X Factor List: Contestant Rank!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Rank the 2010 finalists based on their first live performance.
Here's mine:

BEST
Aiden
Rebecca
TreyC
Tesco Mary
Paije
Katie
Cher
Nicolo
Belle Amie
FYD
One Direction
John
Matt
Wagner
Diva Fever
>
>
Storm
WORST
 
Tesco Mary
Aiden
TrayC

Cher
Nicolo
Belle Amie
Katie
Rebecca
One Direction
Matt

Wagner
Diva Fever
FYD
Storm
John
Paije
 
J

JadeFan

TreyC / Aiden / Mary

all the rest

Katie Weasel
Wand Erection
 
Treyc
Aiden
Mary
Matt
Rebecca
FYD
Paije
Katie
John
Wagner
Storm
Cher
Nicolo
One Direction
Belle Amie
Diva Fever
 
I've probably got some of their names mixed up but:

Matt
TreyC
Mary
Aiden

Belle Amie
John
Paije

Wagner
FYD
Storm
Diva Fever

One Direction

Cher
Nicolo
Katie


Who is Rebecca? She's the only one i can't recall...
 
Best to worst

Mary
Matt
Treyc
Rebecca
Nicolo
Katie
Cher
John
FYD
Aiden
1 Direction
Storm
Bell Amie
Paije
Wagner
Diva Fever


I think John and Belle Amie will go
 
BEST
1 Treyc
2 Mary
quality gap
3 Rebecca
4 Aiden
5 Paije
6 Matt
quality gap
7 Nicolo
8 One Direction
9 Belle Amie
quality gap
10 John
11 Cher
quality gap
12 Diva Fever
13 FYD
quality chasm
14 Wagner
15 Storm
crossing over the edge of the world
16 Katie
 
MarkB said:
BEST
1 Treyc
2 Mary
quality gap
3 Rebecca
4 Aiden
5 Paije
6 Matt
quality gap
7 Nicolo
8 One Direction
9 Belle Amie
quality gap
10 John
11 Cher
quality gap
12 Diva Fever
13 FYD
quality chasm
14 Wagner
15 Storm
crossing over the edge of the world
16 Katie


Get a grip, Katie's performance tonight was one of the best. I'm all for people trying to be objective, but at least try to be reasonable about these things.
 
^ Nope. The song was too big for her. The styling was absurd. It was the embodiment of everything that is wrong with her. The only good thing I can say is she actually managed to get through the whole bloody thing. Unfortunately.

I should say that that list is very different from what it would have been a few hours ago, so it's not that I'm sticking to preconceived ideas.
 
tOMMYp3 said:
MarkB said:
BEST
1 Treyc
2 Mary
quality gap
3 Rebecca
4 Aiden
5 Paije
6 Matt
quality gap
7 Nicolo
8 One Direction
9 Belle Amie
quality gap
10 John
11 Cher
quality gap
12 Diva Fever
13 FYD
quality chasm
14 Wagner
15 Storm
crossing over the edge of the world
16 Katie


Get a grip, Katie's performance tonight was one of the best. I'm all for people trying to be objective, but at least try to be reasonable about these things.

Everyone is entitled to their own opinion.
 
LIKE

Aiden
Matt
Cher
Rebecca
Paije
Mary
Treyc
FYD
Nicolo
Belle Amie

DISLIKE

Katie
One Direction
Storm
John
Diva Fever
Wagner
 
I'm going to rank these according to the groups.
No.1 Boy - Aiden I ain't gonna lie,before his performance I thought he'd slip under the radar but boy did he impress.
No.1 Girl - Rebecca Exactly the same opinion as above.
No. 1 Group - Belle Amie Purely because they've the best chemistry.
No.1 Over 28's - Mary A powerhouse of a performance.

No.2 Boy - Paije Was impressed with his interpration of 'Killing Me Softly'
No. 2 Girl - Cher Unique
No. 2 Group One Direction Same opinion as Paije's
No.2 Over 28's Wagner Very entertaing.

No.3 Boy - Matt He has an amazing voice but I think the song choice let him down slighlty.
No. 3 Girl Treyc Same as Mary's performance.
No.3 Group Diva Fever V. Entertaing
No. 3 Over 28's John Bad song choice
All the rest were below average
 
From today's live show, my ranking would be...

Best
1 Aiden
2 Mary
3 Cher

and the Rest
4 Treyc
5 Paije
6 FYD
7 Rebecca
8 Matt
9 1 Direction
10 John
11 Nicolo
12 Belle Amie
13 Katie
14 Storm
15 Diva Fever
16 Wagner
 
I

itzkk96

Based on tonight's show

BEST
Aiden
TreyC
Mary
Cher
Paije
Diva Fever (entertaining)

OKAY
Nicolo
Rebecca
Matt
FYD

The rest of them....
 
J

JadeFan

DANNII WIN-OGUE
Aiden
Mary
TreyC

CHERYL COOL
Paije
Matt
Diva Fever
Cher

SIMON OK-OWELL
FYD
John
Storm
Rebecca

BOO-UIS WALSH
Wagner
One Direction
Belle Amie
Nicolo
Katie
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top