The Winners' Rate: Part 5 - Winner Crowned & Statistics!

Winners' Winners' Rate Poll - Choose Your Favourite

  • Genie In A Bottle

    Votes: 8 14.3%
  • Run Away With Me

    Votes: 13 23.2%
  • Frozen

    Votes: 25 44.6%
  • Physical

    Votes: 10 17.9%

  • Total voters
    56
It’s been a while…


I know I shouldn’t have kept you waiting…


But I’m here now…
winneratetitle.jpg
Hello and welcome to the 5th edition of The Winners’ Rate! It is an honour to be your host for what promises to be a diverse and taste filled rate! I fully anticipate there to be drama and surprises along the way…

We have a exquisite collection of 76 songs competing, coming from rates in the Charts, rates, etc sub-forum as well as the Eurovision and K-pop sub-forums battling it out to join the current ‘Elite Four’ which are:

Genie In A Bottle
Run Away With Me
Frozen

And our most recent winner… Physical

Represented this time we have forum favourites such as Britney Spears and Lady Gaga to potential underdogs with the likes of Mitski and Erika Vikman.

Which song will the PJ forum crown our fifth winner of winners? That decision is up to you!

'How does it work?' I hear you ask…

Well, we are using the same format that has been used in the previous Winners’ Rate. If you didn’t join the last one and want to catch up, you can find it here.

For further information, please see below in the ‘Rules’ post for all the information you need!

The voting deadline will be:

Monday 27th February 2023

Watch2gether sessions:

