The Pussycat Dolls Discography Rate
- Thread starter LA Hallucinations
- Start date
Our next elimination is the most controversial yet and the first one with multiple 10s.
Fearing for Flirt.
#39
We Went As Far As We Felt Like Going
Average: 5.776
Highest: 2 x 9 (@Robsolete, @Conan), 3 x 8 (@Remorque, @Mr.Arroz, @LA Hallucinations)
Lowest: 1 x 0 (@Serg.), 1 x 3 (@DJHazey)
Another PCD song, another cover. This is a cover of a Labelle song, which was also used for the soundtrack of the movie Shark Tale. Y’all did this one wrong. Melody wailing in the background and Carmit appearing make this bop one of the better covers they’ve done. A farwell single teas.
The title is indeed long, as Slice of Life points out, ‘What kind of long-ass song title? She doesn't have the range.’ Who are you talking bout boo? Pecans is not here for vocals galore, ‘Ad-libs overload.. wow. Nicole and Melody's vocal acrobatics are so extra on this. I don't dislike this by any means but it's painful to listen to. I feel like I'm having a seizure when Nicole is bellowing and Melody's vocals are ringing in my ears. Do I hear some Carmit too?’ Yup, and Remorque is here for her, ‘Well, it’s kinda fun and a nice little soundtrack cut. Justice for those backing singers who are doing the hard work. Though I do actually love Carmit’s part here.’ If there were one person to stan for the Shark Tale soundtrack, it would have to be Sprockrooster, and he doesn’t disappoint, ‘The Shark Tale soundtrack is amazing and I did not make the connection at first when I heard Don't Cha as them being also featured there. Great track, but in time it has not aged that well. Not to the point I do not like it, but the love is gone.’ HollyDunnSomething is not impressed, ‘Meh’, and PCDPG thinks it's ‘Not that special.’
Well, it’s an acquired taste xxxx. Speaking of acquired taste, Filler is here, ‘Specifically, that's to the end of Flirt, then hitting stop before I have to hear this’. I’ll let this one slide because of the Flirt stanning. Next up, the ever-so-patient evilsin, ‘That's like some contemporary cha-cha-cha or something. Reminded me of Girls Aloud's "Why Do It?". Nn, I’ve never heard a Girls Aloud song so I’ll just pretend to agree. Weslicious has overdosed on covers, ‘At this stage of the album, another 'covers medley' seems a bit surplus to requirements’, while Epic Chocolat ‘appreciates Prince’s influence’.
Original:
I didn't leave commentary for this song..
Whoops, sorry. Fixed now!
D
Deleted member 3416
I see our love for The Little Mermaid has meant we've merged into one somehow.
Ha! Mermaids unite.
#38
Whatchamacallit
Average: 5.793
Highest: 3 x 10 (@DJHazey, @lemonsqueezyy, @Weslicious)
Lowest: 1 x 0 (@2014), 1 x 1 (@Serg.)
Bourgie fifi ooh la oui oui Paris to Japan
Ichi ni san shi Pierre Cardin
And the girls go (uh uh uh uh hoo)
Yeah, the fly girls go (uh uh uh uh hoo) yeah
In a typical Timbaland fashion, this song is all over the place, thus explaining the range of scores it got. It’s a bop but it can be very grating to the ears.
Sprockrooster will be happy to see the streak of his favourites being eliminated end, ‘Stupid title. Hideous song. Skip and moving on.’ Slice of Life is getting ha life, ‘Why is this so hoochie (to borrow a term from Miss Tyra)??? Dddd it's kinda iconic way. I bet this would pop off in the clerb or something.’ We’ll request it in a clerb when I come to conquer the Filpino party scene. Looks like Weslicious will be joining us, ‘Braggadocio bop! I love it. Not performing it properly on tour was questionable.’ Yeah, shame it was only an interlude, it would have gone off live. Meanwhile evilsin continues with references I don’t get, ‘This is like a sister to Puakenikeni, only the latter is the prettier one.’ To Remorque, ‘It’s that “je ne sais quoi”.’ Je connais, the quoi is 2000s Timbaland production, which PCDPG is here for, ‘A fun song!’. On the other hand, Reboot is not, ‘I hate this.’ Filler mimics the song, ‘WHAT A MESS I LOVE IT’. It has grown on me a bit.
Sprockrooster will be happy to see the streak of his favourites being eliminated end, ‘Stupid title. Hideous song. Skip and moving on.’ Slice of Life is getting ha life, ‘Why is this so hoochie (to borrow a term from Miss Tyra)??? Dddd it's kinda iconic way. I bet this would pop off in the clerb or something.’ We’ll request it in a clerb when I come to conquer the Filpino party scene. Looks like Weslicious will be joining us, ‘Braggadocio bop! I love it. Not performing it properly on tour was questionable.’ Yeah, shame it was only an interlude, it would have gone off live. Meanwhile evilsin continues with references I don’t get, ‘This is like a sister to Puakenikeni, only the latter is the prettier one.’ To Remorque, ‘It’s that “je ne sais quoi”.’ Je connais, the quoi is 2000s Timbaland production, which PCDPG is here for, ‘A fun song!’. On the other hand, Reboot is not, ‘I hate this.’ Filler mimics the song, ‘WHAT A MESS I LOVE IT’. It has grown on me a bit.
