X Factor Celebrity/X Factor All Stars 2019

M

Mike

I think it's since come out that she never taught the lead singer of Bullet For My Valentine.

Not that it mattered, as I suspect at least two people on that panel - perhaps even all four - wouldn't have had a clue who she was talking about anyway.
 
Babylon

Babylon

JENNEH to win.

Just because she’s a bit iconic.

I do actually think she’d be good with a bit of vocal training.
 
T

thequinntessential

DMDR said:
I gave it a shot again this year and enjoyed the initial 'audition' stage and then jumped ship after the first live show. Simon himself is damaging it, people are tired of the manipulations and he doesn't seem to recognise that.

Although I haven't been watching I still follow this thread and he basically pressured Nicole into giving away her act's golden buzzer to one of his, saved Martin over talent I think a couple of times, refused to vote when they made a deal out of deadlock being gone and then saved Vinnie over someone half talented.

Simon has become the toxic ingredient in regards to X Factor, I honestly think if he stepped down as a judge and didn't even have input as a producer then the show would be tonnes better.
Click to expand...

When he left for the US X-Factor (with Cheryl... so much for that) and Dannii left and it became Gary - Tulisa - Kelly then Nicole - Louis, it was such a strong panel and the show maintained strong ratings/popularity without Simon. Simon seems so think all his shows need him, when nowadays, I actually would say the opposite and in fact his continuing to be there is probably what's killing it.
 
sugababesoverloaded

sugababesoverloaded

Axe this show already . It was only good when Dannii, Louis , Cheryl , and Simon were on it . No panel has ever come close , but the format doesn’t work anymore now . Singing shows are tired !
 
bonnieetclyde

bonnieetclyde

I think it would only work if each contestant got to write/perform their own songs each week. Then the public get to vote for the best song.

Each week we can see the process of how they wrote the song. They can bring in popular songwriters each week to work with the contestants. You can still have 'theme' weeks if you want - ballad week, banger week, alternative week or whatever.

Then by the time the show ends, whoever wins already has an album of original material ready to release and they can capitalise on that by releasing the album right after winning the show.
 
sugababesoverloaded

sugababesoverloaded

Not sure that would work . Ideally it would be nice , and would be so fresh . But it wouldn’t happen as the producers would want them to perform what they want. As well as the label / station will want to own 100% of the material written by the contestants . Which a lot of the contestants would not allow that .
 
bonnieetclyde

bonnieetclyde

Galaxy_star said:
Not sure that would work . Ideally it would be nice , and would be so fresh . But it wouldn’t happen as the producers would want them to perform what they want. As well as the label / station will want to own 100% of the material written by the contestants . Which a lot of the contestants would not allow that .
Click to expand...

Just trying to think outside the box. It was certainly refreshing this year to have Megan singing her own material. Makes for a much better show than just hearing the same cover songs over and over with flamboyant production.
 
sugababesoverloaded

sugababesoverloaded

bonnieetclyde said:
Just trying to think outside the box. It was certainly refreshing this year to have Megan singing her own material. Makes for a much better show than just hearing the same cover songs over and over with flamboyant production.
Click to expand...
No I agree with you . Sadly these shows are just overdone . I always thought they should retire it for 5-10 years and bring it back .
 
kermit_the_frog

kermit_the_frog

thequinntessential said:
When he left for the US X-Factor (with Cheryl... so much for that) and Dannii left and it became Gary - Tulisa - Kelly then Nicole - Louis, it was such a strong panel and the show maintained strong ratings/popularity without Simon. Simon seems so think all his shows need him, when nowadays, I actually would say the opposite and in fact his continuing to be there is probably what's killing it.
Click to expand...

That year (ignoring the Alexandra/JLS pinnacle which just can't be disputed) is my favourite series - Little Mix, Misha B, Marcus Collins and Amelia Lily all delivered at least one great song following the show... Simon Cowell could never...
 
Alenko

Alenko

he/him/his
bonnieetclyde said:
I think it would only work if each contestant got to write/perform their own songs each week. Then the public get to vote for the best song.

Each week we can see the process of how they wrote the song. They can bring in popular songwriters each week to work with the contestants. You can still have 'theme' weeks if you want - ballad week, banger week, alternative week or whatever.

Then by the time the show ends, whoever wins already has an album of original material ready to release and they can capitalise on that by releasing the album right after winning the show.
Click to expand...

I mean that was pretty much Rak-Su and then no album came out of it
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Top