The Rate & Graphics Help Desk | Page 4 | The Popjustice Forum

The Rate & Graphics Help Desk

Discussion in 'Charts, rates etc' started by ohnostalgia, Jun 8, 2018.

  1. londonrain

    londonrain Staff Member

    I've been using for my rates and it's gone well so far.
    Sprockrooster and slaybellz like this.
  2. Hiiiii is there anyone who would be willing to make graphics for my Miley Cyrus rate? Obviously it'll be a while before it's ready to open, but I wanna make sure everything is ready. If you can, feel free to PM me, or post in here whenever you have a chance. Thanks in advance!
    londonrain likes this.
  3. ohnostalgia

    ohnostalgia Staff Member

    I’m gonna have to pass on that one, but maybe someone who can stand Miley will volunteer.
    londonrain and Music Is Life like this.
  4. @ohnostalgia - can I secure your services for the Anime Rate? A Sailor Moon and Revolutionary Girl Utena crossed over with some @ohnostalgia art is all I never knew I needed in my life! Ddddd
    evilsin and ohnostalgia like this.
  5. Haha well thanks anyway.
    And thanks for the good laugh this gave me.
    Last edited: Aug 2, 2019
  6. ohnostalgia

    ohnostalgia Staff Member

    When is it happening?
    berserkboi likes this.
  7. I am sixth on the queue so not for a few months...
  8. ohnostalgia

    ohnostalgia Staff Member

    Then I should be able to help.
    berserkboi likes this.
  9. ohnostalgia

    ohnostalgia Staff Member

    I finished the Little Mix Rate. How many songs are you needing?
    slaybellz likes this.
  10. Great! Like 30ish. I'll PM you!
    ohnostalgia likes this.
  11. I’m due to start my One Album Girlband Rate very soon and I have everything written up. Unfortunately there aren’t a lot of quality pictures and gifs up on the internet and I was wondering if anybody was up for giving me a hand.

    It would be much appreciated.
    londonrain likes this.
  12. Tribal Spaceman

    Tribal Spaceman Staff Member

    Great idea for a thread. I wouldn't mind doing some graphics in the future, as long as I had a bit of notice.
    ohnostalgia likes this.
  13. ohnostalgia

    ohnostalgia Staff Member

    @Music Is Life here’s your chance!
    Music Is Life likes this.
  14. londonrain

    londonrain Staff Member

    Hosting a rate is fun, but it's also a lot of work!

    Here's a sense of the amount of time it takes:
    I know I tend to take about an hour per write-up including PJ formatting, and even that is quite a lot of time!

    What do you need to run a rate?

    1. Have an idea.

    Rates on the forum mostly fall into one of these categories:
    • Discography rates. These consist of an artist's entire discography, including all songs from all their albums, and sometimes including B-sides, soundtrack contributions, appearances on other artist's albums, unreleased tracks or other rarities, depending on how popular the act is and how long it makes the song list. (As a general rule, rates tend to vary between 50 and 100 songs in length. If you're going over 100 songs in a discography rate, make sure it's for an act who is so popular that you'll still get lots of voters. You may also consider splitting a discography rate into multiple parts to cover different periods of a prolific artist's career, as has been done with acts like Mariah Carey, Namie Amuro, the Pet Shop Boys and Ayumi Hamasaki.)
    • Singles rates. These are largely meant to cover all the singles by an artist and usually occur when the host is either unwilling to handle a huge discography or is not confident that the artist is so popular on the forum that there will be lots of voters keen to rate random B-sides by them. You can host a singles rate for an act who has had a discography rate already, or vice versa.
    • Multi-artist "versus" rates. Usually a set of songs by a small number of acts being pitted against each other. For example, you could choose to pit all of Lizzo's singles against all of Charli XCX's singles, since they each have a fairly small number of singles and the total song list would be relatively short. It's more common for rates to be organised around a concept, however, and it's important to have a clear concept that makes it self-evident what is and isn't in the song list. For example, the Billboard #1s of the '90s rate (run in two parts - 1990-1994 and 1995-1999) simply chose a song list that consisted of every song that hit #1 in that period. You could also choose to just take a bunch of albums that are similar in period and/or genre and pit those against each other - for example, the 2018 Big Pop Girls rate included the biggest pop albums by female artists and a few additional hit singles from acts whose albums couldn't make it into the rate for one reason or another. Whatever your concept is, make it clear.
    • Song contests. Song contests have their own scoring system and their own spreadsheet style. PM me separately if you want advice on how to run a song contest.

