The Pussycat Dolls Discography Rate
- Thread starter LA Hallucinations
- Start date
Melody and Ashley still have theirs in!
D
Deleted member 3416
C'mon Ashley, be victorious.
Slice of Life
Staff member
She was my second fave!
And Melody's solo better be the most successful solo in this rate. Kween of Pop and Extra Adlibs!
Good morning.
Time for a new elimination.
#32
Sway
Average: 6.448
Highest: 2 x 10 (@lemonsqueezyy, @send photo)
Lowest: 2 x 3 (@tylerc904, @Robsolete)
I’m pretty sure this is the first song of theirs that I’ve ever heard and now we’re here. This is the first loss that hurts, I think it’s smooth, atmospheric and just all around brilliant. It’s by far the best of their jazziest songs. The video is also a lewk. And according to Wikipedia In 2012, the song charted on the South Korea Gaon International Chart at number 111, due to strong digital downloads. We love a song with international longevity and a Korean classic
TWICE are shaking, f(x) are hiding, Red Velvet have cancelled their second album, etc.
Let’s start with evilsin spilling some tea, ‘Truly shows how Nicole can sing anything and do it brilliantly.’ In the grand scheme of things, she is such an underrated vocalist. Slice of Life is a hater, ‘I always thought this was a little on the flat side. Keep it.’ Me when I first saw your ass xxxx. Weslicious gets it, ‘Nice. An obvious cover, but it was just a soundtrack song from a relatively unknown group at the time so I'm not going to do too much on it.’ Epic Chocolat likes the climax, ‘It gets catchier towards the end.’ Sprockrooster serves taste, ‘I love to sway with Nicole’, along with lemonsqueezyy, ‘The perfect cover for Nicole’s tone, but wait… how many girls were in the group here?’ Okay but Melody’s backing vocals near the end are iconic. PCDPG wonders, ‘I appreciate the song as the bridge from the old skool pussycat dolls to the recording group. If you look closely in the music video you can see a blond woman behind Carmit and Melody in their group shots. I wonder whether Kaya left the group when the music video finalized as she’s pretty much cut from the whole video.’ You’re probably right, as she’s not on the single cover either. The song brings up nostalgia in Remorque, ‘Ugh… A half point more than Feelin’ Good got, because it was the first video I ever watched of them, therefore brings up a certain melancholy’, while Filler seems to be immune, ‘Shall we not?’ Yes, we shall.
Let’s start with evilsin spilling some tea, ‘Truly shows how Nicole can sing anything and do it brilliantly.’ In the grand scheme of things, she is such an underrated vocalist. Slice of Life is a hater, ‘I always thought this was a little on the flat side. Keep it.’ Me when I first saw your ass xxxx. Weslicious gets it, ‘Nice. An obvious cover, but it was just a soundtrack song from a relatively unknown group at the time so I'm not going to do too much on it.’ Epic Chocolat likes the climax, ‘It gets catchier towards the end.’ Sprockrooster serves taste, ‘I love to sway with Nicole’, along with lemonsqueezyy, ‘The perfect cover for Nicole’s tone, but wait… how many girls were in the group here?’ Okay but Melody’s backing vocals near the end are iconic. PCDPG wonders, ‘I appreciate the song as the bridge from the old skool pussycat dolls to the recording group. If you look closely in the music video you can see a blond woman behind Carmit and Melody in their group shots. I wonder whether Kaya left the group when the music video finalized as she’s pretty much cut from the whole video.’ You’re probably right, as she’s not on the single cover either. The song brings up nostalgia in Remorque, ‘Ugh… A half point more than Feelin’ Good got, because it was the first video I ever watched of them, therefore brings up a certain melancholy’, while Filler seems to be immune, ‘Shall we not?’ Yes, we shall.
Another one in the casket.
I don't want to fall in love
Just want to have a little fun
Then you came and swept me up
And now I'm done so done
Falling madly deeply I
Surprise myself enough to find
That what's begun is love
And now I'm done so done, I'm done
I don't want to fall in love
Just want to have a little fun
Then you came and swept me up
And now I'm done so done
Falling madly deeply I
Surprise myself enough to find
That what's begun is love
And now I'm done so done, I'm done
#31
I’m Done
Average: 6.500
Highest: 1 x 10 (@Mr.Arroz), 1 x 9.5 (@MollieSwift21)
Lowest: 1 x 3.5 (@Slice of Life), 3 x 4 (@haps, @Conan, @Weslicious)
I’m Done
Average: 6.500
Highest: 1 x 10 (@Mr.Arroz), 1 x 9.5 (@MollieSwift21)
Lowest: 1 x 3.5 (@Slice of Life), 3 x 4 (@haps, @Conan, @Weslicious)
Another elimination that I really like. It’s a cute ballad, albeit Nicole-heavy. I don’t really have much to say about it, though. It wasn’t performed live (I think) and it’s a cute closer (although not really if you factor in all the rereleases of Doll Domination, dddd).
