The Winners Rate #2: AND THE WINNER IS.... Me, Because I'm Done

ohnostalgia

Staff member
She/her
FADE IN:

INT. RESTAURANT - MORNING (PRESENT DAY)


NUvSoc6.jpg


OHNOSTALGIA is a waitress in a coffee shop. She is in her late-twenties, but too old to be doing this. She is very pretty and meticulously groomed, even at the end of her shift. She is slamming dirty coffee cups from the counter into a bus tray underneath the counter. It is making a lot of RACKET which she is oblivious to. There is POP MUZAK in the b.g., which she hums along with.




INT. SEND PHOTO'S KITCHEN - MORNING

fUQG2rb.jpg


SEND PHOTO is a househusband. It's morning and he is slamming coffee cups from the breakfast table into the kitchen sink, which is full of dirty breakfast dishes and some stuff left from last night's dinner which had to "soak." He is still in his crop top pajamas. The TV is ON in the b.g. From the kitchen, we can see an incomplete gif project going on in the dining room, an obvious "do-it-yourself" attempt by @send photo.




INT. RESTAURANT - MORNING

IvaEZPh.jpg


@ohnostalgia goes to the phone and dials a number.




INT. SEND PHOTO'S KITCHEN - MORNING

y98C4ig.jpg


Phone RINGS. @send photo goes over to answer it.


SEND PHOTO
(hollering)
I got it! Hello.




INT. RESTAURANT - MORNING

Pg9AOx2.jpg


OHNOSTALGIA
I hope you're ready, 'cause I'm opening the thread. You ready to take our act on the road?




INT. SEND PHOTO'S KITCHEN - MORNING


cUdlg0c.jpg


SEND PHOTO
Well, wait a second now. I still have to ask Slicey if I can go.




INT. RESTAURANT - MORNING

WQWYx61.jpg


OHNOSTALGIA
(dramatically sighs)
You mean you haven't asked him yet? For Jepsus's sake, @send photo, is he your husband or your father? It's just two days. Beysus, don't go all "twenty-five" year old on me. Just tell Slicey you're goin' with me. Tell him I'm havin' a nervous breakdown.




INT. SEND PHOTO'S KITCHEN - MORNING

Ixm49Ch.jpg


SEND PHOTO
Slicey already thinks you're out of your mind, @ohnostalgia, that don't carry much weight with her. Are you at work?


OHNOSTALGIA (V.O.)
No, I'm calling from Nelly Furtado's Surrey concert.


SEND PHOTO
I'll call you right back.




0wEMBUh.jpg


@send photo goes through the living room to the bottom of the stairs and leans on the banister.


SEND PHOTO
Slicey! Honey, you'd better hurry up.




YqcFcTb.jpg


SLICE OF LIFE comes trotting down the stairs. Polyester was made for ha. She's positively dripping in imported Korean costume jewellery; Slicey manages a Korean Karaoke bar.


SLICE OF LIFE
Damnit, @send photo, don't holler like that! Haven't I told you I can't stand it when you holler in the morning.


SEND PHOTO
I'm sorry, sugarbutt, I just don't want you to be late.




5EV7T5p.jpg


Slice of Life exudes overconfidence from his 8 month residency as the K-Pop Monthly Charts host. He scrolls through his phone searching for the perfect DAY6 track to start his day.


SEND PHOTO
Hon.


SLICE OF LIFE
What.


SEND PHOTO
(he decides not to tell Slicey)
Have a good day at work today.


SLICE OF LIFE
Uh-huh.


SEND PHOTO
Hon?


SLICE OF LIFE
What?!


SEND PHOTO
You want anything special for dinner?


SLICE OF LIFE
No @send photo, I don't give a vegan shit what we have for dinner. I may not even make it home for dinner. You know how Mondays are.


SEND PHOTO
Funny how so many people want to sing K-Pop on a Monday night. You'd almost think they'd want to forget about it until the weekend.


SLICE OF LIFE
Well then, it's a good thing you're not manager and I am.


SEND PHOTO
'Bye honey. I won't wait up.


SLICE OF LIFE
See ya.




60jcnri.jpg


Slice of Life leaves. We see her Corvette parked out front. As she closes the front door, @send photo leans against it.


SEND PHOTO
Slicey's gonna shit ha-self.


He goes back into the kitchen and dials the phone.




INT. RESTAURANT - MORNING

RmZbMhp.jpg


The phone on the wall RINGS. ISLAND, a busboy, answers.


ISLAND
Good morning. Why yes she is. Is this @send photo? Oh, @send photo, when you going to run away with me?




acWKCk1.jpg


@ohnostalgia comes over and takes the phone out of his hand.


