can go, especially "Rock Star" which is one of my lowest scores in the entire rate.
  • Leave Meet Miley Cyrus unscathed, thank you very much, They're all amazing and we've eliminated my three lowest scores.
  • For Breakout, the trinity of "See You Again (Rock Mafia Remix)", "7 Things", and "Full Circle" can stay as long as they want and everything can leave in a hurry!
  • Not too fussed about losing anything from HM: The Movie.
  • Keep "He Could Be the One" as one of the last remaining Hannah songs please.
  • "Kicking & Screaming" is one of my favorite songs in the entire rate we better not cut it soon but I'm worried, "Party in the USA" will be here for the long haul and I'm not mad about it, the other two...see ya!
  • "Ordinary Girl" is a cute girl that can hang around for a bit.
  • For Can't Be Tamed, it's all about saying 'get lost' to "Scars" and "My Heart..." otherwise everything can remain unbothered until the Top 20.
 
Music Is Life & Death

Music Is Life & Death

He/Him
DJHazey said:
Nothing from the peanut gallery please, you asked for what I want out and you're getting it, no regrets:

  • Basically anything from HM1 can exit, especially "The Best of Both Worlds".
  • Anything except "Life's What You Make It" from HM2 can go, especially "Rock Star" which is one of my lowest scores in the entire rate.
  • Leave Meet Miley Cyrus unscathed, thank you very much, They're all amazing and we've eliminated my three lowest scores.
  • For Breakout, the trinity of "See You Again (Rock Mafia Remix)", "7 Things", and "Full Circle" can stay as long as they want and everything can leave in a hurry!
  • Not too fussed about losing anything from HM: The Movie.
  • Keep "He Could Be the One" as one of the last remaining Hannah songs please.
  • "Kicking & Screaming" is one of my favorite songs in the entire rate we better not cut it soon but I'm worried, "Party in the USA" will be here for the long haul and I'm not mad about it, the other two...see ya!
  • "Ordinary Girl" is a cute girl that can hang around for a bit.
  • For Can't Be Tamed, it's all about saying 'get lost' to "Scars" and "My Heart..." otherwise everything can remain unbothered until the Top 20.
Click to expand...
You really didn't think I wasn't going to comment?
  • You tasteless bastard, If We Were A Movie deserves top 10
  • Nobody's Perfect is a Hannah classic, expecting that out anytime soon is like thinking Party In The USA will go out soon.
  • Hmmmm...I'm okay either way depending on the songs
  • No. The remix of See You Again is great but it should be going soon, and a couple of other songs deserve to stick around a bit
  • Agreed with 2/3 songs but The Climb deserves top 5
  • Agreed
  • Agreed, mostly but I love When I Look At You so if it sticks around then I won't be mad
  • Agreed
  • The whole album is amazing so it can stick around, but Scars is amazing, you heathen. So is My Heart...but I'm not surprised at your tastelessness there.
 
iheartpoptarts

iheartpoptarts

she/her
I really don't think Meet Miley Cyrus is any better than most of the Hannah songs so it being like 70% here is a bit of a surprise.

P.S. Not that it's even remotely realistic, but I'd be quite happy if 'If We Were a Movie' won the whole thing. *dies of adorableness*
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Top