The Saturdays
- Thread starter poploz
- Start date
TJ said:
No thank you, I choose my own destiny. [/britney stan]
The 30 day teases would be overkill. Have we not learned from Britney's "Hold It Against Me" countdown? Took too long. Even when the girls did the promo for "Notorious" it kind of gave away too many scenes from parts of the video and didn't really get that many views or pump me up as a fan. I think making an announcement 2-3 days before the video premiere is perfect in my opinion. Getting the girls to show up to a big radio show to premiere the song would be ideal with a day ortwo of anticipation.
Scaper said:
Top 10 dosent suit them , they are a gimic......not a girl group
H
Hitori
Sometimes I forget that Mollie was rejected from The X Factor two times, but it proved that if you work hard enough, you'll make it just like she has. It would be amazing if she becomes a judge.
TJ said:
As many of us remember, he learnt about her a long time ago. She would be a better judge than Frankie, but I don't watch the show so I don't know much about it. I'm a bit curious about how Tulisa did last year, for instance.
The girls aren't controversial or outspoken enough. The X Factor relies upon drama and I can't see any of The Saturdays ever causing any especially not Mollie. Frankie comes across as pretty bland when she's on TV. Rochelle or Una are the only ones I could see working but I don't think it'll ever happen.
Watch Vanessa become the judge now.
Rochelle needs to come on the X-Factor and show them who's the new HBIC.
That, or Una could come in, but she strikes me as more of a perfect fit with "The Voice". Rochelle doesn't play off well against other people sometimes (which is why she would work on X-Factor), but Una does.
Ness probably wouldn't even make it to the first taping... Mollie would work, I guess. The new nation's sweetheart. And Frankie isn't exactly the most loved member among the X-Factor demographic.
That, or Una could come in, but she strikes me as more of a perfect fit with "The Voice". Rochelle doesn't play off well against other people sometimes (which is why she would work on X-Factor), but Una does.
Ness probably wouldn't even make it to the first taping... Mollie would work, I guess. The new nation's sweetheart. And Frankie isn't exactly the most loved member among the X-Factor demographic.
LightningRider said:
Rochelle and Tulisa are good friends, I think they would make a good pairing. Una has a great personality and when she's talking about music, her passion is really obvious, she'd work well too. I just don't think Mollie could bring the tension that's needed between judges, she's too nice and she'd probably be eaten alive by the press and judges alike. Rochelle and Una seem like the only ones who could handle it.
Simon didn't even know who Frankie was though and she's the most recognisable member, I think the general perception is that they're all a bit bland and uncontroversial so I don't think any of them would ever get the job. They go for people who are mouthy and/or high profile.
See, I was just thinking about that recently. The girls don't really have much going for them, do they? I mean, the only time we ever see people talking about them is when they've got a new single out. The only press they get is when they're out and about and that doesn't exactly make me pay attention. Other than that, they're completely out of public consciousness.
Yes! So she can give every contestant this look: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NCXqpylOy-c#t=0m41s I actually think she'd be a great judge, she's been in the music business quite a long time, she comes across as quite knowledgeable and she's got all the contacts.