OHNOSTALGIA
(to Island)
Not today, sweetie. He's running away with me.


(into phone)

Hi. What did Slicey say?


SEND PHOTO (V.O).

When are you going to pick me up?


OHNOSTALGIA
You're kidding! Alright! I'll be there around two or three.


SEND PHOTO (V.O).
What kind of stuff do I bring?


OHNOSTALGIA
I don't know. Photoshop stuff, I guess. We need graphics. I'm just going to bring everything.


SEND PHOTO (V.O).
Okay. I will, too.


OHNOSTALGIA
And steal Slicey's K-Pop music.


SEND PHOTO (V.O).
You don't know K-Pop, @ohnostalgia.


OHNOSTALGIA
Slicey does, how hard can it be? I'll see you later. Be ready.







VuUTbE7.gif


THE WINNER'S RATE PART 2

Hello and welcome to The Winners Rate Part 2!!! What is a Winners Rate, you ask? Basically it's PopJustice Rates: All Stars Edition, but with probably less likes for you than live posting Celebrity Big Brother. Because we don't have enough drama or meltdowns on this forum, @Sprockrooster decided we should rate all the winners against each other to win the coveted prize of the Ultimate Fave. Who will join Emma Bunton's Maybe in the ultimate echelon of PopJustice fame??? I can't wait to find out.


When I was asked to host the reprise of The Winners Rate a month ago, my first instinct was "oh hell no." I've had many - let's say discussions - about the White Nonsense that went down in the Original Recipe edition. If you're looking for a host who's going to excuse what happened and say the criticisms were overblown, you've got the wrong woman. Musical tastes are not made in a vacuum- all of the intersections that influence the rest of society (racism, sexism, homophobia, transphobia, etc), also make it into the musical sphere. You may not want to interrogate your musical tastes from these perspectives, nor can I force you to, but @send photo and I will delete any -ist commentary. Because quite frankly members of our community who belong to these groups do not need to constantly read that shit and explain why it's harmful over and over again. We want this to be a fun positive experience for everybody, and I am determined to do my best to make that happen.


So this is where your participation is vital. I post on this forum every day; I know the wide array of music we all love. PopJustice deserves a rate that reflects all of our tastes- whether that's the purest pop of Carly Rae, the R&B of Beyoncé, the indie tones of Grimes, the hip hop of Nicki Minaj, the oldies but goodies like Bananarama, the K-Pop of 2NEI, the country of Maren Morris, or even the pop-rock of The Killers. The only way this can happen is if all of you vote. Spread the word, tell your friends to vote, tell your enemies to vote, tell random people you've never talked to before to vote! You know @send photo and I will put on a messy and unnecessarily extra show. And if you don't give us attention we will continue our reign of messiness into other threads. So really, if you think about it, you're doing the forum a huge public service.




V O T E



tumblr_inline_ojvks7lWDu1sm0bjj_540.gif
 
Last edited:
S

send photo

baXsIx7.png


  1. No trolling. Troll votes will swiftly be tossed.
  2. Score between 0 and 10. Decimals allowed but don't get crazy.
  3. One song gets your 11. No 10.5's. Use your 11 wisely.
  4. Be respectful. The hosts put a lot of work into their rates even if you don't care for the song that they're representing.
  5. PM scores to either host. Whomever you're most comfortable with. *tumble weed rolls through my PMs* (You could also add us both to the conversation!)
VOTES DUE JULY 9TH @ 11:59PM PST