Saturday 11th February - 7PM GMT
Saturday 18th February - 7PM GMT


giphy.gif
 
Last edited:
songs.jpg


After School - Flashback // After School discography = @vague
Allie X - Girl Of The Year // Allie X = @SophiaSophia
Bat For Lashes - Daniel // 00s Indie Pop Rate = @soratami
The Beatles - Eleanor Rigby // The Beatles = @Ironheade & @ohnostalgia & @WowWowWowWow
BESS - Ram pam pam // Eurovizh Alt-Song Contest 2022 = @WowWowWowWow
Billie Eilish - Happier Than Ever // Big Pop Girls 2021 = @aux
BoA - Valenti // BoA discography, part 1 = @Crisp X
Britney Spears - Gimme More // Britney Spears = @Holly Something
Chanel - SloMo // Popjustice 12 Points Eurovision 2022 = @stevo_1988
Charli XCX - Good Ones // 2021 PJ Chart Rate = @BubblegumBoy
Charli XCX - Track 10 // Charli XCX = @Petty Mayonnaise & @2014
Christina Aguilera - Fighter // Christina Aguilera discography = @BEST FICTION
Clara Luciana - La Grenade // La Musique Française Moderne: Les Chanteurs/Compositeurs = @berserkboi
COY - Promises // PJSC Winners Rate = @imaduck & @soratami
Crystal Kay - Kirakuni // The J-R&B Divas Rate! = @RUNAWAY & @evilsin
Dollar - Hand Held In Black & White // Dollar Singles Rate 1978-1988 = @simes1970
DOUBLE - Shake // The J-R&B Divas Rate! = @RUNAWAY
Duran Duran - Ordinary World // Duran Duran UK Singles Rate = @simes1970
Elena Tsagrinou - El Diablo // Popjustice 12 Points Eurovision 2021 = @stevo_1988
ENHYPEN - Drunk Dazed // K-Pop Boys 2021 = @Glitterizer
Erika Vikman - Syntisten pöytä // PJ Song Contests Winners Rumble 2020 = @Doodvid
Eyedi - Caffeine // City Pop = @thommyh & @codecat
Five Star - The Slightest Touch (Shep Pettibone 7" Mix) // Five Star 1983-1991 = @simes1970
Foxes - Body Talk // UK Ladies Not #1s of 2010s = @saviodxl
Foxes - Sister Ray // Foxes Discography Rate = @2014
Frida - I Know There's Something Going On // 80s/'90s Lost Classics Rate = @berserkboi & @filippa
f(x) - 4 Walls // f(x) discography = @eccentricsimply
Girls Aloud - Sexy! No No No... // Girls Aloud = @Physical
Girls Aloud - Something Kinda Ooooh // PJ Twenty Quid Rate: Part One = @Lost In Japan.
Girls Aloud - Something New // UK Ladies Not #1s of 2010s = @saviodxl
Haim - Now I'm In It // Haim discography = @2014
iamamiwhoami - y // The iamamiwhoami Rate = @eatyourself & @Glitterizer
Infernal - From Paris to Berlin // Rate Danes = @WowWowWowWow
IZ*ONE - La Vie En Rose // IZ*ONE Discography = @eatyourself
Jana Burčeska - Dance Alone // Popjustice Again 2021 = @WowWowWowWow
Janelle Monae - Cold War // The Janelle Monae Rate = @BubblegumBoy
Jazmine Sullivan - Lost One // Jazmine Sullivan discography = @RainOnFire
Jenny Berggren - Let Your Heart Be Mine // PopJustice Second Chances: Eurovision Edition = @WowWowWowWow
Julie Bergan - One Touch // PJSC Veto - Part 2 = @WoW73
Katy Perry - Never Really Over // Katy Perry discography = @swim
Kylie Minogue - Tightrope // Kylie Minogue B-Sides and Rarities = @P'NutButter
Lady Gaga - Marry the Night // BPG Classique 2011 = @RJF & @Laura Vanderbooben
Ladyhawke - Magic // A Kiwi Versus Rate = @Phonetics Girl
Liberty X - Just A Little // Mixed Pop Groups & Duos = @Doodvid & @Ezz
Linkin Park - Breaking The Habit // The Nu Metal Rate = @DJHazey
Little Mix - Sweet Melody // Little Mix Discography Rate = @RainOnFire
LOVELYZ - Destiny // LOVELYZ Discography rate = @Attis
Madness - It Must Be Love // Madness UK Singles Rate = @simes1970
Miley Cyrus - Midnight Sky // Miley Cyrus discography, part 2 = @Music Is Death
Miss A - Hush // Miss A = @Rem
Mitski - Your Best American Girl // Mitski = @fatyoshi
M.O. - Who Do You Think Of? // M.O. discography = @boombazookajoe
Muna - Number One Fan // Quirky Pop Girls: Sophomore (B) = @soratami
Orchestral Manoeuvres in the Dark - Souvenir // OMD UK Singles Rate = @simes1970
Paloma Faith - Only Love Can Hurt Like This // The Paloma Faith Rate = @BubblegumBoy
Parade of Planets - Où est ton amour? // PJSC Winners Rumble 2021 = @Doodvid & @berserkboi
Paradis - Toi Et Moi // La Musique Française Moderne: Les Hommes = @berserkboi
Park Ji Yoon - Coming of Age Ceremony // First Gen Female Soloists = @Ana Raquel
Pixie Lott - Boys and Girls // Pixie Lott discography = @saviodxl
Precious - Rewind // Flop Girlbands = @Remorque
Rammstein - Du Hast // The Nu Metal Rate = @DJHazey
The Saturdays - All Fired Up // The Saturdays 2020 Re-rate = @DJHazey
S Club 7 - Don't Stop Moving // S Club 7 = @j267
Shakespeare Sisters - Hello (Turn Your Radio On) // The Shakespeare Sisters Rate = @VivaForever
Shura - Religion (You Can Lay Your Hands On Me) // 20BiTeen = @Trouble in Paradise & @Cutlery
Sugababes - Easy // Song Title Battle = @jtm
T-ARA - Sugar Free // T-ARA = @GeiPanda
Tomorrow x Together - Ghosting // K-Pop Boys 2020 = @Glitterizer
TWICE - I Can't Stop Me // K-Pop Song of the Year 2020 = @Slice of Life
TWICE - Fancy // TWICE = @aux
TWICE - Likey // 3rd Gen Girls: The Debut = @Serg.
Whitney Houston - I Wanna Dance With Somebody (Who Loves Me) // Whitney Houston singles = @londonrain
WJSN - Unnatural // KSOTY 2021 = @Slice of Life
WJSN - Save Me, Save You // WJSN Discography rate = @junglefish
The xx - On Hold // The xx = @klow
Yeah Yeah Yeahs - Heads Will Roll // 00s Indie Rock Rate = @soratami