PCDPG finds it to be ‘One of their best ballads and one of my favorites.’ Reboot also likes it, ‘I love a good ballad.’ Evilsin is content, ‘Ooh, this is nice, surely nice to end an album with’, which Filler quickly shuts down, ‘No I'm not, there are 11 tracks to go on this album alone. What the fuck is up with Doll Domination, I'm tired, let me go, fucking hell.’ I love it when the commentary writes itself, thanks gals x. Sprockrooster confuses me a bit, ‘Not sure how I feel about that dream catcher sound on the album. I love the effect, but what is the use? Is there some meaning? I NEED TO KNOW.’ Nn, what is a dream catcher sound? I’ve googled it and I’m still confused. Weslicious calls it ‘forgettable and pointless’ and Slice of Life agrees, ‘Same, cyst. I'm done.’ GhettoPrincess wonders, ‘Another one from the scrapped Nicole solo album? Not as boring as Happily Never After though.’ Hmm, could be, especially the former half is very Nicole-centred. We’re closing things off with Remorque, ‘Oh, the drama… Yet this is one of Nicole’s best ever ballads and describes entirely what we (and the rest of the band) felt after this album.’ And what the GP felt as soon as Nicole started her solo career? A mess, a kii, a cackle.
PCDPG finds it to be ‘One of their best ballads and one of my favorites.’ Reboot also likes it, ‘I love a good ballad.’ Evilsin is content, ‘Ooh, this is nice, surely nice to end an album with’, which Filler quickly shuts down, ‘No I'm not, there are 11 tracks to go on this album alone. What the fuck is up with Doll Domination, I'm tired, let me go, fucking hell.’ I love it when the commentary writes itself, thanks gals x. Sprockrooster confuses me a bit, ‘Not sure how I feel about that dream catcher sound on the album. I love the effect, but what is the use? Is there some meaning? I NEED TO KNOW.’ Nn, what is a dream catcher sound? I’ve googled it and I’m still confused. Weslicious calls it ‘forgettable and pointless’ and Slice of Life agrees, ‘Same, cyst. I'm done.’ GhettoPrincess wonders, ‘Another one from the scrapped Nicole solo album? Not as boring as Happily Never After though.’ Hmm, could be, especially the former half is very Nicole-centred. We’re closing things off with Remorque, ‘Oh, the drama… Yet this is one of Nicole’s best ever ballads and describes entirely what we (and the rest of the band) felt after this album.’ And what the GP felt as soon as Nicole started her solo career? A mess, a kii, a cackle.
A mandatory messy fan video:
Couldn't find any live performances, so here's @send photo, @Slice of Life and I covering it:
Last edited:
Hm. It might not be called dream catcher in English. I think most Americans have it on their porch and as the wind blows the rocks hit each other and make a tingling sound.
That is what I heard on I'm Done and I wonder why.
Those two are the best!
I think you mean a wind chime.
If Melody was gonna ignore the Nicole solo songs when choosing her favourite PCD song, she probably wouldn't have a favourite PCD song.
Here is our top 30, ladies!
TOP 30
PCD (10/15)
Don’t Cha
Beep
Wait A Minute
Stickwitu
Buttons
I Don’t Need A Man
Hot Stuff (I Want You Back)
Bite The Dust
Tainted Love/Where Did Our Love Go
Flirt
Doll Domination (18/27)
When I Grow Up
Bottle Pop
Whatcha Think About That
I Hate This Part
Takin’ Over The World
Who’s Gonna Love You
Happily Never After
Magic
Halo
Elevator
Hush Hush – Original Version
Love The Way You Love Me
Jai Ho! (You Are My Destiny)
Top Of The World
Painted Windows
Lights, Camera, Action
Space – Introducing Melody Thornton
Played – Introducing Ashley Roberts
TOP 30
PCD (10/15)
Don’t Cha
Beep
Wait A Minute
Stickwitu
Buttons
I Don’t Need A Man
Hot Stuff (I Want You Back)
Bite The Dust
Tainted Love/Where Did Our Love Go
Flirt
Doll Domination (18/27)
When I Grow Up
Bottle Pop
Whatcha Think About That
I Hate This Part
Takin’ Over The World
Who’s Gonna Love You
Happily Never After
Magic
Halo
Elevator
Hush Hush – Original Version
Love The Way You Love Me
Jai Ho! (You Are My Destiny)
Top Of The World
Painted Windows
Lights, Camera, Action
Space – Introducing Melody Thornton
Played – Introducing Ashley Roberts
Extras (2/4)
Hush Hush; Hush Hush (single version)
Bad Girl
Hush Hush; Hush Hush (single version)
Bad Girl
So we're at a 6.5 average and Bad Girl is still in?
D
Deleted member 22682
Yas at Melody's solo getting into the top 30.
Eeeek, just catching up and the Baby Love single cover is soooo awful!
Eeeek, just catching up and the Baby Love single cover is soooo awful!
The tragic fact the Melody solo deserves to be in the top 30 because of some other songs.