MESS at this completely slipping my mind and thinking you were talking about something Russian. Forgive me, Nicole, for I have sinned.
What kind of a Russian word "пуакеникени" is in your opinion?
Girl, calm down. Lemme rub those exhausted feet for ya.I've had a long day, сука
Yaaaas.
D
Deleted member 3416
First solo song out!
#37
Until U Love U (Nicole Scherzinger)
Average: 5.983
Highest: 1 x 10 (@Pecans), 1 x 9 (@Robsolete)
Lowest: 1 x 3 (@GhettoPrincess), 5 x 4 (@Terminus, @lemonsqueezyy, @send photo, @Slice of Life, @Filler)
#37
Until U Love U (Nicole Scherzinger)
Average: 5.983
Highest: 1 x 10 (@Pecans), 1 x 9 (@Robsolete)
Lowest: 1 x 3 (@GhettoPrincess), 5 x 4 (@Terminus, @lemonsqueezyy, @send photo, @Slice of Life, @Filler)
Nn at Diane Warren writing this. Every girl got a solo track, so obviously Nicole had to get (an official) one as well. Kii at this being the only one not titled as ‘introducing’. I find it to be cute, it’s pretty standard though, Nicole can do much better.
Remorque/Nostradamus predicts the outcome of the rate, ‘The worst of the solo efforts to these ears. There! I said it! Though I can’t really fault the girl, because she could fart and it would sound good…’ Ddd, completely accurate. Slice of Life crosses the line, ‘I now understand why Nicole is a failure as a solo popstar.’ Missy, we do not joke about that in this house. Pecans stans for ha life, ‘I'm guessing this would have been on her scrapped début? I love this: the build is amazing. Nicole's vocals shine so much. Until U Love U is actually a great addition to Nicole's discography.’ I don’t think so, it doesn’t appear on the tracklist of the scrapped album, but it could be from the sessions. I think Nicole just wanted an ‘introducing’ track as well nn. Filler is not feeling this filler, ‘"UULU" is an interesting initialism for a song. Can't be many UULUs in pop. I have nothing else to say about this song, I don't understand what it is, I don't care enough to find out, just let me go to bed already.’ Me writing this write-up teas xx. PCDPG finds it ‘cheesy’, while evilsin @s Nicole, ‘Nicole, no! Drop that boo-boo now!’. Sprockrooster is semi-here for it, ‘Always here for a dramatic power ballad, but aside from that it is nothing special.’ Yeah, it is pretty by-the-book. Weslicious has already gotten to know Nicole, ‘Did Nicole really need a 'solo' track to be grouped with the others? Really? It's not even that great.’ Looks like everyone agrees, as this was voted as the worst solo song.
Remorque/Nostradamus predicts the outcome of the rate, ‘The worst of the solo efforts to these ears. There! I said it! Though I can’t really fault the girl, because she could fart and it would sound good…’ Ddd, completely accurate. Slice of Life crosses the line, ‘I now understand why Nicole is a failure as a solo popstar.’ Missy, we do not joke about that in this house. Pecans stans for ha life, ‘I'm guessing this would have been on her scrapped début? I love this: the build is amazing. Nicole's vocals shine so much. Until U Love U is actually a great addition to Nicole's discography.’ I don’t think so, it doesn’t appear on the tracklist of the scrapped album, but it could be from the sessions. I think Nicole just wanted an ‘introducing’ track as well nn. Filler is not feeling this filler, ‘"UULU" is an interesting initialism for a song. Can't be many UULUs in pop. I have nothing else to say about this song, I don't understand what it is, I don't care enough to find out, just let me go to bed already.’ Me writing this write-up teas xx. PCDPG finds it ‘cheesy’, while evilsin @s Nicole, ‘Nicole, no! Drop that boo-boo now!’. Sprockrooster is semi-here for it, ‘Always here for a dramatic power ballad, but aside from that it is nothing special.’ Yeah, it is pretty by-the-book. Weslicious has already gotten to know Nicole, ‘Did Nicole really need a 'solo' track to be grouped with the others? Really? It's not even that great.’ Looks like everyone agrees, as this was voted as the worst solo song.
Also our last song under 6.0!
D
Deleted member 3416
Poor Nicole.
:format(jpeg):mode_rgb():quality(40)/discogs-images/R-5875586-1436101207-5496.jpeg.jpg)