After School - Flashback
Allie X - Girl Of The Year
Bat For Lashes - Daniel
The Beatles - Eleanor Rigby
BESS - Ram pam pam
Billie Eilish - Happier Than Ever
BoA - Valenti
Britney Spears - Gimme More
Chanel - SloMo
Charli XCX - Good Ones
Charli XCX - Track 10
Christina Aguilera - Fighter
Clara Luciana - La Grenade
COY - Promises
Crystal Kay - Kirakuni
Dollar - Hand Held In Black & White
DOUBLE - Shake
Duran Duran - Ordinary World
Elena Tsagrinou - El Diablo
ENHYPEN - Drunk Dazed
Erika Vikman - Syntisten pöytä
Eyedi - Caffeine
Five Star - The Slightest Touch (Shep Pettibone 7" Mix)
Foxes - Body Talk
Foxes - Sister Ray
Frida - I Know There's Something Going On
f(x) - 4 Walls
Girls Aloud - Sexy! No No No...
Girls Aloud - Something Kinda Oooh!
Girls Aloud - Something New
Haim - Now I'm In It
iamamiwhoami - y
Infernal - From Paris to Berlin
IZ*ONE - La Vie En Rose
Jana Burčeska - Dance Alone
Janelle Monae - Cold War
Jazmine Sullivan - Lost One
Jenny Berggren - Let Your Heart Be Mine
Julie Bergan - One Touch
Katy Perry - Never Really Over
Kylie Minogue - Tightrope
Lady Gaga - Marry the Night
Ladyhawke - Magic
Liberty - Just A Little
Linkin Park - Breaking The Habit
Little Mix - Sweet Melody
LOVELYZ - Destiny
Madness - It Must Be Love
Miley Cyrus - Midnight Sky
Miss A - Hush
Mitski - Your Best American Girl
M.O. - Who Do You Think Of?
Muna - Number One Fan
Orchestral Manoeuvres in the Dark - Souvenir
Paloma Faith - Only Love Can Hurt Like This
Parade of Planets - Où est ton amour?
Paradis - Toi Et Moi
Park Ji Yoon - Coming of Age Ceremony
Pixie Lott - Boys and Girls
Precious - Rewind
Rammstein - Du Hast
The Saturdays - All Fired Up
S Club 7 - Don't Stop Moving
Shakespeare Sisters - Hello (Turn Your Radio On)
Shura - Religion (You Can Lay Your Hands On Me)
Sugababes - Easy
T-ARA - Sugar Free
Tomorrow x Together - Ghosting
TWICE - I Can't Stop Me
TWICE - Fancy
TWICE - Likey
Whitney Houston - I Wanna Dance With Somebody (Who Loves Me)
WJSN - Unnatural
WJSN - Save Me, Save You
Yeah Yeah Yeahs - Heads Will Roll
The xx - On Hold

Spotify Playlist:



(Missing: Jenny Berggren - Let Your Heart Be Mine)

YouTube Playlist:

Link - Courtesy of @Maki

(Missing: Crystal Kay - Kira Kuni)

And... Apple Music Playlist Courtesy of @Glitterizer
 
Last edited:
rules.jpg

  1. Send in your scores by Monday 27th February 2023
  2. If you don't understand the scoring system, copy and paste the example ballot into a text document and just replace “Artist - Song” in each case with the songs you are voting for.​
  3. Please follow the format in the example ballot. This will make my life a LOT easier when I enter your scores. If you don’t follow the format in the example ballot, I reserve the right to throw it out and ask you to resubmit it in the correct format.​
  4. When you send in your ballots, please also tell me which was your favourite of the songs you hadn’t heard before. This doesn’t count for additional points, and the song doesn’t need to be one you gave points to.​
12 points:
Artist - Song
Artist - Song
Artist - Song
Artist - Song

10 points:
Artist - Song
Artist - Song
Artist - Song
Artist - Song

8 points:
Artist - Song
Artist - Song
Artist - Song
Artist - Song

7 points:
Artist - Song
Artist - Song
Artist - Song
Artist - Song

6 points:
Artist - Song
Artist - Song
Artist - Song
Artist - Song

5 points:
Artist - Song
Artist - Song
Artist - Song
Artist - Song

4 points:
Artist - Song
Artist - Song
Artist - Song
Artist - Song

3 points:
Artist - Song
Artist - Song
Artist - Song
Artist - Song

2 points:
Artist - Song
Artist - Song
Artist - Song
Artist - Song

1 point:
Artist - Song
Artist - Song
Artist - Song
Artist - Song

Questions, answered...

