The SHINee Discography Rate: Part One (WINNER) | Page 2 | The Popjustice Forum

The SHINee Discography Rate: Part One (WINNER)

Discussion in 'K-pop' started by eccentricsimply, Mar 30, 2018.

  1. [​IMG]

    Ddd the album averages are deceiving since an album with mainly 8s and 9s can become a 7-average with one 4 score. Over nearly 4/5ths of my scores are 6+ and one half are 7+, and I don’t have anything below a 4. I thought I was super fair for someone with only a brief understanding of their music. If my ballot is a bit much though, feel free to dump it since I wouldn't want to ruin the experience of others.
     
    vague, Deja-Boo, vikeyeol and 5 others like this.
  2. No no it isn't!!!! It was just a joke, it's great babe.
     
  3. Ddddd I just wanted to make sure, but yay.

    Me going into this having no clue if my 10s are fandom faves and going in blind to if they'll succeed:
    [​IMG]
     
  4. No PM-able list? The level of unprofessionalism...

    Replay
    In My Room
    Real
    Love Should Go On

    Amigo
    Forever or Never
    Love Like Oxygen
    Romantic
    Love's Way
    One For Me
    Graze
    Last Gift
    Best Place
    Y Si Fuera Ella
    Four Seasons
    The Shinee World (Doo-Bop)

    Talk To You
    Juliette
    Hit Me
    Señorita
    Please, Don't Go
    Romeo + Juliette

    Year of Us
    Ring Ding Dong
    JoJo
    Get Down
    Shinee Girl
    The Name I Loved

    Lucifer
    Hello
    One
    Get it
    UP&DOWN
    Electric Heart
    A-Yo
    Obsession
    Quasimodo
    Shout Out
    WOWOWOW
    Your Name
    Life
    Ready Or Not
    Love Pain
    Love Still Goes On

    Sherlock (Clue + Note)
    Clue
    Note
    Alarm Clock
    The Reason
    Stranger
    Honesty

    Spoiler
    Dream Girl
    Hitchhiking
    Punch Drunk Love
    Girls Girls Girls
    Aside
    Beautiful
    Dynamite
    Runaway
    Selene 6.23
     
    vague and eccentricsimply like this.
  5. I'm half way through, but I'm not promising any commentary, sorry.
     
  6. Same but I’m definitely voting!
     
  7. Yes! My exams are finally over, so I can hopefully dive into their discography.
     
  8. I’m doing this. I promise.
     
  9. Why is the first mini album SLAYING me?
     
  10. She's in.
    [​IMG]

    The averages:
    Replay - 7.250 (10x1; 5x1)
    The Shinee World / Amigo - 7.666 (10x1; 5x1)
    Romeo - 7.416 (9x2; 5x2)
    2009, Year of Us - 6.666 dddd (9x1; 4x1)
    Lucifer / Hello - 7.344 (10x2; 4x1)
    Sherlock - 8.143 (10x2; 6x1)
    Dream Girl - 7.450 (10x1; 5x2)

    Some of those averages, ddd. And one of those 10s is an 11, obviously.
     
  11. I HAVE YET TO EVEN START THIS FD;AIEWRPUWQRQEWR

    [​IMG]
     
    vague, Slice of Life, evilsin and 2 others like this.
  12. Same, but I thought it was due tomorrow.
     
    vague, Slice of Life, evilsin and 2 others like this.
  13. Y'all still have a week! And probably a few more days because I'm out of the city for my nephew's birthday on the 5th.
     
  14. [​IMG]

    She's voted.

    Replay - 7.37
    The Shinee World - 6.25
    Romeo - 6.41
    2009, Year of Us - 9.91 (dd I didn't realize how aggressively I stanned this of all things until now)
    Lucifer/Hello - 7.53
    Sherlock - 8.35
    Dream Girl - The Misconceptions of You - 8.15

    I always thought of myself as a bit of a ballad hater but all my 11's in the past 3 rates I've done have been ballads and it's giving me a bit of an existential crisis.
     
    vague, Serg., send photo and 4 others like this.
  15. I finished putting your scores in the spreadsheet and................... We really need to address this sub-forum's hatred of ballads.

    [​IMG]

    My averages, in case you're curious:

    Replay - 7,75
    The Shinee World - 7,41
    Romeo - 8,75
    200, Year of Us - 7,66
    Lucifer - 7,10
    Sherlock - 8,64
    Misconceptions of You - 9,05


    ALSO, do you guys need a extension? I have no problem give you guys one, so let me know!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
     
    Deja-Boo, Vixen, vague and 7 others like this.
  16. [​IMG]

    Sorry for being a flop xxxxx
     
    Deja-Boo, Vixen, vague and 6 others like this.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.