The irony of me starting this thread and only just now watching 5cream a.k.a. Five Cream last night. I intentionally saved it for Halloween 2022 and have avoided this thread and all spoilers completely.
I have to say that I need some time to process my feelings on it. Some of it was immediately great (I loved the fake-out moments where the film made you think the killer was about to reveal themself), seeing the original gang reunite was genuinely emotional, Neve Campbell and Courtney Cox gave incredible performances, and there were times I was extremely on edge. I was entertained throughout. However, I do have strong feelings that not everything "worked." Mostly some of the new characters not being nearly as magnetic or likeable as some others. I wish the killer reveal had been more of a gag. Although I stan Amber!!
I need some time to better articulate my feelings. It was definitely the best since Scream 2, no question.