Are we going through the whole "score from 0-10 except for your 11" thing?

Nope. We are going to draw our inspiration from the PJ song contests and use four Eurovision ballots. This means that, instead of assigning a score to every song in the rate, you will instead rank your top forty songs and arrange them in a ballot, which you will then send to me by PM.

Your top 40 will be grouped in groups of 4, and each group will get a set number of points. Your top 4 will get 12 points each, the next 4 will get 10 points each, the next 4 will get 8 points each, and then each successive group of 4 will get 7, 6, 5, 4, 3, 2 and 1 each.

What happens to the rest of the songs?

They all get a zero from you.

How will results be revealed?

They will be revealed ballot by ballot. I will literally just take your PM to me and post it in the thread during the results, and I will repeat this with each voter. After I post each ballot I will update the leaderboard, so you'll see songs move up and down until we get to the final leaderboard, which will crown our winner.​
 
Last edited:
Wow that's a lot of songs. Also puts into perspective what a flop rate host I am fff

Also, there's been an Eurovision 00s 'rate' of sorts completed very recently - does the winner of that one ("Die for You" by Antique) also qualify to appear here?

I've been told that the 'justice' type rates aren't included so I've remained with the same criteria as the previous rates. That's why those are omitted.

@Maki if you are planning on voting, do you think you could compile a YouTube playlist at all?
 
I've been told that the 'justice' type rates aren't included so I've remained with the same criteria as the previous rates. That's why those are omitted.

@Maki if you are planning on voting, do you think you could compile a YouTube playlist at all?
Ah right, got it! And yes I do plan on making a YouTube playlist for this, though all the links in the song list leading to blank/blocked pages will make it more tricky.
 