ZdTvmX1.png


We'll be doing summaries over the course of the voting period, as we post them I'll link them by the song marked (S). @Alouder98 was kind enough to make a Spotify Playlist, thanks sis! It has a few omissions but here's a full list with Youtube links anyway:
01. The Chain // Fleetwood Mac (S)
02. You Oughta Know // Alanis Morissette (S)
03. Bad Girls // M.I.A. (S)
04. Run Away With Me // Carly Rae Jepsen (S)
05. Damaged // Danity Kane (S)
06. Trick Me // Kelis (S)
07. Motorway // Little Boots (S)
08. All I Wanna Do // Dannii Minogue (S)
09. The One // Kylie Minogue (S)
10. Jóga // Björk (S)
11. Skyscraper // Demi Lovato (S)
12. Move // Little Mix (S)
13. Come Clean // Hilary Duff (S)
14. From This Moment On // Shania Twain (S)
15. King // Years & Years (S)
16. White Diamond (Live) // Kylie Minogue (S)
17. Domino // Jessie J (S)
18. Escapade // Janet Jackson (S)
19. Crazy In Love // Beyoncé (S)
20. Romantic World // Dana Dawson (S)
21. Toes // LIGHTS (S)
22. Kiss You // One Direction (S)
23. I Want It That Way // Backstreet Boys
24. Everybody // Backstreet Boys
25. Countdown // Beyoncé (S)
26. Bleeding Love // Leona Lewis (S)
27. Hot Summer // Monrose (S)
28. Into You // Ariana Grande (S)
29. Summer Son // Texas (S)
30. All The Times I Cried // Sharleen Spiteri (S)
31. Black Coffee // All Saints (S)
32. Glorybox // Portishead (S)
33. What Is Love // Howard Jones (S)
34. Cruel Summer // Bananarama (S)
35. Cosmic Love // Florence + The Machines (S)
36. Crank It Up // Ashley Tisdale (S)
37. The Sign // Ace Of Base (S)
38. Shower Scene // Saint Etienne (S)
39. Mr. Saxobeat // Alexandra Stan (S)
40. Formation // Beyoncé
41. When Doves Cry // Prince (S)
(these are all shit quality obscure links I'm sorry blame Prince)
42. Nothing Compares 2 U // Sinéad O'Connor (S)
43. Get Right // Jennifer Lopez (S)
44. Sissy That Walk // RuPaul (S)
45. Paparazzi // Lady Gaga (S)
46. Upside Down // A*Teens (S)
47. Boy Is A Bottom // DWV (S)
48. My Blood // Ellie Goulding (S)
49. Back In Your Head // Tegan and Sara (S)
50. Monster // Basically Nicki Minaj (S)
51. 10.000 Luchtballonnen // K3 (S)
52. Work // Rihanna
53. Mr. Brightside // The Killers (S)
54. Last Friday Night (T.G.I.F.) // Katy Perry
55. Delirious // Susanne Sandfor (S)
56. Flesh Without Blood // Grimes
57. Lonely Town // Brandon Flowers (S)
58. Sirens // Cher Lloyd (S)
59. Ugly Heart // G.R.L. (S)
60. Whenever, Wherever // Shakira (S)
61. Genie // SNSD (S)
62. I Love You // 2NE1 (S)
63. Closer // Oh! My Girl (S)
64. FM // Crayon Pop (S)
65. Someone Like U // Dal*Shabet (S)
66. Love Is A Sudden // MIXX (S)
67. Ace Reject // Sugababes
68. Starboy // The Weeknd (S)
69. I Could Use A Love Song // Maren Morris
70. Burning House // Cam
71. Powerless (Say What You Want) // Nelly Furtado (S)
72. Vienna // Ultravox (S)
73. Across The Sky // Madonna (S)

*If any links are broken please let me know!


01. The Chain // Fleetwood Mac -
02. You Oughta Know // Alanis Morissette -
03. Bad Girls // M.I.A. -
04. Run Away With Me // Carly Rae Jepsen -
05. Damaged // Danity Kane -
06. Trick Me // Kelis -
07. Motorway // Little Boots -
08. All I Wanna Do // Dannii Minogue -
09. The One // Kylie Minogue -
10. Jóga // Björk -
11. Skyscraper // Demi Lovato -
12. Move // Little Mix -
13. Come Clean // Hilary Duff -
14. From This Moment On // Shania Twain -
15. King // Years & Years -
16. White Diamond (Live) // Kylie Minogue -
17. Domino // Jessie J -
18. Escapade // Janet Jackson -
19. Crazy In Love // Beyoncé -
20. Romantic World // Dana Dawson -
21. Toes // LIGHTS -
22. Kiss You // One Direction -
23. I Want It That Way // Backstreet Boys -
24. Everybody // Backstreet Boys -
25. Countdown // Beyoncé -
26. Bleeding Love // Leona Lewis -
27. Hot Summer // Monrose -
28. Into You // Ariana Grande -
29. Summer Son // Texas -
30. All The Times I Cried // Sharleen Spiteri -
31. Black Coffee // All Saints -
32. Glorybox // Portishead -
33. What Is Love // Howard Jones -
34. Cruel Summer // Bananarama -
35. Cosmic Love // Florence + The Machines -
36. Crank It Up // Ashley Tisdale -
37. The Sign // Ace Of Base -
38. Shower Scene // Saint Etienne -
39. Mr. Saxobeat // Alexandra Stan -
40. Formation // Beyoncé -
41. When Doves Cry // Prince -
42. Nothing Compares 2 U // Sinéad O'Connor -
43. Get Right // Jennifer Lopez -
44. Sissy That Walk // RuPaul -
45. Paparazzi // Lady Gaga -
46. Upside Down // A*Teens -
47. Boy Is A Bottom // DWV -
48. My Blood // Ellie Goulding -
49. Back In Your Head // Tegan and Sara -
50. Monster // Basically Nicki Minaj -
51. 10.000 Luchtballonnen // K3 -
52. Work // Rihanna -
53. Mr. Brightside // The Killers -
54. Last Friday Night (T.G.I.F.) // Katy Perry -
55. Delirious // Susanne Sandfor -
56. Flesh Without Blood // Grimes -
57. Lonely Town // Brandon Flowers -
58. Sirens // Cher Lloyd -
59. Ugly Heart // G.R.L. -
60. Whenever, Wherever // Shakira -
61. Genie // SNSD -
62. I Love You // 2NE1 -
63. Closer // Oh! My Girl -
64. FM // Crayon Pop -
65. Someone Like U // Dal*Shabet -
66. Love Is A Sudden // MIXX -
67. Ace Reject // Sugababes -
68. Starboy // The Weeknd -
69. I Could Use A Love Song // Maren Morris -
70. Burning House // Cam -
71. Powerless (Say What You Want) // Nelly Furtado -
72. Vienna // Ultravox -
73. Across The Sky // Madonna -

