The Miley Cyrus Discography Rate Part 1: WINNER ANNOUNCED! FINISHED!

What's your favorite album featured here?

  • Meet Miley Cyrus

    Votes: 3 7.5%
  • Breakout

    Votes: 7 17.5%
  • The Time Of Our Lives

    Votes: 2 5.0%
  • Can't Be Tamed

    Votes: 24 60.0%
  • A Hannah Soundtrack

    Votes: 4 10.0%

  • Total voters
    40
I just audibly gasped seeing that elimination. What the hell went wrong??
Not...everyone...gave it a 10?
I’ll take a guess that the mess is partially my fault as an anti of that album....
Girl you gave it an 8. Its lowest score came from @iheartpoptarts and that was only a 5. It just ended up ranking lower.
Where do we start?

The top of this ranking is turning out to more of "GP's Favorite Miley Songs!" than a hardcore fan's ranking.
Well, just because they're singles doesn't mean fans don't love them. A lot of fans still love The Climb, Party In The U.S.A., 7 Things, See You Again and Who Owns My Heart. Then there's Nobody's Perfect. Which I love, but maybe shouldn't be in the top 6. If we had more voters, things might've turned out differently, but only 19 people wanted to and were able to vote. So we have to make do.
The thing a lot of these ~controversial~ coming-of-age pop moments have in common is that they seem to throw everything I love musically out the window at the same time.

(But then you get your 'Overprotected' and all is right in the world again.)
Ddddd I can definitely see how they don't fit your music tastes. But yes. That is a classic and one of Brit's best.
Also yes at this causing the most discussion so far.
 
'Can't Be Tamed' is fine. I know it's loved & was a hit... so I can understand it being in the top 10, I guess (even though I was always rather underwhelmed by it.) I will admit to feeling a bit shocked at the idea that it had a chance of winning. That opinion just isn't computing for me. I guess it's a decent declaration of independence anthem, but her best song (or even top 5)? I'm gonna need to think about that.

As far as 'The Climb', it isn't an absolute Miley fave of mine, but it feels way more classic than 'Can't Be Tamed' & top 5 worthy to me.
 
'Can't Be Tamed' is fine. I know it's loved & was a hit... so I can understand it being in the top 10, I guess (even though I was always rather underwhelmed by it.) I will admit to feeling a bit shocked at the idea that it had a chance of winning. That opinion just isn't computing for me. I guess it's a decent declaration of independence anthem, but her best song (or even top 5)? I'm gonna need to think about that.

As far as 'The Climb', it isn't an absolute Miley fave of mine, but it feels way more classic than 'Can't Be Tamed' & top 5 worthy to me.
I totally get why Can't Be Tamed - a dance-ready electro-pop song about breaking out of societal norms, and doing what you want - is more-loved on a pop music forum full of queers then The Climb - a soft rock almost-country ballad about the journey that life can be - by some. I feel they both deserve top 5, but I'm an original stan so I am biased.
 
Hmmmm...well, I'm not saying it will, but I'd rather have 7 Things win then See You Again, if only because it already won, but I'd also take all of the other three Miley songs over both of them dddd.

No, no, no, literally no. Though I'd be okay if Party in the USA won. My top 6...

6. Nobody's Perfect
5. Who Owns My Heart
4. The Climb
3. Party in the USA
2. See You Again
1. 7 Things

I know this is going to be a) unpopular and b) so wrong but I'll be over here chilling with my bad taste. It's okay.
 

Top