Sammy, Steps and PCD in one show and then I can go and stalk Vanessa Amorosi and Jessica Mauboy?
Let me book flights.
The Pussycat Dolls
- Thread starter angelX
- Start date
Let me book flights.
Found this interview with Melody from earlier this year pretty much dismissing her ever going back to the group. Her reasoning makes perfect sense & can't blame her either tho I do miss her presence.
he/him
This line-up...what kind of cross-section of 2007 Andy and 2019 Andy?
I think they probably do not consider that a proper reveal/performance of the song, which I am inclined to think myself as well. Do you really want to put the song out there off the back of a 44 seconds snippet that's mixed with elements from other songs? But will they have another platform as big to promote it on the back of?
He/They
D
Deleted member 2097
I’ll be amazed if they don’t do *something* in the US.
Why are we still discussing why React is not releases when @Hotel_paper already told us the girls couldn't agree on its release?
Mr.Arroz
Staff member
He/Him/His
D
Deleted member 10466
I’ve watched this performance approximately 4,394 times since last night. They REALLY DID THAT.
So we are criticizing the likes of Cheryl and Selena for their “poor” vocals, but praising this? No baby, no.
D
Deleted member 2097
I adore ‘Woman Up’.
The performance was kind of awkward to me. The Flashdance homage at the end was fun. I don't know. The camera focusing so much on Nicole only really did make it feel like a solo performance with back up dancers, which I get in essence is what they've always been, but it still felt like for a big "its a Pussycat Dolls reunion!" moment you'd think they'd try to make it clear this was a "group". Nicole not singing much and constantly shouting out to the audience also felt a bit off. That works in a live concert setting but not so much for a television performance. They all look great and move great and the songs are still bops, so there's that.
I am dumbfounded as a casual fan to find myself currently obsessing over this group, having barely remembered their existence prior to this killer performance.
Can somebody please help me with some age-old PCD mysteries?
1. Why does it seem like Kimberly is not a 'full' member in the Don't Cha video e.g. being left out of the chair routine in the third verse? Was the lineup still being decided at this point? During the chorus routine, you could be forgiven for thinking there were some additional girls in the group as well - were any of them genuine contenders?
2. Why didn't Asia end up joining the group? Did she or the group ever comment on this situation?
3. I don't remember Carmit leaving causing much of a stir at the time. Did she leave on good terms? Again, were there any statements of note from either party at the time?
4. The legendary incident of Melody storming onto the stage mid-performance of Buttons is a classic - but again, went relatively unnoticed at the time (I could only dig up a 2-page thread on here and it wasn't necessarily conclusive that the performance hadn't been designed that way). Am I correct in thinking the media didn't pick it up as indicative of a rift within the group? Did Melody ever comment?
5. Whatever came of the entirely new lineup of PCD when our originals, bar Nicole, had all quit? Did they ever perform or do anything of note? Did we ever hear comments from them after nothing came to fruition?
6. Have any of the girls from this line-up commented on the allegations by Kaya Jones?
Apologies for being 'brand new', but I am fascinated by the history of this group and want to pay close attention this time round!
Can somebody please help me with some age-old PCD mysteries?
1. Why does it seem like Kimberly is not a 'full' member in the Don't Cha video e.g. being left out of the chair routine in the third verse? Was the lineup still being decided at this point? During the chorus routine, you could be forgiven for thinking there were some additional girls in the group as well - were any of them genuine contenders?
2. Why didn't Asia end up joining the group? Did she or the group ever comment on this situation?
3. I don't remember Carmit leaving causing much of a stir at the time. Did she leave on good terms? Again, were there any statements of note from either party at the time?
4. The legendary incident of Melody storming onto the stage mid-performance of Buttons is a classic - but again, went relatively unnoticed at the time (I could only dig up a 2-page thread on here and it wasn't necessarily conclusive that the performance hadn't been designed that way). Am I correct in thinking the media didn't pick it up as indicative of a rift within the group? Did Melody ever comment?
5. Whatever came of the entirely new lineup of PCD when our originals, bar Nicole, had all quit? Did they ever perform or do anything of note? Did we ever hear comments from them after nothing came to fruition?
6. Have any of the girls from this line-up commented on the allegations by Kaya Jones?
Apologies for being 'brand new', but I am fascinated by the history of this group and want to pay close attention this time round!
Wikipedia is the first place to start which would give you insight into a lot your questions & history of the group. Asia was never actually going to be an actual member. It was simply a marketing gimmick to have the Doll brand extend into reality TV.