A big thanks to @Sprockrooster for organizing the list for Part 2 and hosting the first edition!​
 
Last edited by a moderator:

ohnostalgia

Staff member
She/her
VOTERS


INTRO SONG POSTS
http://forum.popjustice.com/threads...n-vote-by-july-9th.63961/page-22#post-5465669
10.000 Luchtballonnen | K3
Ace Reject | Sugababes
Across The Sky | Madonna
All I Wanna Do | Danni Minogue
All The Times I Cried | Sharleen Spiteri
Back In Your Head | Tegan & Sara
Bad Girls | M.I.A.
Black Coffee | All Saints
Bleeding Love | Leona Lewis
Boy is a Bottom | DWV
Burning House | Cam
Closer | Oh My Girl
Come Clean | Hilary Duff
Cosmic Love | Florence + The Machine
Countdown | Beyoncé
Crank It Up | Ashley Tisdale
Crazy in Love (feat. Jay-Z) | Beyoncé
Cruel Summer | Bananarama
Damaged | Danity Kane
Delirious | Susanne Sundfør
Domino | Jessie J
Escapade | Janet Jackson
Everybody (Backstreet's Back) | Backstreet Boys
Flesh Without Blood | Grimes
FM | Crayon Pop
Formation | Beyoncé
From This Moment On | Shania Twain
Genie | SNSD
Get Right | Jennifer Lopez
Glory Box | Portishead
Hot Summer | Monrose
I Could Use A Love Song | Maren Morris
I Love You | 2NE1
I Want It That Way | Backstreet Boys
Into You | Ariana Grande
Jóga | Björk
King | Years & Years
Kiss You | One Direction
Last Friday Night | Katy Perry
Lonely Town | Brandon Flowers
Love is a Sudden | Mixx
Monster | Nicki Minaj and some other people
Motorway | Little Boots
Move | Little Mix
Mr. Brightside | The Killers
Mr. Saxobeat | Alexandra Stan
My Blood | Ellie Goulding
Nothing Compares 2 U | Sinéad O'Connor
Paparazzi | Lady Gaga
Powerless (Say What You Want) | Nelly Furtado
Romantic World | Dana Dawson
Run Away With Me | Carly Rae Jepsen
Shower Scene | St. Etienne
Sirens | Cher Lloyd
Sissy That Walk | Rupaul
Skyscraper | Demi Lovato
Someone Like U | Dal*Shabet
Starboy | The Weeknd
Summer Son | Texas
The Chain | Fleetwood Mac
The One | Kylie Minogue
The Sign | Ace of Base
Toes | Lights
Trick Me | Kelis
Ugly Heart | G.R.L.
Upside Down | A*Teens
Vienna | Ultravox
What Is Love | Howard Jones
When Doves Cry | Prince
Whenever, Wherever | Shakira
White Diamond (Live) | Kylie Minogue
Work (feat. Drake) | Rihanna
You Oughta Know | Alanis Morissette