songs.jpg


After School - Flashback // After School discography = @vague
Allie X - Girl Of The Year // Allie X = @SophiaSophia
Bat For Lashes - Daniel // 00s Indie Pop Rate = @soratami
BESS - Ram pam pam // Eurovizh Alt-Song Contest 2022 = @WowWowWowWow
Billie Eilish - Happier Than Ever // Big Pop Girls 2021 = @aux
BoA - Valenti // BoA discography, part 1 = @Crisp X
Britney Spears - Gimme More // Britney Spears = @Holly Something
Chanel - SloMo // Popjustice 12 Points Eurovision 2022 = @stevo_1988
Charli XCX - Good Ones // 2021 PJ Chart Rate = @BubblegumBoy
Charli XCX - Track 10 // Charli XCX = @Petty Mayonnaise & @2014
Christina Aguilera - Fighter // Christina Aguilera discography = @BEST FICTION
Clara Luciana - La Grenade // La Musique Française Moderne: Les Chanteurs/Compositeurs = @berserkboi
COY - Promises // PJSC Winners Rate = @imaduck & @soratami
Crystal Kay - Kirakuni // The J-R&B Divas Rate! = @RUNAWAY
Dollar - Hand Held In Black & White // Dollar Singles Rate 1978-1988 = @simes1970
DOUBLE - Shake // The J-R&B Divas Rate! = @RUNAWAY
Duran Duran - Ordinary World // Duran Duran UK Singles Rate = @simes1970
Elena Tsagrinou - El Diablo // Popjustice 12 Points Eurovision 2021 = @stevo_1988
ENHYPEN - Drunk Dazed // K-Pop Boys 2021 = @Glitterizer
Erika Vikman - Syntisten pöytä // PJ Song Contests Winners Rumble 2020 = @Doodvid
Eyedi - Caffeine // City Pop = @thommyh & @codecat
f(x) - 4 Walls // f(x) discography = @eccentricsimply
Five Star - The Slightest Touch (Shep Pettibone 7" Mix) // Five Star 1983-1991 = @simes1970
Foxes - Body Talk // UK Ladies Not #1s of 2010s = @saviodxl
Foxes - Sister Ray // Foxes Discography Rate = @2014
Frida - I Know There's Something Going On // 80s/'90s Lost Classics Rate = @berserkboi
Girls Aloud - Sexy! No No No... // Girls Aloud = @Physical
Girls Aloud - Something Kinda Ooooh // PJ Twenty Quid Rate: Part One = @Lost In Japan.
Girls Aloud - Something New // UK Ladies Not #1s of 2010s = @saviodxl
Haim - Now I'm In It // Haim discography = @2014
iamamiwhoami - y // The iamamiwhoami Rate = @eatyourself & @Glitterizer
Infernal - From Paris to Berlin // Rate Danes = @WowWowWowWow
IZ*ONE - La Vie En Rose // IZ*ONE Discography = @eatyourself
Jana Burčeska - Dance Alone // Popjustice Again 2021 = @WowWowWowWow
Janelle Monae - Cold War // The Janelle Monae Rate = @BubblegumBoy
Jazmine Sullivan - Lost One // Jazmine Sullivan discography = @RainOnFire
Jenny Berggren - Let Your Heart Be Mine // PopJustice Second Chances: Eurovision Edition = @WowWowWowWow
Julie Bergan - One Touch // PJSC Veto - Part 2 = @WoW73
Katy Perry - Never Really Over // Katy Perry discography = @swim
Kylie Minogue - Tightrope // Kylie Minogue B-Sides and Rarities = @P'NutButter
Lady Gaga - Marry the Night // BPG Classique 2011 = @RJF & @Laura Vanderbooben
Ladyhawke - Magic // A Kiwi Versus Rate = @Phonetics Girl
Liberty X - Just A Little // Mixed Pop Groups & Duos = @Doodvid & @Ezz
Linkin Park - Breaking The Habit // The Nu Metal Rate = @DJHazey
Little Mix - Sweet Melody // Little Mix Discography Rate = @RainOnFire
LOVELYZ - Destiny // LOVELYZ Discography rate = @Attis
M.O. - Who Do You Think Of? // M.O. discography = @boombazookajoe
Madness - It Must Be Love // Madness UK Singles Rate = @simes1970
Miley Cyrus - Midnight Sky // Miley Cyrus discography, part 2 = @Music Is Death
Miss A - Hush // Miss A = @Rem
Mitski - Your Best American Girl // Mitski = @fatyoshi
Muna - Number One Fan // Quirky Pop Girls: Sophomore (B) = @soratami
Orchestral Manoeuvres in the Dark - Souvenir // OMD UK Singles Rate = @simes1970
Paloma Faith - Only Love Can Hurt Like This // The Paloma Faith Rate = @BubblegumBoy
Parade of Planets - Où est ton amour? // PJSC Winners Rumble 2021 = @Doodvid & @berserkboi
Paradis - Toi Et Moi // La Musique Française Moderne: Les Hommes = @berserkboi
Park Ji Yoon - Coming of Age Ceremony // First Gen Female Soloists = @Ana Raquel
Pixie Lott - Boys and Girls // Pixie Lott discography = @saviodxl
Precious - Rewind // Flop Girlbands = @Remorque
Rammstein - Du Hast // The Nu Metal Rate = @DJHazey
S Club 7 - Don't Stop Moving // S Club 7 = @j267
Shakespeare Sisters - Hello (Turn Your Radio On) // The Shakespeare Sisters Rate = @VivaForever
Shura - Religion (You Can Lay Your Hands On Me) // 20BiTeen = @Trouble in Paradise & @Cutlery
Sugababes - Easy // Song Title Battle = @jtm
T-ARA - Sugar Free // T-ARA = @GeiPanda
The Beatles - Eleanor Rigby // The Beatles = @Ironheade & @ohnostalgia & @WowWowWowWow
The Saturdays - All Fired Up // The Saturdays 2020 Re-rate = @DJHazey
The xx - On Hold // The xx = @klow
Tomorrow x Together - Ghosting // K-Pop Boys 2020 = @Glitterizer
TWICE - Fancy // TWICE = @aux
TWICE - I Can't Stop Me // K-Pop Song of the Year 2020 = @Slice of Life
TWICE - Likey // 3rd Gen Girls: The Debut = @Serg.
Whitney Houston - I Wanna Dance With Somebody (Who Loves Me) // Whitney Houston singles = @londonrain
WJSN - Save Me, Save You // WJSN Discography rate = @junglefish
WJSN - Unnatural // KSOTY 2021 = @Slice of Life
Yeah Yeah Yeahs - Heads Will Roll // 00s Indie Rock Rate = @soratami

