The more the merrier, you've got until January 12th! Remember you have one 11 for contestants and another for judges.
**The X Factor Rate: JUDGES' WINNER **
- Thread starter AmbivalentToBritney
- Start date
D
Deleted member 3416
Although I have a question @AmbivalentToBritney, are we judging the contestants on just their time on the show? For example, Diana Vickers would have a different score from me based on her time on the show and based on her career after.
It's not just contestants we're rating ...
Up to you, though most people so far have rated solely on their time on the show.
D
Deleted member 3416
Is it bad that the majority of my scores have been quite low so far? I feel like a hater.
You should see some of the scores I've had sent in!
Judging on vocal ability only, I think Sam Bailey would sing her off the roof.
D
Deleted member 3416
If anyone marks Sam Bailey above Alexandra Burke then they need to re-evaluate themselves. One of them has the true X Factor, let's be real.
Is it too late now to say sorry?
OK why are you all rating Sophie Habibis so high? She did absolutely nothing on the show.
Teenage Dream? Let's be (Miss) Frank, one amazing performance is more than 60% of these contestants managed in their entire runs on the show...
I stanned Rebecca on the show BUT it has since come to my attention that Rebecca Ferguson and "in tune" are infrequent partners, amazing tone or not... I've scored her according to how much I rooted for her during that series but she would lose marks based on her post-show output (unpopular pop opinion alert)...
Johnny Robinson
I can't remember who that is ... will google him..
You're in for a treat.
Yup, Dannii.
Dannii is the easiest 11 I've ever given in a rate.
She was absolutely tragic the last seasons in Australia and Britain.