Threads Moved to Pop & Justice

ohnostalgia · Sep 6, 2020

Aldous Harding
Alice Chater
Alice Merton
Alison Ponthisr
Alvvays
Amy Shark
Ana Straker
Ari Lennox
Arlo Parks
Ashe
Ashnikko
Baby Queen
Banoffee
beabadoobee
Bella Poarch
BENEE
Betta Lemme
blackbear
Blanche
Bronze AVERY
bülow
Call Me Loop
Carly Hanson
Celeste
Chanel Tres
Chappell Roan
Charlotte Lawrence
Chelsea Jade
CMAT
COBRAH
Conan Gray
CXLOE
Cub Sport
CuteBad
Cyn
Doechii
Dorian Electra
Dotter
ELIO
Emotional Oranges
Ethel Cain
Fancy Hagood
Finneas
FLO
G Flip
Girl In Red
Grace Davies
Gracie Abrams
GRACEY
Goldilox
Hatchie
Holiday Sidewinder
Holly Humberstone
ILIRA
Isaac Dunbar
JACKIE EXTREME
Jade Bird
Jensen McRae
joan
Joy Crookes
Julia Jacklin
Julie Bergan
Julien Baker
Kamille
Kelly Lee Owens
Kelsey Liu
Kota Banks
Kiana Ledé
L Devine
Lolo Zuwaï
Loote
Lous and the Yakuza
Lucy Davis
Lydia Ainsworth
Mae Muller
Magdalena Bay
Maisie Peters
Mariah the Scientist
Matty Noyes
Men I Trust
Miya Folick
MorMor
Moses Sumney
Muni Long
Namasenda
Nicole Dollengager
Nilüfer Yanya
No Rome
Now, Now
Okay Kaya
Oklou
Olivia Rodrigo
Olivia O’Brien
Omar Apollo
Orkid
Pink Sweat$
pinkpantheress
Pure Shores
PWR BTTM
Rag’n’Bone Man
Raveena
Rayvn Lenae
Rico Nasty
Ruel
Samia
Sarah Klang
Sasha Sloan
SG Lewis
Shy Martin
Shygirl
Silver Sphere
Sir Babygirl
Skott
Snail Mail
So Below
Soccer Mommy
Sofia de la Torre
Sudan Archives
Tash Sultana
Tate McRae
Tayla Parx
That Kid
The Japanese Breakfast
The Weather Station
U.S. Girls
VanJess
Wet Leg
Winona Oak
yeule
Yola
Yung Baby Tate
Yungblud

+HipsterJustice

Last updated: January 13, 2023

ohnostalgia · Sep 6, 2020

I chose these threads based on page count plus a sense of their popularity in Charts & Rates. Charts & Rates has both monthly charts and song contests that spotlight new music.

I've only reviewed threads with a last reply date in August 2020, so the list should keep growing. And I am always open to suggestions for threads to move.

If a thread owner finds they are getting less engagement in P&J than here, I can move the thread back on their request.

Island · Sep 6, 2020

Possibly move the L Devine thread too?

ohnostalgia · Sep 6, 2020

Island said:
Possibly move the L Devine thread too?

Done!

mindtrappa · Sep 6, 2020

I would suggest moving (or at least reviewing)

Shygirl (hehe)
Yungblud
Finneas
Ashnikko
Channel Tres
Rico Nasty
That Kid

These are all artists who have at least a full length project out (or coming out) and have been receiving decent buzz online. If Slayyyter is in the main forum, there's no reason That Kid, for example, shouldn't be as well, etc.

I'd also suggest looking into pinning this subform inside Pop & Justice so it's more readily available to users? I'm not sure if it's possible with this forum software, but I think a move like that could promote more activity.

ohnostalgia · Sep 6, 2020

mindtrappa said:
I'd also suggest looking into pinning this subform inside Pop & Justice so it's more readily available to users? I'm not sure if it's possible with this forum software, but I think a move like that could promote more activity.

I don't think we can pin sub-forums inside other sub-forums right now.

ohnostalgia · Sep 6, 2020

@mindtrappa do you have a link to That Kid? The search function makes it impossible to find. I have moved all your other suggestions to P&J.

mindtrappa · Sep 6, 2020

ohnostalgia said:
@mindtrappa do you have a link to That Kid? The search function makes it impossible to find. I have moved all your other suggestions to P&J.

Here it is!

and thank you!

ohnostalgia · Sep 6, 2020

mindtrappa said:
Here it is!

and thank you!

Hopefully that will help their new campaigns get discussion.

2014 · Sep 6, 2020

Maybe move Yola too!! Not just because i created her thread but she did bag some Grammy noms too! Great idea though, thanks @ohnostalgia x

ohnostalgia · Sep 6, 2020

2014 said:
Maybe move Yola too!! Not just because i created her thread but she did bag some Grammy noms too! Great idea though, thanks @ohnostalgia x

I was debating Yola. With this extra push I'll move her.

swim · Sep 7, 2020

I'm not entirely sure this is going to actually benefit any of the moved artists ddd but while I'm here I'd move Call Me Loop too

4Roses · Sep 7, 2020

bülow and Gia Woods deserve a move teebs.

ohnostalgia · Sep 7, 2020

Lost Boy said:
I'm not entirely sure this is going to actually benefit any of the moved artists ddd but while I'm here I'd move Call Me Loop too

They can always come back. That’s why I’m keeping the list.

Also done.

Jwentz · Nov 17, 2020

Lost Boy said:
I'm not entirely sure this is going to actually benefit any of the moved artists

This is my thought, an artist like Hatchie is just going to slide far down the pages of P&J. This subform feels kinda lacking when buzzier small acts are taken out of it.

ohnostalgia · Nov 17, 2020

Jwentz said:
This is my thought, an artist like Hatchie is just going to slide far down the pages of P&J. This subform feels kinda lacking when buzzier small acts are taken out of it.

And keeping small buzzy acts here can move brand new artist threads down quickly. Hatchie is an established act with 7 pages of discussion and is no longer on her first release.

The solution we actually want to implement is not possible under the current infrastructure. The idea would be to have a subforum within the P&J forum.

Jwentz · Nov 17, 2020

ohnostalgia said:
And keeping small buzzy acts here can move brand new artist threads down quickly. Hatchie is an established act with 7 pages of discussion and is no longer on her first release

It also means the first page of this subform goes back a full week, so I guess I wonder what the pro is here?

ohnostalgia · Nov 17, 2020

Jwentz said:
It also means the first page of this subform goes back a full week, so I guess I wonder what the pro is here?

I don’t see why this subforum needs to be fast moving. There is a small dedicated group of posters in this subforum and everyone else ignores it.

But the pro is that a random forum user who only posts in P&J has the potential to see the artist thread on the first few pages and find a new discovery.

Jwentz · Nov 17, 2020

ohnostalgia said:
I don’t see why this subforum needs to be fast moving. There is a small dedicated group of posters in this subforum and everyone else ignores it.

But the pro is that a random forum user who only posts in P&J has the potential to see the artist thread on the first few pages and find a new discovery.

I don’t think it ever did move fast though. Generally all the threads I’d come here for hovered in the first few pages and are now inactive. Just my thoughts on the changes.

2014 · Nov 22, 2020

Moved VanJess after Vas asked - have edited the first post! x