After School - Flashback
Allie X - Girl Of The Year
Bat For Lashes - Daniel
BESS - Ram pam pam
Billie Eilish - Happier Than Ever
BoA - Valenti
Britney Spears - Gimme More
Chanel - SloMo
Charli XCX - Good Ones
Charli XCX - Track 10
Christina Aguilera - Fighter
Clara Luciana - La Grenade
COY - Promises
Crystal Kay - Kirakuni
Dollar - Hand Held In Black & White
DOUBLE - Shake
Duran Duran - Ordinary World
Elena Tsagrinou - El Diablo
ENHYPEN - Drunk Dazed
Erika Vikman - Syntisten pöytä
Eyedi - Caffeine
f(x) - 4 Walls
Five Star - The Slightest Touch (Shep Pettibone 7" Mix)
Foxes - Body Talk
Foxes - Sister Ray
Frida - I Know There's Something Going On
Girls Aloud - Sexy! No No No...
Girls Aloud - Something Kinda Oooh!
Girls Aloud - Something New
Haim - Now I'm In It
iamamiwhoami - y
Infernal - From Paris to Berlin
IZ*ONE - La Vie En Rose
Jana Burčeska - Dance Alone
Janelle Monae - Cold War
Jazmine Sullivan - Lost One
Jenny Berggren - Let Your Heart Be Mine
Julie Bergan - One Touch
Katy Perry - Never Really Over
Kylie Minogue - Tightrope
Lady Gaga - Marry the Night
Ladyhawke - Magic
Liberty - Just A Little
Linkin Park - Breaking The Habit
Little Mix - Sweet Melody
LOVELYZ - Destiny
M.O. - Who Do You Think Of?
Madness - It Must Be Love
Miley Cyrus - Midnight Sky
Miss A - Hush
Mitski - Your Best American Girl
Muna - Number One Fan
Orchestral Manoeuvres in the Dark - Souvenir
Paloma Faith - Only Love Can Hurt Like This
Parade of Planets - Où est ton amour?
Paradis - Toi Et Moi
Park Ji Yoon - Coming of Age Ceremony
Pixie Lott - Boys and Girls
Precious - Rewind
Rammstein - Du Hast
S Club 7 - Don't Stop Moving
Shakespeare Sisters - Hello (Turn Your Radio On)
Shura - Religion (You Can Lay Your Hands On Me)
Sugababes - Easy
T-ARA - Sugar Free
The Beatles - Eleanor Rigby
The Saturdays - All Fired Up
The xx - On Hold
Tomorrow x Together - Ghosting
TWICE - Fancy
TWICE - I Can't Stop Me
TWICE - Likey
Whitney Houston - I Wanna Dance With Somebody (Who Loves Me)
WJSN - Save Me, Save You
WJSN - Unnatural
Yeah Yeah Yeahs - Heads Will Roll

Spotify Playlist:



(Missing: Jenny Berggren - Let Your Heart Be Mine)

YouTube Playlist:

#soon​

Hi, it’s probably only available in Denmark so adding it to the playlist won’t make a difference for many voters, but just in case:
 
Support excellence





...and I guess I should mention my third winner as well, even though I only gave it a 7 at the time I'm not sure I'll actually vote for it here ff



I love that a lot of songs that did very well in the Quirky Pop rates despite not winning are here too (Girl of the Year, Good Ones, Body Talk, Sister Ray, Cold War, Magic and religion (u can lay your hands on me)). I will definitely be supporting all of these.
 
Ooooo yeah excited for this! Everyone please support one of the reasons Flowers is experiencing all this success:

This winning really was such a moment.

Am curious about the time period for the winners here?
EDIT: Oh wait, FROOT isn't here cause it was in a previous winner's rate. Duh.
Also, you want me to choose a favorite between four of the best pop songs of the past 25 years?
 
Top