    2. Put yourself into the rate queue.

    • Propose your idea by posting in the Rate Queue to see if anyone is interested. This isn't compulsory but it will help you gauge whether your rate is DOA or not.
    • If you're a solo host who is hosting for the first time, find a backup host. A backup host is always a good idea, but it's particularly important to make sure there is someone else on hand to cover in case you are suddenly unable to post eliminations for some reason - life happens, and it's useful for someone else to be able to pick up where you left off, or to post guest eliminations if you’re going to be unable to post for a short period of time. Nobody likes to put the effort into voting in a rate and then find out that the host has delayed or abandoned the results halfway! If you can’t find a backup host, ask for one in this thread or the rate queue thread... and if you’re still unable to find one, ask me.
    • Tag or PM @RainOnFire to ask to be included in the queue. You will be assigned to a "list" according to the rules on page 1 of the thread. Please read those rules, because they also tell you things like when you will be allowed to start, how often you can use voting extensions, and so on.
    • The rate queue does not apply to Eurovision or K-pop rates. If you are running a rate of exclusively Eurovision songs, it's usual to run it in the Eurovision sub-forum rather than the Charts, rates, etc. sub-forum. The K-pop sub-forum has its own general rate thread, so if your rate consists exclusively of Korean acts then you should consider posting your idea there and running it in that sub-forum. There's nothing stopping you from running these rates in the Charts, rates, etc. forum if you want to - it's just that those sub-forums will have a ready-made audience for you!

    3. Put together a spreadsheet.
    • Familiarise yourself with Excel. I recommend using Google Sheets if you're likely to be posting from more than one device, but you can also use Microsoft Excel if you think you won't need to be able to access your sheets from the cloud.
    • Design your spreadsheet. It doesn't need to be pretty, but it does need to work. The basic formula that needs to work is the one that gives you the average for each song, but there are tons of other useful formulas which will give you ranks, album averages, the highest and lowest scores for each song, and much more! This is the one I used for my 2018 R&B Legends rate, which featured three full albums from 2018 and a number of extras. The second tab is the most relevant one, but I also had the first tab to help me calculate album averages and the highest and lowest scorers for each act. You do not need to use this spreadsheet as a template, but you're welcome to if you like.
    4. Design your graphics and choose an image hosting site.
    • Figure out your image format. I tend to use the official single covers where available and then create my own covers for tracks that don't have single covers, but you don't have to do this - some people create their own covers for all the songs. If, like me, you have the graphic design skills of a potato, you can either have a bash anyway or you can ask for help in the Graphics Help Desk.
    • Choose an image hosting site. I personally like but a lot of people swear by It doesn't really matter as long as the images embed properly - both imgur and Photobucket can be problematic on the forum.

    5. Set a voting deadline and hustle for voters.

    Remember to promote the rate by tagging people in the rate thread and/or posting in the artist threads and the Rate Queue thread. It's a shame if fans of a particular act don't know about that act being included in a rate, and a very small rate can have some very odd results!

    6. Choose a format and pace for your rate eliminations.

    This is quite important. Usually one or two eliminations a day tends to work fast enough for most people, but think through how many you can reasonably do in a week and how many songs you have. If you take too long, it delays the start of the next rate. If the result is that you're going to take 18 months to finish your rate, rethink the pace or number of songs!

    7. Enter your ballots and post your rate eliminations.

    This is hopefully self-explanatory. Some hosts don't really participate in the thread apart from posting each elimination, and some hosts (like me) like to engage in the inevitable drama between eliminations. If your songs are at all popular, people will have views about the scores other people gave, and that's fine. The arguments are part of the fun! If something gets massively out of hand, however, feel free to report the relevant posts.

    This is not an exhaustive list of answers to every question you might have, and this thread is meant to encourage discussion about things that are unclear. Feel free to post about your own experiences hosting or any questions that you have!
    Last edited: Sep 9, 2019
    myblood, Sail On, chanex and 27 others like this.
  15. 2014

    2014 Staff Member

  16. [​IMG]
  17. londonrain

    londonrain Staff Member


    And Koda Kumi.

  18. Could you imagine the endless timeline you'd have if you did a full discography Rate for some of the traditional French ladies of music who had over 500 songs in their discography? A shame the likes of Sheila, France, Dalida, Mireille, Edith etc won't ever have that here but no one would want the 10 year timeline to complete this either lol

    A Spotlight or two for each of these fantastic artists is in order!
  19. Great idea @londonrain! I believe I will start to haunt this thread when I start my first only rate dddd
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.