The Veronicas Discography Rate - COMPLETE!

[DJHazey]

Untouched is probably about my #5 or #6 song in their discography, after listening to all their songs now. This is despite having listening to it the most, even more than 4Ever.

When it comes down to it, I've probably heard them both over a hundred times but I'd rather listen to 4Ever on repeat today.

 

[Robsolete]

Even though my 11 didn't win, I'm not at all mad. What an amazing top 2.

And thanks @Aidan for getting this started and to @Mina for finishing this. You did a great job!

 

[Mina]

YAY! Justice for 4ever!

Thanks for taking over the rate @Mina you star xx

Indeed! Thank you!

I thought Untouched was a sure thing it was robbed. Oh well.

Thanks for the rate, i can't wait for the final scores and statistics eventually.

I know, I'm quite curious as to how close the final two really were. From the sampling of scores/commentary I got, "Untouched" seemed to get several more lower scores than "4Ever," but that's only speculation from an incomplete data set.

Even though you've been teasing the lyrics throughout when I first read "we could make the night last.." I somehow thought it was actually going to lead to 4Ever #2. Congratulations on your first 11 win @Mina which ended up being karma for taking over the rate and doing things so flawlessy. If you ever decide to run your own rate from scratch I would definitely be there to participate fully.

Thank you! I still can't believe my 11 won a rate...it'll probably never happen again (unless y'all miraculously choose the right song in @Remorque 's ABBA rate).

Totally worthy winner, thanks for taking over @Mina you were an amazing host!

Thank you!

Untouched is probably about my #5 or #6 song in their discography, after listening to all their songs now. This is despite having listening to it the most, even more than 4Ever.

When it comes down to it, I've probably heard them both over a hundred times but I'd rather listen to 4Ever on repeat today.

I agree - they're both stellar pop songs, but I definitely favor 4Ever (I'm glad I can finally publicly say that!).

Even though my 11 didn't win, I'm not at all mad. What an amazing top 2.

And thanks @Aidan for getting this started and to @Mina for finishing this. You did a great job!

Thank you - and glad there are no hard feelings!

 

[phily693]

Although my 11 didn't win, well done on having such good taste everyone because that was a great Top 5.

Thanks @Aidan for starting the rate and @Mina for stepping in to finish it.

 

[Mina]

Although my 11 didn't win, well done on having such good taste everyone because that was a great Top 5.

Thanks @Aidan for starting the rate and @Mina for stepping in to finish it.

You're welcome! And indeed, it was a terrific top 5, so thank you to everyone for not fucking that up.

 

[Mina]

And just for fun, here's my personal Veronicas top 10, in order, including some songs we didn't rate:

1. 4Ever
2. Lolita
3. Everything
4. More Like Me
5. Cruel
6. Untouched
7. All I Have
8. This Is How It Feels
9. Stutter
10. Hollywood

 

[Old Untouchable Ace]

How does everyone rate the new song Only High? Where would it have placed?

 

[Deleted member 3416]

How does everyone rate the new song Only High? Where would it have placed?

Not very exciting. Would be better if it was an album track basically.

 

[Mina]

How does everyone rate the new song Only High? Where would it have placed?

I personally would've rated it a 4 or 5...it's pretty boring to me after a few listens. It's one of their rare single choices that has me puzzled.

 

[VivaForever]

Shocked by Untouched not winning this. Nevertheless the entire slate of results is unspeakably messy. As inevitably happens when we have voters with very different tastes in the act being rated.

At any rate, you've been a great host, @Mina, especially under the circumstances but just in general as well. xoxo

 

[Mina]

Shocked by Untouched not winning this. Nevertheless the entire slate of results is unspeakably messy. As inevitably happens when we have voters with very different tastes in the act being rated.

At any rate, you've been a great host, @Mina, especially under the circumstances but just in general as well. xoxo

Thank you! xoxo

 

[DJHazey]

Damn I've lost track of all the moments I've had with songs I was just discovering when I voted in this. So many songs are now unquestioned 10s and my list of 11-contenders is insanely long now.

 

[Mina]

and my list of 11-contenders is insanely long now.

I still think we made the correct choice.

 

[DJHazey]

I still think we made the correct choice.

Sure and maybe it's the "newness" of my love for the other songs speaking but I'm looking forward to that rate you're doing that has their album in it, even more now.

 

[Mina]

Sure and maybe it's the "newness" of my love for the other songs speaking but I'm looking forward to that rate you're doing that has their album in it, even more now.

Glad to hear it!

Although I can tell you my 11 is already decided, and it won't be a Veronicas song.

 

[Old Untouchable Ace]

Any chance we can get those final scores for each song?

 

[Mina]

Any chance we can get those final scores for each song?

@Aidan - if you still have this info and would be willing to share, it'd be much appreciated!