ELIMINATIONS

72. Boy is a Bottom | DWV
71. 10.000 Luchtballonnen | K3
70. Skyscraper | Demi Lovato
69. All The Times I Cried | Sharleen Spiteri
68. What is Love | Howard Jones
67. Hot Summer | Monrose
66. Domino | Jessie J
65. Vienna | Ultravoxx
64. Crank It Up | Ashley Tisdale
63. Love is a Sudden | MIXX
61. All I Wanna Do | Dannii Minogue
61. Across The Sky (feat. Justin Timberlake) | Madonna
60. White Diamond (Live) | Kylie Minogue
59. Upside Down | A*Teens
58. Last Friday Night (T.G.I.F.) | Katy Perry
57. Kiss You | One Direction
56. Burning House | Cam
55. Romantic World | Dana Dawson
54. Toes | Lights
53. Mr. Saxobeat | Alexandra Stan
52. FM | Crayon Pop
51. Damaged | Danity Kane
50. Come Clean | Hilary Duff
49. Monster | Nicki Minaj + Others
48. Summer Son | Texas
46. Get Right | Jennifer Lopez
46. Motorway | Little Boots
45. Cruel Summer | Bananarama
44. Glory Box | Portishead
43. Genie | Girl's Generation
42. Back In Your Head | Tegan & Sara
41. Trick Me | Kelis
39. Shower Scene | Saint Etienne
39. Someone Like U | Dal*Shabet
38. The Sign | Ace of Base
37. Work (feat. Drake) | Rihanna
36. From This Moment On | Shania Twain
35. Everybody (Backstreet's Back) | Backstreet Boys
34. I Could Use A Love Song | Maren Morris
33. Sirens | Cher Lloyd
32. Starboy (feat. Daft Punk) | The Weeknd
31. Ugly Heart | G.R.L.
30. My Blood | Ellie Goulding
29. Sissy That Walk | RuPaul
27. The Chain | Fleetwood Mac
27. Black Coffee | All Saints
26. Lonely Town | Brandon Flowers
25. Move | Little Mix
23. Closer | Oh My Girl
23. Bad Girls | M.I.A.
22. Cosmic Love | Florence + The Machine
21. I Love You | 2NE1
20. I Want It That Way | Backstreet Boys
19. Escapade | Janet Jackson
18. Jóga | Björk
17. When Doves Cry | Prince
16. Nothing Compares 2 U | Sinéad O'Connor
15. You Oughta Know | Alanis Morissette
13. Delirious | Susanne Sundfør
13. Mr. Brightside | The Killers
12. King | Years & Years
11. The One | Kylie Minogue
10. Ace Reject | Sugababes
9. Bleeding Love | Leona Lewis
8. Countdown | Beyoncé
7. Whenever, Wherever | Shakira
6. Paparazzi | Lady Gaga
5. Formation | Beyoncé
4. Flesh Without Blood | Grimes
3. Crazy in Love (feat. Jay-Z) | Beyoncé
2. Into You | Ariana Grande
1. Run Away With Me | Carly Rae Jepsen

DQ. Powerless (Say What You Want) | Nelly Furtado
 
Last edited:
For the last winner's rate I gave out a load of 10s, but I think I'm not gonna be so generous this time because there are a few ... popular 10s that I don't want to end up winning. It's still an amazing bunch of songs, though.

That said, I'm still bitter about everything that happened in the boy band rate, results-wise.
 
S

send photo

Three times a day until we're out of songs, @ohnostalgia and I will be posting summaries of all the entries to help highlight them for your voting process. Let's start out strong, shall we?

INTO YOU | ARIANA GRANDE
ARIANA GRANDE DISCOGRAPHY RATE // BIG POP GIRLS 2016 VS RATE
by: @Laura Vanderbooben // @RJF

JuTtkJP.png


Winning Post // Winning Post
RUNNER UP: Love Me Harder // Kiss It Better
2ND RUNNER UP: Touch It // Formation

This behemoth of a song has already won two rates. Can it win a third? It's very possible. Hands down the quintessential bop of 2016. If you want to have a good time you put Into You on. The video hardly serves it justice but at least she's serving looks.

Her #1 fan Laura Vanderbooben says there was no competition, "Our #1 from the moment voting opened, Into You accumulated 87 tens and elevens out of 101 voters. You do the math."

Avert your eyes stalgy because here's a recap of RJF's Formation-gate, "I mean... we can agonise over the scores we gave things forever, but if it makes y'all feel better, this wasn't even close in the end. "Into You" had a twenty point lead over "Kiss It Better" and has, quite frankly, scored an insanely high average with 139 voters. I genuinely thought there was a chance of it clearing an average of 10.00 at one point, and while it didn't quite manage that, it certainly came close. Dangerously, close, one might say. But yes, your winner by a long shot, and a deeply worthy one too."

 
Top