The Miley Cyrus Discography Rate Part 1: WINNER ANNOUNCED! FINISHED!

What's your favorite album featured here?

  • Meet Miley Cyrus

    Votes: 3 7.5%
  • Breakout

    Votes: 7 17.5%
  • The Time Of Our Lives

    Votes: 2 5.0%
  • Can't Be Tamed

    Votes: 24 60.0%
  • A Hannah Soundtrack

    Votes: 4 10.0%

  • Total voters
    40
I'm nearly done with the Kate Nash rate, then I'll do then Robyn one after that I'll do this one, so it might still be a bit before you get my ballot, but you can count on it @Music Is Life.

Dividing the rate the way it is was actually a great idea, because in a way it almost feels like pre and post-Bangerz Miley are two completely different people. Like, sometimes it's hard to wrap my head around the fact that current Miley is the same girl who used to play Hannah Montana.
Yay, I'm so happy to have you!!
And that's exactly what I was thinking! She does seem like a completely different person, but I think the seeds of Bangerz Miley were planted during this time period. I just thought it was a great way to separate them and include the Hannah stuff.
Also thanks for the flood of likes.
 
Going through old Miley threads and let me tag
@imperialsteroid
@SMG
@Robsolete
@man.tis.shrimp
in here.
On a slightly different note I feel like I might get more voters for part 2 than part 1.
Given some of my posts in the Miley threads, I'm surprised you want me to participate ddd.

Sadly, it's not for me. I do enjoy some of her early material, but my opinion of her is... much too poor for me to take part. Good luck, though.
 
Spotlight is the best pop song ever made and that's that on that.
You have an 11! Please participate!
Given some of my posts in the Miley threads, I'm surprised you want me to participate ddd.

Sadly, it's not for me. I do enjoy some of her early material, but my opinion of her is... much too poor for me to take part. Good luck, though.
Honestly I can't figure out who still likes her and who doesn't anymore. I wasn't sure if you did or not, especially since I'm reading through the Dead Petz thread for something to do, and you were positive at the time.
Thanks anyway.
 
he/him
Another example is Fly On The Wall, which on the surface is about a guy, but is more about paparazzi and tabloids. Obviously, she's not the first artist to sing about this, but Miley makes the song interesting with the production, giving it a more electronic and dance, but at the same time harder rock sound, synth-laden handclaps, as well as an altered voice (whether hers or someone else's, we don't know) singing the title. On paper it's a distorted mess, but it works wonders on the ears. (Well, for most of us.)

 
Hannah Montana 3: 9.69
albumhannah3.png

(created by @Suburbia)
The soundtrack for the third season is where I think Hannah got a little more interesting musically speaking, though the seeds for this were planted in the movie soundtrack. Yes, there's still a pop-rock basis to these songs, but I feel like the upbeat songs are just a little more groovy, a little more dancey, and kinda new wavey, more so than on previous soundtracks. Take album opener It's All Right Here. Starting with pounding drums, and quickly adding electric guitars, it sounds like a standard Hannah affair, but with a little more...something that I can't quite put my finger on. It also incorporates sounds of traffic and airplanes, because why not? And then just as it starts to build, it does something totally unexpected: it slows down into a groovy bridge that brings to mind surf boards and beaches, before launching into a fast paced final chorus. Or I Wanna Know You, which mixes in some horns to give the song a bit of a jazzy feel. Or the electro/hard-rock pulse of Supergirl, which brings to mind Fly On The Wall. Then there's Ice Cream Freeze (Let's Chill) a curious mix of bubblegum-pop, pop-rock and hoedown fun. And I have to talk about Let's Do This and Let's Get Crazy, both previously featured on the movie soundtrack. Let's Do This is pop-rock perfection with non-stop amazingness, and Let's Get Crazy is electro-rock perfection with non-stop amazingness, as well as incorporating new elements, such as paparazzi flashbulbs. If I add my scores for those two songs to the average for this soundtrack, it becomes 9.84, making it my highest Hannah average (oop). Without those two though, it's my third highest behind the movie, and Hannah Montana 2. This is actually pretty surprising to me, as I didn't realize I enjoyed these songs that much. They don't hold as much nostalgia for me as the first two soundtracks, so I thought I would like them less. I'm glad I was wrong. My heart won't be when the songs get kicked out though. Lyrically, the songs on the soundtrack advance on the previous themes of love, and the double life, as well as new themes of trying to figure out who you are and hiding our pain when needed. As is standard, the songs fit the themes of the third season of the show, which I'll talk more about throughout the rate. The soundtrack also featured a version of I Wanna Know You with David Archuleta, a song performed by the show's Oliver, Mitchel Musso, and a new version of If We Were A Movie, now a duet with Corbin Bleu (who payed Miley's crush Johnny in a couple episodes of the show.) The soundtrack went to number two on the Billboard 200 chart with sales of 137,000 copies, making it the first Hannah soundtrack to miss number one. I think this might have been the point when some people were getting a little sick of Hannah, as critical reception to the soundtrack was more mixed than the previous three, but Miley wasn't done owning the year 2009.
It's All Right Here: 9.25
Mixed Up: 9.5
He Could Be The One: 10
Just A Girl: 9
I Wanna Know You: 9.5
Supergirl: 10
Every Part Of Me: 10
Ice Cream Freeze (Let's Chill): 10
Don't Wanna Be Torn: 10
 
Last edited:
At least we both have the same lowest score for Hannah Montana: The Movie as well.

I made about five new discoveries, going through that album...one I even handed out a fresh 10 which is rare.
I noticed that! It made me so happy, especially as that song was a surprise 10 for me as well. I hope you find some discoveries in Hannah Montana 3 as well.
 
Ddd I lied. You're only getting one write-up today.
Sorry y'all, lost track of time talking to a friend about nerd stuff, and now I'm gonna have to be on stage soon. The weekend will be pretty quiet too, so Monday you'll get more.
 
Last edited:

Top